Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,388
Default Find max value in one column based on another column

I searched the posts, but didn't find anything obvious that would work in my
situation.

I have a list of part numbers in column A, and their revisions in column B.
One part number can have 1 or more revisions. I'd like to find the latest
revision for each part number in column A. My list looks like:

PART NUMBER Revision
1120007 A
1120007 B00
5360120 A00
5360120 A01
5360120 D00
and so on

I have 51,000+ rows of data, and would like to summarize by finding only the
latest revisions of the parts- in this case it would be B00 for PN 1120007
and D00 for PN 5360120. I can probably boil down that 51,000 part number
rows to 3,000 to 4,000.

I sense it would be pretty simple, but I'm a relative novice when it comes
to Excel.

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Dave
  #2   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 11,501
Default Find max value in one column based on another column

Maybe

=LOOKUP(2,1/(A1:A100=C1),B1:B100)

Where C1 is the part No you are looking for.

Mike

"Dave" wrote:

I searched the posts, but didn't find anything obvious that would work in my
situation.

I have a list of part numbers in column A, and their revisions in column B.
One part number can have 1 or more revisions. I'd like to find the latest
revision for each part number in column A. My list looks like:

PART NUMBER Revision
1120007 A
1120007 B00
5360120 A00
5360120 A01
5360120 D00
and so on

I have 51,000+ rows of data, and would like to summarize by finding only the
latest revisions of the parts- in this case it would be B00 for PN 1120007
and D00 for PN 5360120. I can probably boil down that 51,000 part number
rows to 3,000 to 4,000.

I sense it would be pretty simple, but I'm a relative novice when it comes
to Excel.

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Dave

  #3   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 15,768
Default Find max value in one column based on another column

Maybe this if you want to get rid of the old data and only keep the most
recent data (assuming that your data is sorted as is shown in your sample).

Enter this formula in colun C and copy down to the end of data:

=IF(A3<A2,"x","")

The "x" will mark the latest revision.

Now, convert the formulas to constants:

Select the range of formulas in column C.
Goto EditCopy
Then, EditPaste SpecialValuesOK

Now, sort the entire range on column C in descending order. This will put
all the latest revisions at the top.

Find the last "x" and delete everything after it. Then delete column C.


--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Dave" wrote in message
...
I searched the posts, but didn't find anything obvious that would work in
my
situation.

I have a list of part numbers in column A, and their revisions in column
B.
One part number can have 1 or more revisions. I'd like to find the latest
revision for each part number in column A. My list looks like:

PART NUMBER Revision
1120007 A
1120007 B00
5360120 A00
5360120 A01
5360120 D00
and so on

I have 51,000+ rows of data, and would like to summarize by finding only
the
latest revisions of the parts- in this case it would be B00 for PN 1120007
and D00 for PN 5360120. I can probably boil down that 51,000 part number
rows to 3,000 to 4,000.

I sense it would be pretty simple, but I'm a relative novice when it comes
to Excel.

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Dave



  #4   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,388
Default Find max value in one column based on another column

Mike,

This "kind of" solved my problem, but not quite. The LOOKUP formula did
return the highest revision number (in column C) for the part numbers in
column A. I thought then I could filter the part number column and get all
the latest revisions for the part numbers.

But the formula "broke down" at row 4319 (of 61,228 rows) and started
returning each revision in column B again.

At part number 1330500 the formula started returning all revisions from
column B, instead of the max revision as with part number 1330496:
1330493 A00 A00
1330494 A00 A01
1330494 A01 A01
1330495 A00 A01
1330495 A01 A01
1330496 A00 A01
1330496 A01 A01
1330497 A00 A00
1330498 A00 A00
1330499 A00 A00
1330500 A00 A00
1330500 A01 A01
1330503 100 100
1330503 A00 A00
1330504 100 100
1330504 A00 A00
1330505 100 100
1330505 A00 A00
1330506 100 100
1330506 101 101

Any idea why this happened? Is it my PC's memory? I have 3GB RAM.

"Mike H" wrote:

Maybe

=LOOKUP(2,1/(A1:A100=C1),B1:B100)

Where C1 is the part No you are looking for.

Mike

"Dave" wrote:

I searched the posts, but didn't find anything obvious that would work in my
situation.

