| Home |
| Search |
| Today's Posts |
|
#1
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.programming
|
|||
|
|||
Pose questions to Microsoft when an answer is not forthcoming in g
I have a problem that does not seem to be attracting an answer in the group
discussions from MVP's or others. Why can't there be a "refer question to Microsoft" option/button somewhere for when this happens? Or an option to refer to a specific MVP who may have more contacts and knowledge of individuals who may have an answer? See discussion "VBA Code stops randomly" and note that the 1st time I submitted this questin i got no replies, but now I'm mostly getting others who have the same proble, but no suggestion as to cause or fix! thanx BAC ---------------- This post is a suggestion for Microsoft, and Microsoft responds to the suggestions with the most votes. To vote for this suggestion, click the "I Agree" button in the message pane. If you do not see the button, follow this link to open the suggestion in the Microsoft Web-based Newsreader and then click "I Agree" in the message pane. http://www.microsoft.com/office/comm...el.programming |
|
#3
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.programming
|
|||
|
|||
|
Pose questions to Microsoft when an answer is not forthcoming in g
the reason is that Microsoft doesn't offer free support. You can contact
microsoft and open a support incident and pay for support. If it turns out that the cause is a bug in the product, then you will not have to pay. the reaons you probably aren't getting support is that the cause is more than likely something to do with your code construction and not a known flaw in excel. for instance, this statement seems problematic: In the middle of the Excel portion of the VBA (the calling Access file has been closed) If the code is in Access, then if you close the file, it seems natural the code would halt. - but you said it worked in earlier versions, so if absolutely no changes have been made, it isn't obvious what would cause this, but support for automation has not changed in Office XP. Also, I suspect that even Microsoft would be hesitant to try to debug a user built application that automates between two products just because of the complexity (unless you describe a known situation - not all of these are documented in the knowledge base). Also, you have described your code a halting (which is one type of problem). Yet later you refer to an error message, but never say what the error message is. Experiencing an error is a much differnt situation than code halting with no indication of why. -- Regards, Tom Ogilvy "BAC" wrote: I have a problem that does not seem to be attracting an answer in the group discussions from MVP's or others. Why can't there be a "refer question to Microsoft" option/button somewhere for when this happens? Or an option to refer to a specific MVP who may have more contacts and knowledge of individuals who may have an answer? See discussion "VBA Code stops randomly" and note that the 1st time I submitted this questin i got no replies, but now I'm mostly getting others who have the same proble, but no suggestion as to cause or fix! thanx BAC ---------------- This post is a suggestion for Microsoft, and Microsoft responds to the suggestions with the most votes. To vote for this suggestion, click the "I Agree" button in the message pane. If you do not see the button, follow this link to open the suggestion in the Microsoft Web-based Newsreader and then click "I Agree" in the message pane. http://www.microsoft.com/office/comm...el.programming |
|
#4
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.programming
|
|||
|
|||
|
Pose questions to Microsoft when an answer is not forthcoming
Thanx Tom for your input, but 1st of all, apparently I am not the only one
having this problem (see the thread on "Let's try again: VBA Code stops randomly"); secondly, when the code halts a dialog box appears stating "Code execution has been interrupted" with "Continue", "End", "Debug" buttons. This may not technically "be an error", but it is "Not right". Selecting "Continue", or selecting "Debug" and then F5 will continue execution normally to the next randonm "Stop". These stops could be anywhere along the program path and do not always occur at the same point. For example in one run the program may stop at the call to a function or sub, then at the start of a loop, then at a field calculation. The next time it runs it may stop 10 times, but none of these stops at the same places as in the previous run. As for running code between applications, the KB has several examples of how to open Access from Excel and vice versa, calling specific macros/subs/functions. The current code begins in Access, then creates an Object reference to Excel, opens a specific Excel Workbook and initiates code within Excel, which pretty much begins by closing the Access database that just called it then proceeds to execute. The "Before Close" even in that Workbook then creates an object reference to Access, re-opens Access and initiates code in Access which Closes