I have a survey form where users can rate corporate performance. It is made
up of radio buttons to rank efficiency. i designed it to prevent closing and
printing if the answers are too skewed (we need 3 5's, 2 4'2 , etc) It works
fine the first time you open the file. However, if you change your answers
(say, rated it 4 and then want to change the rating to 3), the code stops
working.

Why is this? How can I solve this issue?

Thanks so much,
Michelle K

Can you post your code? Hard to know without seeing it.

"Michelle K" wrote:

I have a survey form where users can rate corporate performance. It is made
up of radio buttons to rank efficiency. i designed it to prevent closing and
printing if the answers are too skewed (we need 3 5's, 2 4'2 , etc) It works
fine the first time you open the file. However, if you change your answers
(say, rated it 4 and then want to change the rating to 3), the code stops
working.

Why is this? How can I solve this issue?

Thanks so much,
Michelle K

Show the code and indicate where it goes wrong might be a start.

--
HTH

Bob Phillips

"Michelle K" wrote in message
...
I have a survey form where users can rate corporate performance. It is
made
up of radio buttons to rank efficiency. i designed it to prevent closing
and
printing if the answers are too skewed (we need 3 5's, 2 4'2 , etc) It
works
fine the first time you open the file. However, if you change your
answers
(say, rated it 4 and then want to change the rating to 3), the code stops
working.

Why is this? How can I solve this issue?

Thanks so much,
Michelle K

Here is the code:

Private Sub Workbook_BeforeClose(Cancel As Boolean)


If (Range("C27") < 3 And Range("D27") < 2 And Range("E27") < 1 And
Range("F27") < 2 And Range("G27") < 3 _
And Range("I27") < 3 And Range("J27") < 2 And Range("K27") < 1 And
Range("L27") < 2 And Range("M27") < 3 _
And Range("C42") < 2 And Range("D42") < 2 And Range("E42") < 1 And
Range("F42") < 2 And Range("G42") < 2 _
And Range("I42") < 2 And Range("J42") < 2 And Range("K42") < 1 And
Range("L42") < 2 And Range("M42") < 2 _
And Range("C57") < 2 And Range("D57") < 2 And Range("E57") < 1 And
Range("F57") < 2 And Range("G57") < 2 _
And Range("I57") < 2 And Range("J57") < 2 And Range("K57") < 1 And
Range("L57") < 2 And Range("M57") < 2) Then
MsgBox "You must complete the survey before closing." _
& " Please note the number of selections required per action.",
vbExclamation, "CANNOT CLOSE"
Cancel = True
End If

End Sub

it's a simple code that just prevents the user from closing Excel without
answering the survey accordingly. It runs once and after that it doesn't
anymore.

"K Dales" wrote:

Can you post your code? Hard to know without seeing it.

"Michelle K" wrote:

I have a survey form where users can rate corporate performance. It is made
up of radio buttons to rank efficiency. i designed it to prevent closing and
printing if the answers are too skewed (we need 3 5's, 2 4'2 , etc) It works
fine the first time you open the file. However, if you change your answers
(say, rated it 4 and then want to change the rating to 3), the code stops
working.

Why is this? How can I solve this issue?

Thanks so much,
Michelle K

Do you have other event related code where you disable events

Application.EnableEvents = False

It sounds like events are getting disabled and never reenabled.

--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy

"Michelle K" wrote in message
...
Here is the code:

Private Sub Workbook_BeforeClose(Cancel As Boolean)


If (Range("C27") < 3 And Range("D27") < 2 And Range("E27") < 1 And
Range("F27") < 2 And Range("G27") < 3 _
And Range("I27") < 3 And Range("J27") < 2 And Range("K27") < 1 And
Range("L27") < 2 And Range("M27") < 3 _
And Range("C42") < 2 And Range("D42") < 2 And Range("E42") < 1 And
Range("F42") < 2 And Range("G42") < 2 _
And Range("I42") < 2 And Range("J42") < 2 And Range("K42") < 1 And
Range("L42") < 2 And Range("M42") < 2 _
And Range("C57") < 2 And Range("D57") < 2 And Range("E57") < 1 And
Range("F57") < 2 And Range("G57") < 2 _
And Range("I57") < 2 And Range("J57") < 2 And Range("K57") < 1 And
Range("L57") < 2 And Range("M57") < 2) Then
MsgBox "You must complete the survey before closing." _
& " Please note the number of selections required per action.",
vbExclamation, "CANNOT CLOSE"
Cancel = True
End If

End Sub

it's a simple code that just prevents the user from closing Excel without
answering the survey accordingly. It runs once and after that it doesn't
anymore.