I have a list of part numbers in column A, and their revisions in column B.
One part number can have 1 or more revisions. I'd like to find the latest
revision for each part number in column A. My list looks like:

PART NUMBER Revision
1120007 A
1120007 B00
5360120 A00
5360120 A01
5360120 D00
and so on

I have 51,000+ rows of data, and would like to summarize by finding only the
latest revisions of the parts- in this case it would be B00 for PN 1120007
and D00 for PN 5360120. I can probably boil down that 51,000 part number
rows to 3,000 to 4,000.

I sense it would be pretty simple, but I'm a relative novice when it comes
to Excel.

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Dave

  #5   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 11,501
Default Find max value in one column based on another column

Dave,

The formula I gave you didn't return anything from Column C only Column B.
You may have thought it did because of similarities in the data.

The formula isn't affected by the size of the range except that in Excel
2003 (Don't know about 2007) it won't work on full columns but this is tested
and works on 65535 rows.

=LOOKUP(2,1/(A1:A65535=C1),B1:B6535)

Mike

"Dave" wrote:

Mike,

This "kind of" solved my problem, but not quite. The LOOKUP formula did
return the highest revision number (in column C) for the part numbers in
column A. I thought then I could filter the part number column and get all
the latest revisions for the part numbers.

But the formula "broke down" at row 4319 (of 61,228 rows) and started
returning each revision in column B again.

At part number 1330500 the formula started returning all revisions from
column B, instead of the max revision as with part number 1330496:
1330493 A00 A00
1330494 A00 A01
1330494 A01 A01
1330495 A00 A01
1330495 A01 A01
1330496 A00 A01
1330496 A01 A01
1330497 A00 A00
1330498 A00 A00
1330499 A00 A00
1330500 A00 A00
1330500 A01 A01
1330503 100 100
1330503 A00 A00
1330504 100 100
1330504 A00 A00
1330505 100 100
1330505 A00 A00
1330506 100 100
1330506 101 101

Any idea why this happened? Is it my PC's memory? I have 3GB RAM.

"Mike H" wrote:

Maybe

=LOOKUP(2,1/(A1:A100=C1),B1:B100)

Where C1 is the part No you are looking for.

Mike

"Dave" wrote:

I searched the posts, but didn't find anything obvious that would work in my
situation.

I have a list of part numbers in column A, and their revisions in column B.
One part number can have 1 or more revisions. I'd like to find the latest
revision for each part number in column A. My list looks like:

PART NUMBER Revision
1120007 A
1120007 B00
5360120 A00
5360120 A01
5360120 D00
and so on

I have 51,000+ rows of data, and would like to summarize by finding only the
latest revisions of the parts- in this case it would be B00 for PN 1120007
and D00 for PN 5360120. I can probably boil down that 51,000 part number
rows to 3,000 to 4,000.

I sense it would be pretty simple, but I'm a relative novice when it comes
to Excel.

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Dave



  #6   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,388
Default Find max value in one column based on another column

Biff,

Thanks for the input. This works well, except for the part numbers which
have only one revision. Then, in those cases, an "X" is placed in the
column, making the sort be the same as for lower revisions of a part which
has several revisions.
Example:
TEST A X
TEST B
TEST A00
400078 A X
846261 A00 X
876000 A X
876000 B
876001 A X
876001 B
876002 A X
876002 B
876003 A X
876004 A X
876005 A X
876006 A X
876007 A X
876008 A X
876008 B

In the above exceprt, PNs 876004, 876005, 876006 (which have only one
revision)have X's where PN 87008 has an X for the lower revision and a blank
for the higher revision (B). I need to have 874004,876005,876006 return the
same value in column C as 876008 revision B.

Thanks,

Dave
"T. Valko" wrote:

Maybe this if you want to get rid of the old data and only keep the most
recent data (assuming that your data is sorted as is shown in your sample).

Enter this formula in colun C and copy down to the end of data:

=IF(A3<A2,"x","")

The "x" will mark the latest revision.

Now, convert the formulas to constants:

Select the range of formulas in column C.
Goto EditCopy
Then, EditPaste SpecialValuesOK

Now, sort the entire range on column C in descending order. This will put
all the latest revisions at the top.

Find the last "x" and delete everything after it. Then delete column C.


--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Dave" wrote in message
...
I searched the posts, but didn't find anything obvious that would work in
my
situation.