the Excel workbook, then imports one worksheet just created by the Excel subroutines. I've been using this type of switch between apps since Office 97, and never had this kind of "Code execution has been interupted" problem before. I have experienced this "Error" when I've put Break Points in my code for testing and then failed to remove them before saving. However, using the Shift + F9 "Clear all breakpoints" and recompiling has always fixed this, until now. So, if you should come up with any other ideas or thoughts on what may be causing this I'd appreciate hearing them. Thanks again.. BAC "Tom Ogilvy" wrote: the reason is that Microsoft doesn't offer free support. You can contact microsoft and open a support incident and pay for support. If it turns out that the cause is a bug in the product, then you will not have to pay. the reaons you probably aren't getting support is that the cause is more than likely something to do with your code construction and not a known flaw in excel. for instance, this statement seems problematic: In the middle of the Excel portion of the VBA (the calling Access file has been closed) If the code is in Access, then if you close the file, it seems natural the code would halt. - but you said it worked in earlier versions, so if absolutely no changes have been made, it isn't obvious what would cause this, but support for automation has not changed in Office XP. Also, I suspect that even Microsoft would be hesitant to try to debug a user built application that automates between two products just because of the complexity (unless you describe a known situation - not all of these are documented in the knowledge base). Also, you have described your code a halting (which is one type of problem). Yet later you refer to an error message, but never say what the error message is. Experiencing an error is a much differnt situation than code halting with no indication of why. -- Regards, Tom Ogilvy "BAC" wrote: I have a problem that does not seem to be attracting an answer in the group discussions from MVP's or others. Why can't there be a "refer question to Microsoft" option/button somewhere for when this happens? Or an option to refer to a specific MVP who may have more contacts and knowledge of individuals who may have an answer? See discussion "VBA Code stops randomly" and note that the 1st time I submitted this questin i got no replies, but now I'm mostly getting others who have the same proble, but no suggestion as to cause or fix! thanx BAC ---------------- This post is a suggestion for Microsoft, and Microsoft responds to the suggestions with the most votes. To vote for this suggestion, click the "I Agree" button in the message pane. If you do not see the button, follow this link to open the suggestion in the Microsoft Web-based Newsreader and then click "I Agree" in the message pane. http://www.microsoft.com/office/comm...el.programming |
|
#5
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.programming
|
|||
|
|||
|
Pose questions to Microsoft when an answer is not forthcoming
Thanx DO..
I understand the structure and philosophy of these discussion groups, but I was under the impression that they were sort of "monitored" by MS Subject Matter Experts and /or individuals who were on the development teams for Excel (in this case, bu the other apps in their DG's). Maybe that was in eons gone by! I'm not sure how much clearer I can be in describing my problem. My Excel VBA code stops at random spots and displays a dialog box that says "Code execution has been interrupted" Thanks again for your input .. "Don Guillett" wrote: This is not part of microsoft. It is a peer to peer forum where many of do pro bono work. Sometimes, MS lurks around in the bushes. If you can't find an answer here it's because you aren't explaining enough or you are expecting someone to do a free project. Try again with a good subject line and a full explanation. -- Don Guillett SalesAid Software "BAC" wrote in message ... I have a problem that does not seem to be attracting an answer in the group discussions from MVP's or others. Why can't there be a "refer question to Microsoft" option/button somewhere for when this happens? Or an option to refer to a specific MVP who may have more contacts and knowledge of individuals who may have an answer? See discussion "VBA Code stops randomly" and note that the 1st time I submitted this questin i got no replies, but now I'm mostly getting others who have the same proble, but no suggestion as to cause or fix! thanx BAC ---------------- This post is a suggestion for Microsoft, and Microsoft responds to the suggestions with the most votes. To vote for this suggestion, click the "I Agree" button in the message pane. If you do not see the button, follow this link to open the suggestion in the Microsoft Web-based Newsreader and then click "I Agree" in the message pane. http://www.microsoft.com/office/comm...el.programming |
|
#6
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.programming
|
|||
|
|||
|
Pose questions to Microsoft when an answer is not forthcoming
