Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
|
|||
|
|||
Calculating probabilities
I am trying to calculate probabilities in excel but I dont really know which
functions to use. Lets say I have only two possible outcomes 1 and 0. So far the outcome was as follow: 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 Which are the odds to get 1 and to get 0? Which formula can calculate this? |
#2
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
|
|||
|
|||
Calculating probabilities
Probability that its a 1:
=COUNTIF(A2:A8,1)/COUNTA(A2:A8) Similarly, the probability that its a zero: =COUNTIF(A2:A8,0)/COUNTA(A2:A8) Alternatively, since Pzero + Pone = 1 as the data comprises only zeros or 1s (in this instance) Pzero = 1 - COUNTIF(A2:A8,1)/COUNTA(A2:A8) any good? hit the YES below -- Max Singapore http://savefile.com/projects/236895 Downloads:27,000 Files:200 Subscribers:70 xdemechanik --- "Raul Sousa" wrote: I am trying to calculate probabilities in excel but I dont really know which functions to use. Lets say I have only two possible outcomes 1 and 0. So far the outcome was as follow: 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 Which are the odds to get 1 and to get 0? Which formula can calculate this? |
#3
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
|
|||
|
|||
Calculating probabilities
Thanks for your replay Max.
it could be a good idea. Unfortunately I think it is not correct. The changes to have 1 or 0 are 50/50. In this case there is more 1 than 0 (5Vs2). So the chances that the next number is a zero are bigger than the chances that the next number is 1. I just dont know a formula to calculate these odds. "Max" wrote: Probability that its a 1: =COUNTIF(A2:A8,1)/COUNTA(A2:A8) Similarly, the probability that its a zero: =COUNTIF(A2:A8,0)/COUNTA(A2:A8) Alternatively, since Pzero + Pone = 1 as the data comprises only zeros or 1s (in this instance) Pzero = 1 - COUNTIF(A2:A8,1)/COUNTA(A2:A8) any good? hit the YES below -- Max Singapore http://savefile.com/projects/236895 Downloads:27,000 Files:200 Subscribers:70 xdemechanik --- "Raul Sousa" wrote: I am trying to calculate probabilities in excel but I dont really know which functions to use. Lets say I have only two possible outcomes 1 and 0. So far the outcome was as follow: 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 Which are the odds to get 1 and to get 0? Which formula can calculate this? |
#4
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
|
|||
|
|||
Calculating probabilities
"Raul Sousa" wrote:
Thanks for your replay Max. it could be a good idea. Unfortunately I think it is not correct. It is correct for what Max was trying to do -- which might not be what you need. You told us nothing about the distribution of 1s and 0s. So Max's approach attempts to derive the probabilities based on observed results. Since you have 5 1s and 2 0s, we might reasonably conclude that the probablilities are 5/7 and 2/7 respectively -- that is, until you provide additional information. The changes to have 1 or 0 are 50/50. New information breeds new solutions. But you must also tell us whether the events (1 and 0) are independent or not. It would help if you explained how you are generating the 1s and 0s. For example, flipping a coin, or --(RAND()<=0.5)? the chances that the next number is a zero are bigger than the chances that the next number is 1. I just dont know a formula to calculate these odds. Assuming independent events.... If you had not generated any numbers, the chances of getting a __specific__ sequence of 7 1s and 0s followed by either a 1 or 0 would be 1/(2^8). The chances of getting __any__ sequence of 6 1s and 2 0s is COMBIN(8,6)/2^8 (about 11%), and the chances of getting any sequence of 5 1s and 3 0s is COMBIN(8,5)/2^8 (about 22%). So if you had not generated any numbers, you would be correct that the probablility of 5 1s and 3 0s is higher than 6 1s and 2 0s. But having gotten any sequence of 5 1s and 2 0s, the probability of getting a 1 or 0 next is still 50% each, for the very reason (assumed above) that the choice of 1 or 0 is independent of the past. These are difficult concepts to grasp. You should take an intro course in probability. ----- original message ----- "Raul Sousa" wrote in message ... Thanks for your replay Max. it could be a good idea. Unfortunately I think it is not correct. The changes to have 1 or 0 are 50/50. In this case there is more 1 than 0 (5Vs2). So the chances that the next number is a zero are bigger than the chances that the next number is 1. I just dont know a formula to calculate these odds. "Max" wrote: Probability that its a 1: =COUNTIF(A2:A8,1)/COUNTA(A2:A8) Similarly, the probability that its a zero: =COUNTIF(A2:A8,0)/COUNTA(A2:A8) Alternatively, since Pzero + Pone = 1 as the data comprises only zeros or 1s (in this instance) Pzero = 1 - COUNTIF(A2:A8,1)/COUNTA(A2:A8) any good? hit the YES below -- Max Singapore http://savefile.com/projects/236895 Downloads:27,000 Files:200 Subscribers:70 xdemechanik --- "Raul Sousa" wrote: I am trying to calculate probabilities in excel but I dont really know which functions to use. Lets say I have only two possible outcomes 1 and 0. So far the outcome was as follow: 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 Which are the odds to get 1 and to get 0? Which formula can calculate this? |