I have a list of part numbers in column A, and their revisions in column
B.
One part number can have 1 or more revisions. I'd like to find the latest
revision for each part number in column A. My list looks like:

PART NUMBER Revision
1120007 A
1120007 B00
5360120 A00
5360120 A01
5360120 D00
and so on

I have 51,000+ rows of data, and would like to summarize by finding only
the
latest revisions of the parts- in this case it would be B00 for PN 1120007
and D00 for PN 5360120. I can probably boil down that 51,000 part number
rows to 3,000 to 4,000.

I sense it would be pretty simple, but I'm a relative novice when it comes
to Excel.

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Dave




  #7   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 15,768
Default Find max value in one column based on another column

Hmmm...

The results I get are not the same as the results you've posted.

Here's a small sample file that demonstrates this:

xMarkOld.xls 14kb

http://cjoint.com/?gzxPE2vUKA

In column C I've entered the formula but changed the "x" to "Keep" meaning,
keep this record.

Column D shows the "x" that you posted in your sample. As you'll see the
"keeps" are in the correct places.

--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Dave" wrote in message
...
Biff,

Thanks for the input. This works well, except for the part numbers which
have only one revision. Then, in those cases, an "X" is placed in the
column, making the sort be the same as for lower revisions of a part which
has several revisions.
Example:
TEST A X
TEST B
TEST A00
400078 A X
846261 A00 X
876000 A X
876000 B
876001 A X
876001 B
876002 A X
876002 B
876003 A X
876004 A X
876005 A X
876006 A X
876007 A X
876008 A X
876008 B

In the above exceprt, PNs 876004, 876005, 876006 (which have only one
revision)have X's where PN 87008 has an X for the lower revision and a
blank
for the higher revision (B). I need to have 874004,876005,876006 return
the
same value in column C as 876008 revision B.

Thanks,

Dave
"T. Valko" wrote:

Maybe this if you want to get rid of the old data and only keep the most
recent data (assuming that your data is sorted as is shown in your
sample).

Enter this formula in colun C and copy down to the end of data:

=IF(A3<A2,"x","")

The "x" will mark the latest revision.

Now, convert the formulas to constants:

Select the range of formulas in column C.
Goto EditCopy
Then, EditPaste SpecialValuesOK

Now, sort the entire range on column C in descending order. This will put
all the latest revisions at the top.

Find the last "x" and delete everything after it. Then delete column C.


--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Dave" wrote in message
...
I searched the posts, but didn't find anything obvious that would work
in
my
situation.

I have a list of part numbers in column A, and their revisions in
column
B.
One part number can have 1 or more revisions. I'd like to find the
latest
revision for each part number in column A. My list looks like:

PART NUMBER Revision
1120007 A
1120007 B00
5360120 A00
5360120 A01
5360120 D00
and so on

I have 51,000+ rows of data, and would like to summarize by finding
only
the
latest revisions of the parts- in this case it would be B00 for PN
1120007
and D00 for PN 5360120. I can probably boil down that 51,000 part
number
rows to 3,000 to 4,000.

I sense it would be pretty simple, but I'm a relative novice when it
comes
to Excel.

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Dave






  #8   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,388
Default Find max value in one column based on another column

Hi, Biff-

I re-did the formula to specify "KEEP" and got the following result.

The formula used is depicted in column D:
PN REV FORMULA
400078 A KEEP
846261 A00 KEEP =IF(A8<A7,"KEEP","")
876000 A KEEP
876000 B
876001 A KEEP
876001 B
876002 A KEEP
876002 B
876003 A KEEP
876004 A KEEP
876005 A KEEP
876006 A KEEP
876007 A KEEP
876008 A KEEP
The formula depicted is copied down thru Part Number 876008, and depicts the
relative cells.

But you'll notice that for PNs 876000 thru 876002 the wrong revision is
depicted as a "KEEP".

I dunno what's happening in my sheet. Your sheet looks good.

Dave

"T. Valko" wrote:

Hmmm...

The results I get are not the same as the results you've posted.

Here's a small sample file that demonstrates this:

xMarkOld.xls 14kb

http://cjoint.com/?gzxPE2vUKA

In column C I've entered the formula but changed the "x" to "Keep" meaning,
keep this record.

Column D shows the "x" that you posted in your sample. As you'll see the
"keeps" are in the correct places.