This can happen when VBA's internal code storage area get screwed up. The
best solution is to Export all code to text files, delete all modules and all code, then Import the text files. This will cause VBA to purge all its internal code storage areas and start with a clean slate. Rob Bovey has a excellent add-in that automates this whole process down to two or three mouse clicks. See http://www.appspro.com/Utilities/CodeCleaner.htm Rob's Code Cleaner is a "must have" add-in for any serious Excel development. -- Cordially, Chip Pearson Microsoft MVP - Excel Pearson Software Consulting, LLC www.cpearson.com (email address is on the web site) "BAC" wrote in message ... Thanx Tom for your input, but 1st of all, apparently I am not the only one having this problem (see the thread on "Let's try again: VBA Code stops randomly"); secondly, when the code halts a dialog box appears stating "Code execution has been interrupted" with "Continue", "End", "Debug" buttons. This may not technically "be an error", but it is "Not right". Selecting "Continue", or selecting "Debug" and then F5 will continue execution normally to the next randonm "Stop". These stops could be anywhere along the program path and do not always occur at the same point. For example in one run the program may stop at the call to a function or sub, then at the start of a loop, then at a field calculation. The next time it runs it may stop 10 times, but none of these stops at the same places as in the previous run. As for running code between applications, the KB has several examples of how to open Access from Excel and vice versa, calling specific macros/subs/functions. The current code begins in Access, then creates an Object reference to Excel, opens a specific Excel Workbook and initiates code within Excel, which pretty much begins by closing the Access database that just called it then proceeds to execute. The "Before Close" even in that Workbook then creates an object reference to Access, re-opens Access and initiates code in Access which Closes the Excel workbook, then imports one worksheet just created by the Excel subroutines. I've been using this type of switch between apps since Office 97, and never had this kind of "Code execution has been interupted" problem before. I have experienced this "Error" when I've put Break Points in my code for testing and then failed to remove them before saving. However, using the Shift + F9 "Clear all breakpoints" and recompiling has always fixed this, until now. So, if you should come up with any other ideas or thoughts on what may be causing this I'd appreciate hearing them. Thanks again.. BAC "Tom Ogilvy" wrote: the reason is that Microsoft doesn't offer free support. You can contact microsoft and open a support incident and pay for support. If it turns out that the cause is a bug in the product, then you will not have to pay. the reaons you probably aren't getting support is that the cause is more than likely something to do with your code construction and not a known flaw in excel. for instance, this statement seems problematic: In the middle of the Excel portion of the VBA (the calling Access file has been closed) If the code is in Access, then if you close the file, it seems natural the code would halt. - but you said it worked in earlier versions, so if absolutely no changes have been made, it isn't obvious what would cause this, but support for automation has not changed in Office XP. Also, I suspect that even Microsoft would be hesitant to try to debug a user built application that automates between two products just because of the complexity (unless you describe a known situation - not all of these are documented in the knowledge base). Also, you have described your code a halting (which is one type of problem). Yet later you refer to an error message, but never say what the error message is. Experiencing an error is a much differnt situation than code halting with no indication of why. -- Regards, Tom Ogilvy "BAC" wrote: I have a problem that does not seem to be attracting an answer in the group discussions from MVP's or others. Why can't there be a "refer question to Microsoft" option/button somewhere for when this happens? Or an option to refer to a specific MVP who may have more contacts and knowledge of individuals who may have an answer? See discussion "VBA Code stops randomly" and note that the 1st time I submitted this questin i got no replies, but now I'm mostly getting others who have the same proble, but no suggestion as to cause or fix! thanx BAC ---------------- This post is a suggestion for Microsoft, and Microsoft responds to the suggestions with the most votes. To vote for this suggestion, click the "I Agree" button in the message pane. If you do not see the button, follow this link to open the suggestion in the Microsoft Web-based Newsreader and then click "I Agree" in the message pane. http://www.microsoft.com/office/comm...el.programming |
|
#7
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.programming
|
|||
|
|||
|
Pose questions to Microsoft when an answer is not forthcoming
YAY Chip!