"K Dales" wrote:

Can you post your code? Hard to know without seeing it.

"Michelle K" wrote:

I have a survey form where users can rate corporate performance. It
is made
up of radio buttons to rank efficiency. i designed it to prevent
closing and
printing if the answers are too skewed (we need 3 5's, 2 4'2 , etc)
It works
fine the first time you open the file. However, if you change your
answers
(say, rated it 4 and then want to change the rating to 3), the code
stops
working.

Why is this? How can I solve this issue?

Thanks so much,
Michelle K

I do not have Excel on this machine, so I can't test this theory, but
is it because "Cancel=True". When the code runs a second time, is
Cancel still set to true?

You have put it in Thisworkbook code module?

--

HTH

RP
(remove nothere from the email address if mailing direct)


"Michelle K" wrote in message
...
Here is the code:

Private Sub Workbook_BeforeClose(Cancel As Boolean)


If (Range("C27") < 3 And Range("D27") < 2 And Range("E27") < 1 And
Range("F27") < 2 And Range("G27") < 3 _
And Range("I27") < 3 And Range("J27") < 2 And Range("K27") < 1 And
Range("L27") < 2 And Range("M27") < 3 _
And Range("C42") < 2 And Range("D42") < 2 And Range("E42") < 1 And
Range("F42") < 2 And Range("G42") < 2 _
And Range("I42") < 2 And Range("J42") < 2 And Range("K42") < 1 And
Range("L42") < 2 And Range("M42") < 2 _
And Range("C57") < 2 And Range("D57") < 2 And Range("E57") < 1 And
Range("F57") < 2 And Range("G57") < 2 _
And Range("I57") < 2 And Range("J57") < 2 And Range("K57") < 1 And
Range("L57") < 2 And Range("M57") < 2) Then
MsgBox "You must complete the survey before closing." _
& " Please note the number of selections required per action.",
vbExclamation, "CANNOT CLOSE"
Cancel = True
End If

End Sub

it's a simple code that just prevents the user from closing Excel without
answering the survey accordingly. It runs once and after that it doesn't
anymore.

"K Dales" wrote:

Can you post your code? Hard to know without seeing it.

"Michelle K" wrote:

I have a survey form where users can rate corporate performance. It
is made
up of radio buttons to rank efficiency. i designed it to prevent
closing and
printing if the answers are too skewed (we need 3 5's, 2 4'2 , etc)
It works
fine the first time you open the file. However, if you change your
answers
(say, rated it 4 and then want to change the rating to 3), the code
stops
working.

Why is this? How can I solve this issue?

Thanks so much,
Michelle K

I tried adding these lines but they don't seem to be working:

Public Sub ResetEvents()

Application.EnableEvents = True

End Sub

Private Sub Worksheet_SelectionChange(ByVal Target As Range)

Application.EnableEvents = True

End Sub

I am sure I am missing something or have written these under the wrong
events. Help!

"Tom Ogilvy" wrote:

Do you have other event related code where you disable events

Application.EnableEvents = False

It sounds like events are getting disabled and never reenabled.

--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy

"Michelle K" wrote in message
...
Here is the code:

Private Sub Workbook_BeforeClose(Cancel As Boolean)


If (Range("C27") < 3 And Range("D27") < 2 And Range("E27") < 1 And
Range("F27") < 2 And Range("G27") < 3 _
And Range("I27") < 3 And Range("J27") < 2 And Range("K27") < 1 And
Range("L27") < 2 And Range("M27") < 3 _
And Range("C42") < 2 And Range("D42") < 2 And Range("E42") < 1 And
Range("F42") < 2 And Range("G42") < 2 _
And Range("I42") < 2 And Range("J42") < 2 And Range("K42") < 1 And
Range("L42") < 2 And Range("M42") < 2 _
And Range("C57") < 2 And Range("D57") < 2 And Range("E57") < 1 And
Range("F57") < 2 And Range("G57") < 2 _
And Range("I57") < 2 And Range("J57") < 2 And Range("K57") < 1 And
Range("L57") < 2 And Range("M57") < 2) Then
MsgBox "You must complete the survey before closing." _
& " Please note the number of selections required per action.",
vbExclamation, "CANNOT CLOSE"
Cancel = True
End If

End Sub

it's a simple code that just prevents the user from closing Excel without
answering the survey accordingly. It runs once and after that it doesn't
anymore.

"K Dales" wrote:

Can you post your code? Hard to know without seeing it.

"Michelle K" wrote:

I have a survey form where users can rate corporate performance. It
is made
up of radio buttons to rank efficiency. i designed it to prevent
closing and
printing if the answers are too skewed (we need 3 5's, 2 4'2 , etc)
It works
fine the first time you open the file. However, if you change your
answers
(say, rated it 4 and then want to change the rating to 3), the code
stops
working.