--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Dave" wrote in message
...
Biff,

Thanks for the input. This works well, except for the part numbers which
have only one revision. Then, in those cases, an "X" is placed in the
column, making the sort be the same as for lower revisions of a part which
has several revisions.
Example:
TEST A X
TEST B
TEST A00
400078 A X
846261 A00 X
876000 A X
876000 B
876001 A X
876001 B
876002 A X
876002 B
876003 A X
876004 A X
876005 A X
876006 A X
876007 A X
876008 A X
876008 B

In the above exceprt, PNs 876004, 876005, 876006 (which have only one
revision)have X's where PN 87008 has an X for the lower revision and a
blank
for the higher revision (B). I need to have 874004,876005,876006 return
the
same value in column C as 876008 revision B.

Thanks,

Dave
"T. Valko" wrote:

Maybe this if you want to get rid of the old data and only keep the most
recent data (assuming that your data is sorted as is shown in your
sample).

Enter this formula in colun C and copy down to the end of data:

=IF(A3<A2,"x","")

The "x" will mark the latest revision.

Now, convert the formulas to constants:

Select the range of formulas in column C.
Goto EditCopy
Then, EditPaste SpecialValuesOK

Now, sort the entire range on column C in descending order. This will put
all the latest revisions at the top.

Find the last "x" and delete everything after it. Then delete column C.


--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Dave" wrote in message
...
I searched the posts, but didn't find anything obvious that would work
in
my
situation.

I have a list of part numbers in column A, and their revisions in
column
B.
One part number can have 1 or more revisions. I'd like to find the
latest
revision for each part number in column A. My list looks like:

PART NUMBER Revision
1120007 A
1120007 B00
5360120 A00
5360120 A01
5360120 D00
and so on

I have 51,000+ rows of data, and would like to summarize by finding
only
the
latest revisions of the parts- in this case it would be B00 for PN
1120007
and D00 for PN 5360120. I can probably boil down that 51,000 part
number
rows to 3,000 to 4,000.

I sense it would be pretty simple, but I'm a relative novice when it
comes
to Excel.

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Dave






  #9   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 15,768
Default Find max value in one column based on another column

I suspect you're putting the formula in the wrong row. If your data starts
in A7 then put the formula in C7 then copy down.

=IF(A8<A7,"KEEP","")

--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Dave" wrote in message
...
Hi, Biff-

I re-did the formula to specify "KEEP" and got the following result.

The formula used is depicted in column D:
PN REV FORMULA
400078 A KEEP
846261 A00 KEEP =IF(A8<A7,"KEEP","")
876000 A KEEP
876000 B
876001 A KEEP
876001 B
876002 A KEEP
876002 B
876003 A KEEP
876004 A KEEP
876005 A KEEP
876006 A KEEP
876007 A KEEP
876008 A KEEP
The formula depicted is copied down thru Part Number 876008, and depicts
the
relative cells.

But you'll notice that for PNs 876000 thru 876002 the wrong revision is
depicted as a "KEEP".

I dunno what's happening in my sheet. Your sheet looks good.

Dave

"T. Valko" wrote:

Hmmm...

The results I get are not the same as the results you've posted.

Here's a small sample file that demonstrates this:

xMarkOld.xls 14kb

http://cjoint.com/?gzxPE2vUKA

In column C I've entered the formula but changed the "x" to "Keep"
meaning,
keep this record.

Column D shows the "x" that you posted in your sample. As you'll see the
"keeps" are in the correct places.

--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Dave" wrote in message
...
Biff,

Thanks for the input. This works well, except for the part numbers
which
have only one revision. Then, in those cases, an "X" is placed in the
column, making the sort be the same as for lower revisions of a part
which
has several revisions.
Example:
TEST A X
TEST B
TEST A00
400078 A X
846261 A00 X
876000 A X
876000 B
876001 A X
876001 B
876002 A X
876002 B
876003 A X
876004 A X
876005 A X
876006 A X
876007 A X
876008 A X
876008 B

In the above exceprt, PNs 876004, 876005, 876006 (which have only one
revision)have X's where PN 87008 has an X for the lower revision and a
blank
for the higher revision (B). I need to have 874004,876005,876006
return
the
same value in column C as 876008 revision B.

Thanks,

Dave
"T. Valko" wrote:

Maybe this if you want to get rid of the old data and only keep the
most
recent data (assuming that your data is sorted as is shown in your
sample).

Enter this formula in colun C and copy down to the end of data:

=IF(A3<A2,"x","")

The "x" will mark the latest revision.

