#2   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1,231
Default formula too long

"manman" wrote...
I need to have 2 mores options (ie HVAC_4 & HVAC_5)I am aware that I am
limited to 256 characters and making the range names smaller may help,
however is there another way of doing this that may eliminate the
limitation.

....

[reformatted]
=IF(
OR(
X$9=(DATE(YEAR(Budget_year),MONTH(Budget_year)+3,1 )),
X$9=(DATE(YEAR(Budget_year),MONTH(Budget_year)+6,1 )),
X$9=(DATE(YEAR(Budget_year),MONTH(Budget_year)+9,1 )),
X$9=Budget_year
)*AND(contract!$E12="Quarterly"),
HVAC_1/4,
IF(
contract!$E12="monthly",
HVAC_1/12,
IF(
AND(
contract!$F12=X$9,
contract!$E12="annual"
),
HVAC_1,
0
)
)
)
+IF(
OR(
X$9=(DATE(YEAR(Budget_year),MONTH(Budget_year)+3,1 )),
X$9=(DATE(YEAR(Budget_year),MONTH(Budget_year)+6,1 )),
X$9=(DATE(YEAR(Budget_year),MONTH(Budget_year)+9,1 )),
X$9=Budget_year
)*AND(contract!$E13="Quarterly"),
HVAC_2/4,
IF(
contract!$E13="monthly",
HVAC_2/12,
IF(
AND(
contract!$F13=X$9,
contract!$E13="annual"
),
HVAC_2
)
)
)
+IF(
OR(
X$9=(DATE(YEAR(Budget_year),MONTH(Budget_year)+3,1 )),
X$9=(DATE(YEAR(Budget_year),MONTH(Budget_year)+6,1 )),
X$9=(DATE(YEAR(Budget_year),MONTH(Budget_year)+9,1 )),
X$9=Budget_year
)*AND(contract!$E14="Quarterly"),
HVAC_3/4,
IF(
contract!$E14="monthly",
HVAC_3/12,
IF(
AND(
contract!$F14=X$9,
contract!$E14="annual"
),
HVAC_3
)
)
)


You're performing the longest test once for each HVAC_#. That's where you
should start to make the formula shorter.


=IF(
OR(
X$9=(DATE(YEAR(Budget_year),MONTH(Budget_year)+3,1 )),
X$9=(DATE(YEAR(Budget_year),MONTH(Budget_year)+6,1 )),
X$9=(DATE(YEAR(Budget_year),MONTH(Budget_year)+9,1 )),
X$9=Budget_year
),
IF(contract!$E12="Quarterly",HVAC_1/4,0)
+IF(contract!$E13="Quarterly",HVAC_2/4,0)
+IF(contract!$E14="Quarterly",HVAC_3/4,0)
+IF(contract!$E15="Quarterly",HVAC_4/4,0)
+IF(contract!$E16="Quarterly",HVAC_5/4,0),
0
)
+IF(contract!$E12="monthly",HVAC_1/12,0)
+IF(contract!$E13="monthly",HVAC_2/12,0)
+IF(contract!$E14="monthly",HVAC_3/12,0)
+IF(contract!$E15="monthly",HVAC_4/12,0)
+IF(contract!$E16="monthly",HVAC_5/12,0)
+IF(AND(contract!$F12=X$9,contract!$E12="annual"), HVAC_1,0)
+IF(AND(contract!$F13=X$9,contract!$E13="annual"), HVAC_2,0)
+IF(AND(contract!$F14=X$9,contract!$E14="annual"), HVAC_3,0)
+IF(AND(contract!$F15=X$9,contract!$E15="annual"), HVAC_4,0)
+IF(AND(contract!$F16=X$9,contract!$E16="annual"), HVAC_5,0)


953 characters, but that could be improved upon since there's a lot of
redundancy in these terms. Also, get rid of the unnecessary parentheses.


=SUMPRODUCT(({1;0;0;0;0}*HVAC_1+{0;1;0;0;0}*HVAC_2 +{0;0;1;0;0}*HVAC_3
+{0;0;0;1;0}*HVAC_4+{0;0;0;0;1}*HVAC_5)*((X$9=DATE (YEAR(Budget_year),
MONTH(Budget_year)+{0,3,6,9},DAY(Budget_year)^{1,0 ,0,0}))
*(contract!$E12:$E16="Quarterly")+(contract!$E12:$ E16="monthly")/12
+(contract!$F12:$F16=X$9)*(contract!$E12:$E16="ann ual"))/4)


Also, if you're entering this formula in a cell in the contract worksheet,
you could delete the unnecessary references to it.


=SUMPRODUCT(({1;0;0;0;0}*HVAC_1+{0;1;0;0;0}*HVAC_2 +{0;0;1;0;0}*HVAC_3
+{0;0;0;1;0}*HVAC_4+{0;0;0;0;1}*HVAC_5)*((X$9=DATE (YEAR(Budget_year),
MONTH(Budget_year)+{0,3,6,9},DAY(Budget_year)^{1,0 ,0,0}))
*($E12:$E16="Quarterly")+($E12:$E16="monthly")/12
+($F12:$F16=X$9)*($E12:$E16="annual"))/4)


Reply
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Clearing cells takes long, long time unclemuffin Excel Discussion (Misc queries) 9 August 17th 07 02:22 AM
Formula is too long jai Excel Discussion (Misc queries) 2 June 6th 07 01:33 PM
Formula too long JaB Excel Discussion (Misc queries) 6 January 22nd 07 06:30 PM
formula is too long monkey1 Excel Worksheet Functions 4 October 11th 06 06:36 PM
long formula Jane Excel Worksheet Functions 8 January 10th 05 09:36 AM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 08:21 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 ExcelBanter.
The comments are property of their posters.
 

About Us

"It's about Microsoft Excel"