That worked! who'd a thunk? Thanx a lot and I'm going to copy your post to my earlier thread related to this issue so the others who posted they were having the same problem can apply tour solution... Thanx again! "Chip Pearson" wrote: This can happen when VBA's internal code storage area get screwed up. The best solution is to Export all code to text files, delete all modules and all code, then Import the text files. This will cause VBA to purge all its internal code storage areas and start with a clean slate. Rob Bovey has a excellent add-in that automates this whole process down to two or three mouse clicks. See http://www.appspro.com/Utilities/CodeCleaner.htm Rob's Code Cleaner is a "must have" add-in for any serious Excel development. -- Cordially, Chip Pearson Microsoft MVP - Excel Pearson Software Consulting, LLC www.cpearson.com (email address is on the web site) "BAC" wrote in message ... Thanx Tom for your input, but 1st of all, apparently I am not the only one having this problem (see the thread on "Let's try again: VBA Code stops randomly"); secondly, when the code halts a dialog box appears stating "Code execution has been interrupted" with "Continue", "End", "Debug" buttons. This may not technically "be an error", but it is "Not right". Selecting "Continue", or selecting "Debug" and then F5 will continue execution normally to the next randonm "Stop". These stops could be anywhere along the program path and do not always occur at the same point. For example in one run the program may stop at the call to a function or sub, then at the start of a loop, then at a field calculation. The next time it runs it may stop 10 times, but none of these stops at the same places as in the previous run. As for running code between applications, the KB has several examples of how to open Access from Excel and vice versa, calling specific macros/subs/functions. The current code begins in Access, then creates an Object reference to Excel, opens a specific Excel Workbook and initiates code within Excel, which pretty much begins by closing the Access database that just called it then proceeds to execute. The "Before Close" even in that Workbook then creates an object reference to Access, re-opens Access and initiates code in Access which Closes the Excel workbook, then imports one worksheet just created by the Excel subroutines. I've been using this type of switch between apps since Office 97, and never had this kind of "Code execution has been interupted" problem before. I have experienced this "Error" when I've put Break Points in my code for testing and then failed to remove them before saving. However, using the Shift + F9 "Clear all breakpoints" and recompiling has always fixed this, until now. So, if you should come up with any other ideas or thoughts on what may be causing this I'd appreciate hearing them. Thanks again.. BAC "Tom Ogilvy" wrote: the reason is that Microsoft doesn't offer free support. You can contact microsoft and open a support incident and pay for support. If it turns out that the cause is a bug in the product, then you will not have to pay. the reaons you probably aren't getting support is that the cause is more than likely something to do with your code construction and not a known flaw in excel. for instance, this statement seems problematic: In the middle of the Excel portion of the VBA (the calling Access file has been closed) If the code is in Access, then if you close the file, it seems natural the code would halt. - but you said it worked in earlier versions, so if absolutely no changes have been made, it isn't obvious what would cause this, but support for automation has not changed in Office XP. Also, I suspect that even Microsoft would be hesitant to try to debug a user built application that automates between two products just because of the complexity (unless you describe a known situation - not all of these are documented in the knowledge base). Also, you have described your code a halting (which is one type of problem). Yet later you refer to an error message, but never say what the error message is. Experiencing an error is a much differnt situation than code halting with no indication of why. -- Regards, Tom Ogilvy "BAC" wrote: I have a problem that does not seem to be attracting an answer in the group discussions from MVP's or others. Why can't there be a "refer question to Microsoft" option/button somewhere for when this happens? Or an option to refer to a specific MVP who may have more contacts and knowledge of individuals who may have an answer? See discussion "VBA Code stops randomly" and note that the 1st time I submitted this questin i got no replies, but now I'm mostly getting others who have the same proble, but no suggestion as to cause or fix! thanx BAC ---------------- This post is a suggestion for Microsoft, and Microsoft responds to the suggestions with the most votes. To vote for this suggestion, click the "I Agree" button in the message pane. If you do not see the button, follow this link to open the suggestion in the Microsoft Web-based Newsreader and then click "I Agree" in the message pane. http://www.microsoft.com/office/comm...el.programming |