Now, convert the formulas to constants:

Select the range of formulas in column C.
Goto EditCopy
Then, EditPaste SpecialValuesOK

Now, sort the entire range on column C in descending order. This will
put
all the latest revisions at the top.

Find the last "x" and delete everything after it. Then delete column
C.


--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Dave" wrote in message
...
I searched the posts, but didn't find anything obvious that would
work
in
my
situation.

I have a list of part numbers in column A, and their revisions in
column
B.
One part number can have 1 or more revisions. I'd like to find the
latest
revision for each part number in column A. My list looks like:

PART NUMBER Revision
1120007 A
1120007 B00
5360120 A00
5360120 A01
5360120 D00
and so on

I have 51,000+ rows of data, and would like to summarize by finding
only
the
latest revisions of the parts- in this case it would be B00 for PN
1120007
and D00 for PN 5360120. I can probably boil down that 51,000 part
number
rows to 3,000 to 4,000.

I sense it would be pretty simple, but I'm a relative novice when it
comes
to Excel.

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Dave








  #10   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,388
Default Find max value in one column based on another column

Biff,

No, in my example, I just showed what the value was in cell D8. In cell D7
(for the row containing PN 400078) the formula is =IF (A7<A6,"KEEP","").
All the other rows have the same relative formula.

Sorry for making it confusing....

Dave

"T. Valko" wrote:

I suspect you're putting the formula in the wrong row. If your data starts
in A7 then put the formula in C7 then copy down.

=IF(A8<A7,"KEEP","")

--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Dave" wrote in message
...
Hi, Biff-

I re-did the formula to specify "KEEP" and got the following result.

The formula used is depicted in column D:
PN REV FORMULA
400078 A KEEP
846261 A00 KEEP =IF(A8<A7,"KEEP","")
876000 A KEEP
876000 B
876001 A KEEP
876001 B
876002 A KEEP
876002 B
876003 A KEEP
876004 A KEEP
876005 A KEEP
876006 A KEEP
876007 A KEEP
876008 A KEEP
The formula depicted is copied down thru Part Number 876008, and depicts
the
relative cells.

But you'll notice that for PNs 876000 thru 876002 the wrong revision is
depicted as a "KEEP".

I dunno what's happening in my sheet. Your sheet looks good.

Dave

"T. Valko" wrote:

Hmmm...

The results I get are not the same as the results you've posted.

Here's a small sample file that demonstrates this:

xMarkOld.xls 14kb

http://cjoint.com/?gzxPE2vUKA

In column C I've entered the formula but changed the "x" to "Keep"
meaning,
keep this record.

Column D shows the "x" that you posted in your sample. As you'll see the
"keeps" are in the correct places.

--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Dave" wrote in message
...
Biff,

Thanks for the input. This works well, except for the part numbers
which
have only one revision. Then, in those cases, an "X" is placed in the
column, making the sort be the same as for lower revisions of a part
which
has several revisions.
Example:
TEST A X
TEST B
TEST A00
400078 A X
846261 A00 X
876000 A X
876000 B
876001 A X
876001 B
876002 A X
876002 B
876003 A X
876004 A X
876005 A X
876006 A X
876007 A X
876008 A X
876008 B

In the above exceprt, PNs 876004, 876005, 876006 (which have only one
revision)have X's where PN 87008 has an X for the lower revision and a
blank
for the higher revision (B). I need to have 874004,876005,876006
return
the
same value in column C as 876008 revision B.

Thanks,

Dave
"T. Valko" wrote:

Maybe this if you want to get rid of the old data and only keep the
most
recent data (assuming that your data is sorted as is shown in your
sample).

Enter this formula in colun C and copy down to the end of data:

=IF(A3<A2,"x","")

The "x" will mark the latest revision.

Now, convert the formulas to constants:

Select the range of formulas in column C.
Goto EditCopy
Then, EditPaste SpecialValuesOK

Now, sort the entire range on column C in descending order. This will
put
all the latest revisions at the top.

Find the last "x" and delete everything after it. Then delete column
C.


--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Dave" wrote in message
...
I searched the posts, but didn't find anything obvious that would
work
in
my
situation.

I have a list of part numbers in column A, and their revisions in
column
B.
One part number can have 1 or more revisions. I'd like to find the
latest
revision for each part number in column A. My list looks like:

PART NUMBER Revision
1120007 A
1120007 B00
5360120 A00
5360120 A01
5360120 D00
and so on

I have 51,000+ rows of data, and would like to summarize by finding
only
the
latest revisions of the parts- in this case it would be B00 for PN
1120007
and D00 for PN 5360120. I can probably boil down that 51,000 part
number
rows to 3,000 to 4,000.