#5
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
|
|||
|
|||
Calculating probabilities
Unless you claim to be clairvoyant I knew you were going to say that.......:) Joe, Of course I made some assumptions based on the limited information available. It seemed to me that Raul was trying to predict the outcome of an event based on previous independent events, I may well be wrong, it wouldn't be the first time.... regards, barry -- barry houdini ------------------------------------------------------------------------ barry houdini's Profile: http://www.thecodecage.com/forumz/member.php?userid=72 View this thread: http://www.thecodecage.com/forumz/sh...d.php?t=145263 |
#6
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
|
|||
|
|||
Calculating probabilities
Hi,
The changes to have 1 or 0 are 50/50. In this case there is more 1 than 0 (5Vs2). So the chances that the next number is a zero are bigger than the chances that the next number is 1. That's incorrect because it implies that (say) a coin has memory and if we flip 10 consecutive heads the next is more likely to be tails which it isn't, the chance of the next being tails is exactly the same as for the previous 10 flips 50/50. Mike "Raul Sousa" wrote: Thanks for your replay Max. it could be a good idea. Unfortunately I think it is not correct. The changes to have 1 or 0 are 50/50. In this case there is more 1 than 0 (5Vs2). So the chances that the next number is a zero are bigger than the chances that the next number is 1. I just dont know a formula to calculate these odds. "Max" wrote: Probability that its a 1: =COUNTIF(A2:A8,1)/COUNTA(A2:A8) Similarly, the probability that its a zero: =COUNTIF(A2:A8,0)/COUNTA(A2:A8) Alternatively, since Pzero + Pone = 1 as the data comprises only zeros or 1s (in this instance) Pzero = 1 - COUNTIF(A2:A8,1)/COUNTA(A2:A8) any good? hit the YES below -- Max Singapore http://savefile.com/projects/236895 Downloads:27,000 Files:200 Subscribers:70 xdemechanik --- "Raul Sousa" wrote: I am trying to calculate probabilities in excel but I dont really know which functions to use. Lets say I have only two possible outcomes 1 and 0. So far the outcome was as follow: 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 Which are the odds to get 1 and to get 0? Which formula can calculate this? |
#7
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
|
|||
|
|||
Calculating probabilities
If you flip 9 times a coin and get 9 faces then at the 10Th time you flip it
the odds of getting a tail are much higher than the odds of getting a face. At any flip the chances are 50/50. But, the chances to get 10 faces straight are lower than the chances to get 9 faces and 1 tail in 10 coin flips. I am sure there must be a way to calculate this probabilities in excel. Just dont know how to and appreciate any help. "Mike H" wrote: Hi, The changes to have 1 or 0 are 50/50. In this case there is more 1 than 0 (5Vs2). So the chances that the next number is a zero are bigger than the chances that the next number is 1. That's incorrect because it implies that (say) a coin has memory and if we flip 10 consecutive heads the next is more likely to be tails which it isn't, the chance of the next being tails is exactly the same as for the previous 10 flips 50/50. Mike "Raul Sousa" wrote: Thanks for your replay Max. it could be a good idea. Unfortunately I think it is not correct. The changes to have 1 or 0 are 50/50. In this case there is more 1 than 0 (5Vs2). So the chances that the next number is a zero are bigger than the chances that the next number is 1. I just dont know a formula to calculate these odds. "Max" wrote: Probability that its a 1: =COUNTIF(A2:A8,1)/COUNTA(A2:A8) Similarly, the probability that its a zero: =COUNTIF(A2:A8,0)/COUNTA(A2:A8) Alternatively, since Pzero + Pone = 1 as the data comprises only zeros or 1s (in this instance) Pzero = 1 - COUNTIF(A2:A8,1)/COUNTA(A2:A8) any good? hit the YES below -- Max Singapore http://savefile.com/projects/236895 Downloads:27,000 Files:200 Subscribers:70 xdemechanik --- "Raul Sousa" wrote: I am trying to calculate probabilities in excel but I dont really know which functions to use. Lets say I have only two possible outcomes 1 and 0. So far the outcome was as follow: 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 Which are the odds to get 1 and to get 0? Which formula can calculate this? |
#8
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
|
|||
|
|||
Calculating probabilities
When you say:
"If you flip 9 times a coin and get 9 faces then at the 10Th time you flip it the odds of getting a tail are much higher than the odds of getting a face." you are entirely wrong. When you say: "the chance to get 10 faces straight are lower than the chances to get 9 faces and 1 tail in 10 coin flips." you are right, but only because there are 10 sequences in which you can get 9 faces and 1 tail. If you have had 9 faces in the first 9 flips, the probability of getting 10 faces is exactly the same as getting 9 faces followed by 1 tail. -- David Biddulph Raul Sousa wrote: If you flip 9 times a coin and get 9 faces then at the 10Th time you flip it the odds of getting a tail are much higher than the odds of getting a face. At any flip the chances are 50/50. But, the chances to get 10 faces straight are lower than the chances to get 9 faces and 1 tail in 10 coin flips. I am sure there must be a way to calculate this probabilities in excel. Just don't know how to and appreciate any help. "Mike H" wrote: Hi, The changes to have 1 or 0 are 50/50. In this case there is more 1 than 0 (5Vs2). So the chances that the next number is a zero are bigger than the chances that the next number is 1. That's incorrect because it implies that (say) a coin has memory and if we flip 10 consecutive heads the next is more likely to be tails which it isn't, the chance of the next being tails is exactly the same as for the previous 10 flips 50/50. Mike "Raul Sousa" wrote: Thanks for your replay Max. it could be a good idea. Unfortunately I think it is not correct. The changes to have 1 or 0 are 50/50. In this case there is more 1 than 0 (5Vs2). So the chances that the next number is a zero are bigger than the chances that the next number is 1. I just don't know a formula to calculate these odds. "Max" wrote: Probability that its a 1: =COUNTIF(A2:A8,1)/COUNTA(A2:A8) Similarly, the probability that its a zero: =COUNTIF(A2:A8,0)/COUNTA(A2:A8) Alternatively, since Pzero + Pone = 1 as the data comprises only zeros or 1s (in this instance) Pzero = 1 - COUNTIF(A2:A8,1)/COUNTA(A2:A8) any good? hit the YES below -- Max Singapore http://savefile.com/projects/236895 Downloads:27,000 Files:200 Subscribers:70 xdemechanik --- "Raul Sousa" wrote: I am trying to calculate probabilities in excel but I don't really know which functions to use. Lets say I have only two possible outcomes 1 and 0. So far the outcome was as follow: 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 Which are the odds to get 1 and to get 0? Which formula can calculate this? |
#9
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
|
|||
|
|||
Calculating probabilities
Hi,
If you flip 9 times a coin and get 9 faces then at the 10Th time you flip it the odds of getting a tail are much higher than the odds of getting a face. Incorrect!! The odds of 9 straight head flips is easy to calculate =0.5^9 or around 0.19% chance But having done that the odds of the tenth are 50/50 because the coin has no memory and the result of the next event is not influenced by the previous events. You're actually referring to the 'gamblers fallacy' which is believed to suggest that ultimately the number of events will even out. Ten consecutive black on the roulette wheel so lets bet large on red is a very quick way indeed to end up bankrupt. What will move near to 'normal' is the percentage for each event (50%) but there could be a very large difference in the frequency of each that equate to 50% especially when dealing with large numbers. The odds of doing 10 straight head flips is =0.5^10 Mike "Raul Sousa" wrote: If you flip 9 times a coin and get 9 faces then at the 10Th time you flip it the odds of getting a tail are much higher than the odds of getting a face. At any flip the chances are 50/50. But, the chances to get 10 faces straight are lower than the chances to get 9 faces and 1 tail in 10 coin flips. I am sure there must be a way to calculate this probabilities in excel. Just dont know how to and appreciate any help. "Mike H" wrote: Hi, The changes to have 1 or 0 are 50/50. In this case there is more 1 than 0 (5Vs2). So the chances that the next number is a zero are bigger than the chances that the next number is 1. That's incorrect because it implies that (say) a coin has memory and if we flip 10 consecutive heads the next is more likely to be tails which it isn't, the chance of the next being tails is exactly the same as for the previous 10 flips 50/50. Mike "Raul Sousa" wrote: Thanks for your replay Max. it could be a good idea. Unfortunately I think it is not correct. The changes to have 1 or 0 are 50/50. In this case there is more 1 than 0 (5Vs2). So the chances that the next number is a zero are bigger than the chances that the next number is 1. I just dont know a formula to calculate these odds. "Max" wrote: Probability that its a 1: =COUNTIF(A2:A8,1)/COUNTA(A2:A8) Similarly, the probability that its a zero: =COUNTIF(A2:A8,0)/COUNTA(A2:A8) Alternatively, since Pzero + Pone = 1 as the data comprises only zeros or 1s (in this instance) Pzero = 1 - COUNTIF(A2:A8,1)/COUNTA(A2:A8) any good? hit the YES below -- Max Singapore http://savefile.com/projects/236895 Downloads:27,000 Files:200 Subscribers:70 xdemechanik --- "Raul Sousa" wrote: I am trying to calculate probabilities in excel but I dont really know which functions to use. Lets say I have only two possible outcomes 1 and 0. So far the outcome was as follow: 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 Which are the odds to get 1 and to get 0? Which formula can calculate this? |
#10
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
|
|||
|
|||
Calculating probabilities
Based on your anwser I realized that I must learn some more about ...
