Although Dave has offered kind suggestions, my problem is not solved.
Hopefully this re-re-post ends up on the main list of this group (instead of
as part of the original posting as my first re-post did). If you scroll
down to the bottom you will see my description of the problem.

And the answer to Dave's suggestion is no, the data I mention is actually a
list of constants entered into the declarations section and so is lost along
with the code.

- - It sounds like the old version has the macro. And the "recovered"
version has
the data.

- - Can't you create a third workbook that takes the good things from each
of the
bad things?



"%P*Rr&^" wrote:

I'm reposting this message because it's a rather serious problem for me
and
although people have tried to help, nothing so far has worked (although I
have not yet tried OpenOffice). And also, it seems so weird! Have other
people run into this? The macro is actually quite large but ran
successfully (after saving and reloading) until the last finishing touches
which involved protecting the sheet. Unfortunately the only other saved
version does not include much of the data.

Help! I wrote a vba macro for Excel XP, ran it (and it ran without
problems), saved the spreadsheet, exited Excel and later reloaded the
spreadsheet - but now while loading the spreadsheet, Excel crashes! When
Excel "recovers" the spreadsheet it deletes the VBA code.

Deactivating the Macro doesn't help. Is there someway of retrieving the
code? There is a lot of data in there I do not want to re-enter.

Thanks in Advance,
Perry

--

Dave Peterson

I assume that you tried to open the "faulty" workbook
with "macros disabled"? That should allow you to recover
th ecode. If so, I'd suggest you create a new folder on
your desktop then drag each module from the IDE into the
folder - that's a Save and might save time in future.

Also, I'd go with Dave's suggestion. Open new workbook &
again, in the IDE just drag the modules into the new
workbook in Project Explorer.
Of course, both the above require the original workbook
to open first. So again, try it with security at High and
open with macros disabled.

Patrick Molloy
Microsoft Excel MVP

-----Original Message-----
Although Dave has offered kind suggestions, my problem
is not solved.
Hopefully this re-re-post ends up on the main list of
this group (instead of
as part of the original posting as my first re-post
did). If you scroll
down to the bottom you will see my description of the
problem.

And the answer to Dave's suggestion is no, the data I
mention is actually a
list of constants entered into the declarations section
and so is lost along
with the code.

- - It sounds like the old version has the macro. And
the "recovered"
version has
the data.

- - Can't you create a third workbook that takes the
good things from each
of the
bad things?



"%P*Rr&^" wrote:

I'm reposting this message because it's a rather
serious problem for me
and
although people have tried to help, nothing so far has
worked (although I
have not yet tried OpenOffice). And also, it seems so
weird! Have other
people run into this? The macro is actually quite
large but ran
successfully (after saving and reloading) until the
last finishing touches
which involved protecting the sheet. Unfortunately
the only other saved
version does not include much of the data.

Help! I wrote a vba macro for Excel XP, ran it (and
it ran without
problems), saved the spreadsheet, exited Excel and
later reloaded the
spreadsheet - but now while loading the spreadsheet,
Excel crashes! When
Excel "recovers" the spreadsheet it deletes the VBA
code.

Deactivating the Macro doesn't help. Is there someway
of retrieving the
code? There is a lot of data in there I do not want
to re-enter.

Thanks in Advance,
Perry

--

Dave Peterson



.