I sense it would be pretty simple, but I'm a relative novice when it
comes
to Excel.

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Dave











  #11   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 15,768
Default Find max value in one column based on another column

Well, I don't know what's happening. At this point I'm out of "efficient"
suggestions.

If you have 60,000 rows of data what I'm about to suggest will take forever
to calculate. It may even lock-up Excel or your computer.

=IF(COUNTIF(A$1:A$60000,A1)=COUNTIF(A$1:A1,A1),"x" ,"")

Copied down. Personally, I would not attempt that!

What you could do is every so many rows "reset" the formula by resetting the
referenced range at a change in the pn.

For example:

This formula entered in C1:C1000 -

=IF(COUNTIF(A$1:A$1000,A1)=COUNTIF(A$1:A1,A1),"x", "")

This formula entered in C1001:C2000 -

=IF(COUNTIF(A$1001:A$2000,A1001)=COUNTIF(A$1001:A1 001,A1001),"x","")

Then follow that pattern until your done.

--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Dave" wrote in message
...
Biff,

No, in my example, I just showed what the value was in cell D8. In cell
D7
(for the row containing PN 400078) the formula is =IF (A7<A6,"KEEP","").
All the other rows have the same relative formula.

Sorry for making it confusing....

Dave

"T. Valko" wrote:

I suspect you're putting the formula in the wrong row. If your data
starts
in A7 then put the formula in C7 then copy down.

=IF(A8<A7,"KEEP","")

--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Dave" wrote in message
...
Hi, Biff-

I re-did the formula to specify "KEEP" and got the following result.

The formula used is depicted in column D:
PN REV FORMULA
400078 A KEEP
846261 A00 KEEP =IF(A8<A7,"KEEP","")
876000 A KEEP
876000 B
876001 A KEEP
876001 B
876002 A KEEP
876002 B
876003 A KEEP
876004 A KEEP
876005 A KEEP
876006 A KEEP
876007 A KEEP
876008 A KEEP
The formula depicted is copied down thru Part Number 876008, and
depicts
the
relative cells.

But you'll notice that for PNs 876000 thru 876002 the wrong revision is
depicted as a "KEEP".

I dunno what's happening in my sheet. Your sheet looks good.

Dave

"T. Valko" wrote:

Hmmm...

The results I get are not the same as the results you've posted.

Here's a small sample file that demonstrates this:

xMarkOld.xls 14kb

http://cjoint.com/?gzxPE2vUKA

In column C I've entered the formula but changed the "x" to "Keep"
meaning,
keep this record.

Column D shows the "x" that you posted in your sample. As you'll see
the
"keeps" are in the correct places.

--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Dave" wrote in message
...
Biff,

Thanks for the input. This works well, except for the part numbers
which
have only one revision. Then, in those cases, an "X" is placed in
the
column, making the sort be the same as for lower revisions of a part
which
has several revisions.
Example:
TEST A X
TEST B
TEST A00
400078 A X
846261 A00 X
876000 A X
876000 B
876001 A X
876001 B
876002 A X
876002 B
876003 A X
876004 A X
876005 A X
876006 A X
876007 A X
876008 A X
876008 B

In the above exceprt, PNs 876004, 876005, 876006 (which have only
one
revision)have X's where PN 87008 has an X for the lower revision and
a
blank
for the higher revision (B). I need to have 874004,876005,876006
return
the
same value in column C as 876008 revision B.

Thanks,

Dave
"T. Valko" wrote:

Maybe this if you want to get rid of the old data and only keep the
most
recent data (assuming that your data is sorted as is shown in your
sample).

Enter this formula in colun C and copy down to the end of data:

=IF(A3<A2,"x","")

The "x" will mark the latest revision.

Now, convert the formulas to constants:

Select the range of formulas in column C.
Goto EditCopy
Then, EditPaste SpecialValuesOK

Now, sort the entire range on column C in descending order. This
will
put
all the latest revisions at the top.

Find the last "x" and delete everything after it. Then delete
column
C.


--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Dave" wrote in message
...
I searched the posts, but didn't find anything obvious that would
work
in
my
situation.