|
#8
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.programming
|
|||
|
|||
|
Pose questions to Microsoft when an answer is not forthcoming
"Tom Ogilvy" wrote: the reason is that Microsoft doesn't offer free support. You can contact microsoft and open a support incident and pay for support. If it turns out that the cause is a bug in the product, then you will not have to pay. the reaons you probably aren't getting support is that the cause is more than likely something to do with your code construction and not a known flaw in excel. for instance, this statement seems problematic: In the middle of the Excel portion of the VBA (the calling Access file has been closed) If the code is in Access, then if you close the file, it seems natural the code would halt. - but you said it worked in earlier versions, so if absolutely no changes have been made, it isn't obvious what would cause this, but support for automation has not changed in Office XP. Also, I suspect that even Microsoft would be hesitant to try to debug a user built application that automates between two products just because of the complexity (unless you describe a known situation - not all of these are documented in the knowledge base). Also, you have described your code a halting (which is one type of problem). Yet later you refer to an error message, but never say what the error message is. Experiencing an error is a much differnt situation than code halting with no indication of why. -- Regards, Tom Ogilvy "BAC" wrote: I have a problem that does not seem to be attracting an answer in the group discussions from MVP's or others. Why can't there be a "refer question to Microsoft" option/button somewhere for when this happens? Or an option to refer to a specific MVP who may have more contacts and knowledge of individuals who may have an answer? See discussion "VBA Code stops randomly" and note that the 1st time I submitted this questin i got no replies, but now I'm mostly getting others who have the same proble, but no suggestion as to cause or fix! thanx BAC ---------------- This post is a suggestion for Microsoft, and Microsoft responds to the suggestions with the most votes. To vote for this suggestion, click the "I Agree" button in the message pane. If you do not see the button, follow this link to open the suggestion in the Microsoft Web-based Newsreader and then click "I Agree" in the message pane. http://www.microsoft.com/office/comm...el.programming |
|
#9
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.programming
|
|||
|
|||
|
Pose questions to Microsoft when an answer is not forthcoming
I downloaded Rob's tool (version 5.0) and it seems to have run without error
on my system. (I see the backup and export files in the directory) I even tried the manual export and import of the modules/forms/etc. However, I still experience the issue with the "Code Execution has been interrupted" popup. The only way I've found to get rid of this is to reboot my system. The problem is, after rebooting I able to run only a few different VBE scripts (most of which process large (100MB+) text files) before the problem comes back. It seems it's a memory usage problem, that the memory used doesn't get cleared when I'm done using the file. Is there a way to clear the memory without restarting the comp? FYI, I've got 3GB RAM and a Quad Processor. Any help is appriacted. "Chip Pearson" wrote: This can happen when VBA's internal code storage area get screwed up. The best solution is to Export all code to text files, delete all modules and all code, then Import the text files. This will cause VBA to purge all its internal code storage areas and start with a clean slate. Rob Bovey has a excellent add-in that automates this whole process down to two or three mouse clicks. See http://www.appspro.com/Utilities/CodeCleaner.htm Rob's Code Cleaner is a "must have" add-in for any serious Excel development. -- Cordially, Chip Pearson Microsoft MVP - Excel Pearson Software Consulting, LLC www.cpearson.com (email address is on the web site) "BAC" wrote in message ... Thanx Tom for your input, but 1st of all, apparently I am not the only one having this problem (see the thread on "Let's try again: VBA Code stops