Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1   Report Post  
Chris Berding
 
Posts: n/a
Default VLOOKUP using a cell calculated with NOW returns Error

I am calculating the present age of people, then by their age, I am looking
them up in a rate chart based on their age.

I calculate their age by NOW-D.O.B. which works fine. (see actual cell
contents below)

Then, I use the cell that contains the age result in a VLOOKUP cell to
determine their rate. It works perfectly for exactly 3 people, then it
returns an error #REF! because, I have deduced, that it doesn't like the fact
that the age is constantly changing each time the calculation is done.

Why does it work for 3 people and then stop? More importantly, is there a
way i can just take the "value" of the age cell into the VLOOKUP, rather than
pulling the dynamic number into the function?

Here's my VLOOKUP just for reference:
=(VLOOKUP(F3,VLOOKUPrates!$B$2:$E$74,VLOOKUPrates! $B$2:$B$74))*M3
where F3 is the calculated AGE and M3 is a constant.

Here's my present AGE calculation for reference (that is somehow considered
in the above VLOOKUP):
=IF(TRUNC(((YEAR($A$1)-YEAR(E3))*12+MONTH($A$1)-MONTH(E3))/12)=105, "
",TRUNC(((YEAR($A$1)-YEAR(E3))*12+MONTH($A$1)-MONTH(E3))/12))
Where $A$1 = NOW

any help gratefully acknowleged and appreciated !
  #2   Report Post  
Anne Troy
 
Posts: n/a
Default

Don't use NOW. Try TODAY().
************
Anne Troy
www.OfficeArticles.com



"Chris Berding" wrote in message
...
I am calculating the present age of people, then by their age, I am looking
them up in a rate chart based on their age.

I calculate their age by NOW-D.O.B. which works fine. (see actual cell
contents below)

Then, I use the cell that contains the age result in a VLOOKUP cell to
determine their rate. It works perfectly for exactly 3 people, then it
returns an error #REF! because, I have deduced, that it doesn't like the
fact
that the age is constantly changing each time the calculation is done.

Why does it work for 3 people and then stop? More importantly, is there a
way i can just take the "value" of the age cell into the VLOOKUP, rather
than
pulling the dynamic number into the function?

Here's my VLOOKUP just for reference:
=(VLOOKUP(F3,VLOOKUPrates!$B$2:$E$74,VLOOKUPrates! $B$2:$B$74))*M3
where F3 is the calculated AGE and M3 is a constant.

Here's my present AGE calculation for reference (that is somehow
considered
in the above VLOOKUP):
=IF(TRUNC(((YEAR($A$1)-YEAR(E3))*12+MONTH($A$1)-MONTH(E3))/12)=105, "
",TRUNC(((YEAR($A$1)-YEAR(E3))*12+MONTH($A$1)-MONTH(E3))/12))
Where $A$1 = NOW

any help gratefully acknowleged and appreciated !



  #3   Report Post  
Ron Rosenfeld
 
Posts: n/a
Default

On Sat, 20 Aug 2005 18:40:01 -0700, "Chris Berding"
wrote:

I am calculating the present age of people, then by their age, I am looking
them up in a rate chart based on their age.

I calculate their age by NOW-D.O.B. which works fine. (see actual cell
contents below)

Then, I use the cell that contains the age result in a VLOOKUP cell to
determine their rate. It works perfectly for exactly 3 people, then it
returns an error #REF! because, I have deduced, that it doesn't like the fact
that the age is constantly changing each time the calculation is done.

Why does it work for 3 people and then stop? More importantly, is there a
way i can just take the "value" of the age cell into the VLOOKUP, rather than
pulling the dynamic number into the function?

Here's my VLOOKUP just for reference:
=(VLOOKUP(F3,VLOOKUPrates!$B$2:$E$74,VLOOKUPrates !$B$2:$B$74))*M3
where F3 is the calculated AGE and M3 is a constant.

Here's my present AGE calculation for reference (that is somehow considered
in the above VLOOKUP):
=IF(TRUNC(((YEAR($A$1)-YEAR(E3))*12+MONTH($A$1)-MONTH(E3))/12)=105, "
",TRUNC(((YEAR($A$1)-YEAR(E3))*12+MONTH($A$1)-MONTH(E3))/12))
Where $A$1 = NOW

any help gratefully acknowleged and appreciated !


A few suggestions.

1. To calculate age, use the simpler (but mostly undocumented in Excel)
formula:

=IF(OR(E3="",E3TODAY()),"",DATEDIF(E3,TODAY(),"y" ))

or, with A1: =TODAY()

=IF(OR(E3="",E3A1),"",DATEDIF(E3,A1,"y"))

2. The syntax of your VLOOKUP is incorrect. The third argument is supposed to
be a column number within your table. You have:

=(VLOOKUP(F3,VLOOKUPrates!$B$2:$E$74,VLOOKUPrates! $B$2:$B$74))*M3

But perhaps:

VLOOKUP(F3,VLOOKUPRates!$B$2:$E$74,4)*M3


--ron
Reply
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Convert VLOOKUP to absolute cell reference Rich Excel Discussion (Misc queries) 2 August 6th 05 03:49 AM
Possible Lookup Table Karen Excel Worksheet Functions 5 June 8th 05 09:43 PM
How do I obtain the address of a cell using the vlookup function? Spock Excel Worksheet Functions 2 May 16th 05 06:35 PM
VLOOKUP for a cell with both letters and numbers Sonohal Excel Discussion (Misc queries) 6 April 8th 05 02:13 PM
Using Jet to read excel file returns blank for last cell - sometim Ron Excel Discussion (Misc queries) 1 December 9th 04 08:21 AM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 10:29 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 ExcelBanter.
The comments are property of their posters.
 

About Us

"It's about Microsoft Excel"