I have a list of part numbers in column A, and their revisions in
column
B.
One part number can have 1 or more revisions. I'd like to find
the
latest
revision for each part number in column A. My list looks like:

PART NUMBER Revision
1120007 A
1120007 B00
5360120 A00
5360120 A01
5360120 D00
and so on

I have 51,000+ rows of data, and would like to summarize by
finding
only
the
latest revisions of the parts- in this case it would be B00 for
PN
1120007
and D00 for PN 5360120. I can probably boil down that 51,000
part
number
rows to 3,000 to 4,000.

I sense it would be pretty simple, but I'm a relative novice when
it
comes
to Excel.

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Dave











  #12   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,388
Default Find max value in one column based on another column

Biff,

You were right! I was putting the formula one row too low. My bad! Works
great now. Thanks for your patience!

Dave

"T. Valko" wrote:

I suspect you're putting the formula in the wrong row. If your data starts
in A7 then put the formula in C7 then copy down.

=IF(A8<A7,"KEEP","")

--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Dave" wrote in message
...
Hi, Biff-

I re-did the formula to specify "KEEP" and got the following result.

The formula used is depicted in column D:
PN REV FORMULA
400078 A KEEP
846261 A00 KEEP =IF(A8<A7,"KEEP","")
876000 A KEEP
876000 B
876001 A KEEP
876001 B
876002 A KEEP
876002 B
876003 A KEEP
876004 A KEEP
876005 A KEEP
876006 A KEEP
876007 A KEEP
876008 A KEEP
The formula depicted is copied down thru Part Number 876008, and depicts
the
relative cells.

But you'll notice that for PNs 876000 thru 876002 the wrong revision is
depicted as a "KEEP".

I dunno what's happening in my sheet. Your sheet looks good.

Dave

"T. Valko" wrote:

Hmmm...

The results I get are not the same as the results you've posted.

Here's a small sample file that demonstrates this:

xMarkOld.xls 14kb

http://cjoint.com/?gzxPE2vUKA

In column C I've entered the formula but changed the "x" to "Keep"
meaning,
keep this record.

Column D shows the "x" that you posted in your sample. As you'll see the
"keeps" are in the correct places.

--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Dave" wrote in message
...
Biff,

Thanks for the input. This works well, except for the part numbers
which
have only one revision. Then, in those cases, an "X" is placed in the
column, making the sort be the same as for lower revisions of a part
which
has several revisions.
Example:
TEST A X
TEST B
TEST A00
400078 A X
846261 A00 X
876000 A X
876000 B
876001 A X
876001 B
876002 A X
876002 B
876003 A X
876004 A X
876005 A X
876006 A X
876007 A X
876008 A X
876008 B

In the above exceprt, PNs 876004, 876005, 876006 (which have only one
revision)have X's where PN 87008 has an X for the lower revision and a
blank
for the higher revision (B). I need to have 874004,876005,876006
return
the
same value in column C as 876008 revision B.

Thanks,

Dave
"T. Valko" wrote:

Maybe this if you want to get rid of the old data and only keep the
most
recent data (assuming that your data is sorted as is shown in your
sample).

Enter this formula in colun C and copy down to the end of data:

=IF(A3<A2,"x","")

The "x" will mark the latest revision.

Now, convert the formulas to constants:

Select the range of formulas in column C.
Goto EditCopy
Then, EditPaste SpecialValuesOK

Now, sort the entire range on column C in descending order. This will
put
all the latest revisions at the top.

Find the last "x" and delete everything after it. Then delete column
C.


--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Dave" wrote in message
...
I searched the posts, but didn't find anything obvious that would
work
in
my
situation.

I have a list of part numbers in column A, and their revisions in
column
B.
One part number can have 1 or more revisions. I'd like to find the
latest
revision for each part number in column A. My list looks like:

PART NUMBER Revision
1120007 A
1120007 B00
5360120 A00
5360120 A01
5360120 D00
and so on

I have 51,000+ rows of data, and would like to summarize by finding
only
the
latest revisions of the parts- in this case it would be B00 for PN
1120007
and D00 for PN 5360120. I can probably boil down that 51,000 part
number
rows to 3,000 to 4,000.

I sense it would be pretty simple, but I'm a relative novice when it
comes
to Excel.

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Dave









  #13   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 15,768
Default Find max value in one column based on another column

OK, good deal! Thanks for feeding back.