probabilities. My idea was to know more about statistical functions in Excel and after that calcuate what I need. I think, know, that I will first take a look at a book about probabilities. Thanks again for your anwser. "Mike H" wrote: Hi, If you flip 9 times a coin and get 9 faces then at the 10Th time you flip it the odds of getting a tail are much higher than the odds of getting a face. Incorrect!! The odds of 9 straight head flips is easy to calculate =0.5^9 or around 0.19% chance But having done that the odds of the tenth are 50/50 because the coin has no memory and the result of the next event is not influenced by the previous events. You're actually referring to the 'gamblers fallacy' which is believed to suggest that ultimately the number of events will even out. Ten consecutive black on the roulette wheel so lets bet large on red is a very quick way indeed to end up bankrupt. What will move near to 'normal' is the percentage for each event (50%) but there could be a very large difference in the frequency of each that equate to 50% especially when dealing with large numbers. The odds of doing 10 straight head flips is =0.5^10 Mike "Raul Sousa" wrote: If you flip 9 times a coin and get 9 faces then at the 10Th time you flip it the odds of getting a tail are much higher than the odds of getting a face. At any flip the chances are 50/50. But, the chances to get 10 faces straight are lower than the chances to get 9 faces and 1 tail in 10 coin flips. I am sure there must be a way to calculate this probabilities in excel. Just dont know how to and appreciate any help. "Mike H" wrote: Hi, The changes to have 1 or 0 are 50/50. In this case there is more 1 than 0 (5Vs2). So the chances that the next number is a zero are bigger than the chances that the next number is 1. That's incorrect because it implies that (say) a coin has memory and if we flip 10 consecutive heads the next is more likely to be tails which it isn't, the chance of the next being tails is exactly the same as for the previous 10 flips 50/50. Mike "Raul Sousa" wrote: Thanks for your replay Max. it could be a good idea. Unfortunately I think it is not correct. The changes to have 1 or 0 are 50/50. In this case there is more 1 than 0 (5Vs2). So the chances that the next number is a zero are bigger than the chances that the next number is 1. I just dont know a formula to calculate these odds. "Max" wrote: Probability that its a 1: =COUNTIF(A2:A8,1)/COUNTA(A2:A8) Similarly, the probability that its a zero: =COUNTIF(A2:A8,0)/COUNTA(A2:A8) Alternatively, since Pzero + Pone = 1 as the data comprises only zeros or 1s (in this instance) Pzero = 1 - COUNTIF(A2:A8,1)/COUNTA(A2:A8) any good? hit the YES below -- Max Singapore http://savefile.com/projects/236895 Downloads:27,000 Files:200 Subscribers:70 xdemechanik --- "Raul Sousa" wrote: I am trying to calculate probabilities in excel but I dont really know which functions to use. Lets say I have only two possible outcomes 1 and 0. So far the outcome was as follow: 1 0 1 0 1 1 1 Which are the odds to get 1 and to get 0? Which formula can calculate this? |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Calculating Probabilities | Excel Worksheet Functions | |||
Question about use of Poisson probabilities | Excel Worksheet Functions | |||
Question about use of Poisson probabilities | Excel Discussion (Misc queries) | |||
Probabilities, random numbers and dice throws | Excel Worksheet Functions | |||
Calculating recurring date in following month, calculating # days in that period | Excel Worksheet Functions |