Hi

I am using the sharing facilty to enable multiple simultaneous editing
access to a workbook.

The problem that I want to solve is that the workbook always seems to open
in "thiswork.saved = false" mode i.e. the workbook always prompts the user
to save when closing even if no changes have been made.

Apart form using VB* (which is my curent workaround), is there a solution to
this?

Thanks

Tim

* the reason I want o avoid Vb is that I am tryiing to eliminate extra steps
and including VB would mean users get the "enable macros" screen each time
they open it - and outr IT Dept don't allow us to turn this off on a
permanent basis :)

Do you have any of these volatile functions in your workbook?

=AREAS()
=INDEX() *
=OFFSET()
=CELL()
=INDIRECT()
=ROWS()
=COLUMNS()
=NOW()
=TODAY()
=RAND()

* may not be volatile in all versions

These evaluate with each calculation. And cause excel to think your workbook
has changed.

And excel likes to recalculate workbooks created in earlier versions. Is this
the case in your situation?

======
And as a test, you may want to unshare the workbook (or a copy of the workbook)
to see if it's sharing that's causing the trouble.

Tim Childs wrote:

Hi

I am using the sharing facilty to enable multiple simultaneous editing
access to a workbook.

The problem that I want to solve is that the workbook always seems to open
in "thiswork.saved = false" mode i.e. the workbook always prompts the user
to save when closing even if no changes have been made.

Apart form using VB* (which is my curent workaround), is there a solution to
this?

Thanks

Tim

* the reason I want o avoid Vb is that I am tryiing to eliminate extra steps
and including VB would mean users get the "enable macros" screen each time
they open it - and outr IT Dept don't allow us to turn this off on a
permanent basis :)

--

Dave Peterson

Dave

Good to be in touch again - thanks

I am at home so cannot test the volatile functions etc but I believe it is
sharing that causes the problem because I did not have the "do you want to
save changes dialog box" when I made a copy of the the file and turned off
the sharing.

Any ideas?

Tim


"Dave Peterson" wrote in message
...
Do you have any of these volatile functions in your workbook?

=AREAS()
=INDEX() *
=OFFSET()
=CELL()
=INDIRECT()
=ROWS()
=COLUMNS()
=NOW()
=TODAY()
=RAND()

* may not be volatile in all versions

These evaluate with each calculation. And cause excel to think your
workbook
has changed.

And excel likes to recalculate workbooks created in earlier versions. Is
this
the case in your situation?

======
And as a test, you may want to unshare the workbook (or a copy of the
workbook)
to see if it's sharing that's causing the trouble.

Tim Childs wrote:

Hi

I am using the sharing facilty to enable multiple simultaneous editing
access to a workbook.

The problem that I want to solve is that the workbook always seems to
open
in "thiswork.saved = false" mode i.e. the workbook always prompts the
user
to save when closing even if no changes have been made.

Apart form using VB* (which is my curent workaround), is there a
solution to
this?

Thanks

Tim

* the reason I want o avoid Vb is that I am tryiing to eliminate extra
steps
and including VB would mean users get the "enable macros" screen each
time
they open it - and outr IT Dept don't allow us to turn this off on a
permanent basis :)

--

Dave Peterson

None that I didn't share <bg.

Tim Childs wrote:

Dave

Good to be in touch again - thanks

I am at home so cannot test the volatile functions etc but I believe it is
sharing that causes the problem because I did not have the "do you want to
save changes dialog box" when I made a copy of the the file and turned off
the sharing.

Any ideas?

Tim

"Dave Peterson" wrote in message
...
Do you have any of these volatile functions in your workbook?

=AREAS()
=INDEX() *
=OFFSET()
=CELL()
=INDIRECT()
=ROWS()
=COLUMNS()
=NOW()
=TODAY()
=RAND()

* may not be volatile in all versions

These evaluate with each calculation. And cause excel to think your
workbook
has changed.

And excel likes to recalculate workbooks created in earlier versions. Is
this
the case in your situation?

======
And as a test, you may want to unshare the workbook (or a copy of the
workbook)
to see if it's sharing that's causing the trouble.

Tim Childs wrote:

Hi

I am using the sharing facilty to enable multiple simultaneous editing
access to a workbook.

The problem that I want to solve is that the workbook always seems to
open
in "thiswork.saved = false" mode i.e. the workbook always prompts the
user
to save when closing even if no changes have been made.

Apart form using VB* (which is my curent workaround), is there a
solution to
this?

Thanks

Tim

* the reason I want o avoid Vb is that I am tryiing to eliminate extra
steps
and including VB would mean users get the "enable macros" screen each
time
they open it - and outr IT Dept don't allow us to turn this off on a
permanent basis :)

--

Dave Peterson

--

Dave Peterson

vg - not lost your snse of humour* :)
Tim

note spelling!

"Dave Peterson" wrote in message
...
None that I didn't share <bg.

Tim Childs wrote:

Dave

Good to be in touch again - thanks

I am at home so cannot test the volatile functions etc but I believe it
is
sharing that causes the problem because I did not have the "do you want
to
save changes dialog box" when I made a copy of the the file and turned
off
the sharing.