--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Dave" wrote in message
...
Biff,

You were right! I was putting the formula one row too low. My bad!
Works
great now. Thanks for your patience!

Dave

"T. Valko" wrote:

I suspect you're putting the formula in the wrong row. If your data
starts
in A7 then put the formula in C7 then copy down.

=IF(A8<A7,"KEEP","")

--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Dave" wrote in message
...
Hi, Biff-

I re-did the formula to specify "KEEP" and got the following result.

The formula used is depicted in column D:
PN REV FORMULA
400078 A KEEP
846261 A00 KEEP =IF(A8<A7,"KEEP","")
876000 A KEEP
876000 B
876001 A KEEP
876001 B
876002 A KEEP
876002 B
876003 A KEEP
876004 A KEEP
876005 A KEEP
876006 A KEEP
876007 A KEEP
876008 A KEEP
The formula depicted is copied down thru Part Number 876008, and
depicts
the
relative cells.

But you'll notice that for PNs 876000 thru 876002 the wrong revision is
depicted as a "KEEP".

I dunno what's happening in my sheet. Your sheet looks good.

Dave

"T. Valko" wrote:

Hmmm...

The results I get are not the same as the results you've posted.

Here's a small sample file that demonstrates this:

xMarkOld.xls 14kb

http://cjoint.com/?gzxPE2vUKA

In column C I've entered the formula but changed the "x" to "Keep"
meaning,
keep this record.

Column D shows the "x" that you posted in your sample. As you'll see
the
"keeps" are in the correct places.

--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Dave" wrote in message
...
Biff,

Thanks for the input. This works well, except for the part numbers
which
have only one revision. Then, in those cases, an "X" is placed in
the
column, making the sort be the same as for lower revisions of a part
which
has several revisions.
Example:
TEST A X
TEST B
TEST A00
400078 A X
846261 A00 X
876000 A X
876000 B
876001 A X
876001 B
876002 A X
876002 B
876003 A X
876004 A X
876005 A X
876006 A X
876007 A X
876008 A X
876008 B

In the above exceprt, PNs 876004, 876005, 876006 (which have only
one
revision)have X's where PN 87008 has an X for the lower revision and
a
blank
for the higher revision (B). I need to have 874004,876005,876006
return
the
same value in column C as 876008 revision B.

Thanks,

Dave
"T. Valko" wrote:

Maybe this if you want to get rid of the old data and only keep the
most
recent data (assuming that your data is sorted as is shown in your
sample).

Enter this formula in colun C and copy down to the end of data:

=IF(A3<A2,"x","")

The "x" will mark the latest revision.

Now, convert the formulas to constants:

Select the range of formulas in column C.
Goto EditCopy
Then, EditPaste SpecialValuesOK

Now, sort the entire range on column C in descending order. This
will
put
all the latest revisions at the top.

Find the last "x" and delete everything after it. Then delete
column
C.


--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Dave" wrote in message
...
I searched the posts, but didn't find anything obvious that would
work
in
my
situation.

I have a list of part numbers in column A, and their revisions in
column
B.
One part number can have 1 or more revisions. I'd like to find
the
latest
revision for each part number in column A. My list looks like:

PART NUMBER Revision
1120007 A
1120007 B00
5360120 A00
5360120 A01
5360120 D00
and so on

I have 51,000+ rows of data, and would like to summarize by
finding
only
the
latest revisions of the parts- in this case it would be B00 for
PN
1120007
and D00 for PN 5360120. I can probably boil down that 51,000
part
number
rows to 3,000 to 4,000.

I sense it would be pretty simple, but I'm a relative novice when
it
comes
to Excel.

Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Dave











Reply
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Count number of cells and total in one column, based on another column suffix Pierre Excel Worksheet Functions 5 October 31st 07 12:28 AM
Based on a condition in one column, search for a year in another column, and display data from another column in the same row look [email protected] Excel Discussion (Misc queries) 1 December 27th 06 05:47 PM
How to find the most recent date in a column based on other column Veretax Excel Worksheet Functions 7 October 18th 06 05:01 PM
Find and sum values based on a column search Chocolate-Thunder Excel Discussion (Misc queries) 3 August 9th 06 05:11 PM
Find a time value in one column based on names in another Robert Excel Discussion (Misc queries) 1 January 6th 06 01:33 PM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:37 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 ExcelBanter.
The comments are property of their posters.
 

About Us

"It's about Microsoft Excel"