randomly"); secondly, when the code halts a dialog box appears stating "Code execution has been interrupted" with "Continue", "End", "Debug" buttons. This may not technically "be an error", but it is "Not right". Selecting "Continue", or selecting "Debug" and then F5 will continue execution normally to the next randonm "Stop". These stops could be anywhere along the program path and do not always occur at the same point. For example in one run the program may stop at the call to a function or sub, then at the start of a loop, then at a field calculation. The next time it runs it may stop 10 times, but none of these stops at the same places as in the previous run. As for running code between applications, the KB has several examples of how to open Access from Excel and vice versa, calling specific macros/subs/functions. The current code begins in Access, then creates an Object reference to Excel, opens a specific Excel Workbook and initiates code within Excel, which pretty much begins by closing the Access database that just called it then proceeds to execute. The "Before Close" even in that Workbook then creates an object reference to Access, re-opens Access and initiates code in Access which Closes the Excel workbook, then imports one worksheet just created by the Excel subroutines. I've been using this type of switch between apps since Office 97, and never had this kind of "Code execution has been interupted" problem before. I have experienced this "Error" when I've put Break Points in my code for testing and then failed to remove them before saving. However, using the Shift + F9 "Clear all breakpoints" and recompiling has always fixed this, until now. So, if you should come up with any other ideas or thoughts on what may be causing this I'd appreciate hearing them. Thanks again.. BAC "Tom Ogilvy" wrote: the reason is that Microsoft doesn't offer free support. You can contact microsoft and open a support incident and pay for support. If it turns out that the cause is a bug in the product, then you will not have to pay. the reaons you probably aren't getting support is that the cause is more than likely something to do with your code construction and not a known flaw in excel. for instance, this statement seems problematic: In the middle of the Excel portion of the VBA (the calling Access file has been closed) If the code is in Access, then if you close the file, it seems natural the code would halt. - but you said it worked in earlier versions, so if absolutely no changes have been made, it isn't obvious what would cause this, but support for automation has not changed in Office XP. Also, I suspect that even Microsoft would be hesitant to try to debug a user built application that automates between two products just because of the complexity (unless you describe a known situation - not all of these are documented in the knowledge base). Also, you have described your code a halting (which is one type of problem). Yet later you refer to an error message, but never say what the error message is. Experiencing an error is a much differnt situation than code halting with no indication of why. -- Regards, Tom Ogilvy "BAC" wrote: I have a problem that does not seem to be attracting an answer in the group discussions from MVP's or others. Why can't there be a "refer question to Microsoft" option/button somewhere for when this happens? Or an option to refer to a specific MVP who may have more contacts and knowledge of individuals who may have an answer? See discussion "VBA Code stops randomly" and note that the 1st time I submitted this questin i got no replies, but now I'm mostly getting others who have the same proble, but no suggestion as to cause or fix! thanx BAC ---------------- This post is a suggestion for Microsoft, and Microsoft responds to the suggestions with the most votes. To vote for this suggestion, click the "I Agree" button in the message pane. If you do not see the button, follow this link to open the suggestion in the Microsoft Web-based Newsreader and then click "I Agree" in the message pane. http://www.microsoft.com/office/comm...el.programming |
| Reply |
| Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
| Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads
|
||||
| Thread | Forum | |||
| Does any one ever answer questions on the Sharepoint DG? | Excel Discussion (Misc queries) | |||
| Vlookup? Questions about answer I got??? Help, please. | Excel Discussion (Misc queries) | |||
| View Questions and Answer to questions I created | Excel Discussion (Misc queries) | |||
| Help Needed: Please try to answer the following questions. | Excel Programming | |||
| 4 short answer questions | Excel Programming | |||
Linear Mode