Any ideas?

Tim

"Dave Peterson" wrote in message
...
Do you have any of these volatile functions in your workbook?

=AREAS()
=INDEX() *
=OFFSET()
=CELL()
=INDIRECT()
=ROWS()
=COLUMNS()
=NOW()
=TODAY()
=RAND()

* may not be volatile in all versions

These evaluate with each calculation. And cause excel to think your
workbook
has changed.

And excel likes to recalculate workbooks created in earlier versions.
Is
this
the case in your situation?

======
And as a test, you may want to unshare the workbook (or a copy of the
workbook)
to see if it's sharing that's causing the trouble.

Tim Childs wrote:

Hi

I am using the sharing facilty to enable multiple simultaneous
editing
access to a workbook.

The problem that I want to solve is that the workbook always seems
to
open
in "thiswork.saved = false" mode i.e. the workbook always prompts
the
user
to save when closing even if no changes have been made.

Apart form using VB* (which is my curent workaround), is there a
solution to
this?

Thanks

Tim

* the reason I want o avoid Vb is that I am tryiing to eliminate
extra
steps
and including VB would mean users get the "enable macros" screen
each
time
they open it - and outr IT Dept don't allow us to turn this off on a
permanent basis :)

--

Dave Peterson

--

Dave Peterson

You mean snse or humo(u)r????

Oh, oh.

Tim Childs wrote:

vg - not lost your snse of humour* :)
Tim

note spelling!

"Dave Peterson" wrote in message
...
None that I didn't share <bg.

Tim Childs wrote:

Dave

Good to be in touch again - thanks

I am at home so cannot test the volatile functions etc but I believe it
is
sharing that causes the problem because I did not have the "do you want
to
save changes dialog box" when I made a copy of the the file and turned
off
the sharing.

Any ideas?

Tim

"Dave Peterson" wrote in message
...
Do you have any of these volatile functions in your workbook?

=AREAS()
=INDEX() *
=OFFSET()
=CELL()
=INDIRECT()
=ROWS()
=COLUMNS()
=NOW()
=TODAY()
=RAND()

* may not be volatile in all versions

These evaluate with each calculation. And cause excel to think your
workbook
has changed.

And excel likes to recalculate workbooks created in earlier versions.
Is
this
the case in your situation?

======
And as a test, you may want to unshare the workbook (or a copy of the
workbook)
to see if it's sharing that's causing the trouble.

Tim Childs wrote:

Hi

I am using the sharing facilty to enable multiple simultaneous
editing
access to a workbook.

The problem that I want to solve is that the workbook always seems
to
open
in "thiswork.saved = false" mode i.e. the workbook always prompts
the
user
to save when closing even if no changes have been made.

Apart form using VB* (which is my curent workaround), is there a
solution to
this?

Thanks

Tim

* the reason I want o avoid Vb is that I am tryiing to eliminate
extra
steps
and including VB would mean users get the "enable macros" screen
each
time
they open it - and outr IT Dept don't allow us to turn this off on a
permanent basis :)

--

Dave Peterson

--

Dave Peterson

--

Dave Peterson

u have the last larf!
Tim

"Dave Peterson" wrote in message
...
You mean snse or humo(u)r????

Oh, oh.

Tim Childs wrote:

vg - not lost your snse of humour* :)
Tim

note spelling!

"Dave Peterson" wrote in message
...
None that I didn't share <bg.

Tim Childs wrote:

Dave

Good to be in touch again - thanks

I am at home so cannot test the volatile functions etc but I believe
it
is
sharing that causes the problem because I did not have the "do you
want
to
save changes dialog box" when I made a copy of the the file and
turned
off
the sharing.

Any ideas?

Tim

"Dave Peterson" wrote in message
...
Do you have any of these volatile functions in your workbook?

=AREAS()
=INDEX() *
=OFFSET()
=CELL()
=INDIRECT()
=ROWS()
=COLUMNS()
=NOW()
=TODAY()
=RAND()

* may not be volatile in all versions

These evaluate with each calculation. And cause excel to think
your
workbook
has changed.

And excel likes to recalculate workbooks created in earlier
versions.
Is
this
the case in your situation?

======
And as a test, you may want to unshare the workbook (or a copy of
the
workbook)
to see if it's sharing that's causing the trouble.

Tim Childs wrote:

Hi

I am using the sharing facilty to enable multiple simultaneous
editing
access to a workbook.

The problem that I want to solve is that the workbook always
seems
to
open
in "thiswork.saved = false" mode i.e. the workbook always
prompts
the
user
to save when closing even if no changes have been made.

Apart form using VB* (which is my curent workaround), is there a
solution to
this?

Thanks

Tim

* the reason I want o avoid Vb is that I am tryiing to eliminate
extra
steps
and including VB would mean users get the "enable macros" screen
each
time
they open it - and outr IT Dept don't allow us to turn this off
on a
permanent basis :)

--

Dave Peterson

--

Dave Peterson

--

Dave Peterson