Why is this? How can I solve this issue?

Thanks so much,
Michelle K

If events are disabled, your second procedure will never get triggered.

Are you sure it doesn't run. Perhaps the condition doesn't warrant a
message box?

Try putting in a msgbox at the top (temporarily

Private Sub Workbook_BeforeClose(Cancel As Boolean)
MsgBox "In workbook Close"

If (Range("C27") < 3 And Range("D27") < 2 And Range("E27") < 1 And
Range("F27") < 2 And Range("G27") < 3 _
And Range("I27") < 3 And Range("J27") < 2 And Range("K27") < 1 And
Range("L27") < 2 And Range("M27") < 3 _
And Range("C42") < 2 And Range("D42") < 2 And Range("E42") < 1 And
Range("F42") < 2 And Range("G42") < 2 _
And Range("I42") < 2 And Range("J42") < 2 And Range("K42") < 1 And
Range("L42") < 2 And Range("M42") < 2 _
And Range("C57") < 2 And Range("D57") < 2 And Range("E57") < 1 And
Range("F57") < 2 And Range("G57") < 2 _
And Range("I57") < 2 And Range("J57") < 2 And Range("K57") < 1 And
Range("L57") < 2 And Range("M57") < 2) Then
MsgBox "You must complete the survey before closing." _
& " Please note the number of selections required per action.",
vbExclamation, "CANNOT CLOSE"
Cancel = True
End If

End Sub

You will need to save the workbook to retain the code modification.
--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy


"Michelle K" wrote in message
...
I tried adding these lines but they don't seem to be working:

Public Sub ResetEvents()

Application.EnableEvents = True

End Sub

Private Sub Worksheet_SelectionChange(ByVal Target As Range)

Application.EnableEvents = True

End Sub

I am sure I am missing something or have written these under the wrong
events. Help!

"Tom Ogilvy" wrote:

Do you have other event related code where you disable events

Application.EnableEvents = False

It sounds like events are getting disabled and never reenabled.

--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy

"Michelle K" wrote in message
...
Here is the code:

Private Sub Workbook_BeforeClose(Cancel As Boolean)


If (Range("C27") < 3 And Range("D27") < 2 And Range("E27") < 1 And
Range("F27") < 2 And Range("G27") < 3 _
And Range("I27") < 3 And Range("J27") < 2 And Range("K27") < 1 And
Range("L27") < 2 And Range("M27") < 3 _
And Range("C42") < 2 And Range("D42") < 2 And Range("E42") < 1 And
Range("F42") < 2 And Range("G42") < 2 _
And Range("I42") < 2 And Range("J42") < 2 And Range("K42") < 1 And
Range("L42") < 2 And Range("M42") < 2 _
And Range("C57") < 2 And Range("D57") < 2 And Range("E57") < 1 And
Range("F57") < 2 And Range("G57") < 2 _
And Range("I57") < 2 And Range("J57") < 2 And Range("K57") < 1 And
Range("L57") < 2 And Range("M57") < 2) Then
MsgBox "You must complete the survey before closing." _
& " Please note the number of selections required per action.",
vbExclamation, "CANNOT CLOSE"
Cancel = True
End If

End Sub

it's a simple code that just prevents the user from closing Excel
without
answering the survey accordingly. It runs once and after that it
doesn't
anymore.

"K Dales" wrote:

Can you post your code? Hard to know without seeing it.

"Michelle K" wrote:

I have a survey form where users can rate corporate performance.
It
is made
up of radio buttons to rank efficiency. i designed it to prevent
closing and
printing if the answers are too skewed (we need 3 5's, 2 4'2 ,
etc)
It works
fine the first time you open the file. However, if you change
your
answers
(say, rated it 4 and then want to change the rating to 3), the
code
stops
working.

Why is this? How can I solve this issue?

Thanks so much,
Michelle K

No that is an event argument to stop the close event happening.

--
HTH

Bob Phillips

"p.hall" wrote in message
oups.com...
I do not have Excel on this machine, so I can't test this theory, but
is it because "Cancel=True". When the code runs a second time, is
Cancel still set to true?

I added a message box into the top of the code and it worked - meaning, it is
reading the code. How come then that it isn't evaluating the condition
anymore?

"Tom Ogilvy" wrote:

If events are disabled, your second procedure will never get triggered.

Are you sure it doesn't run. Perhaps the condition doesn't warrant a
message box?

Try putting in a msgbox at the top (temporarily

Private Sub Workbook_BeforeClose(Cancel As Boolean)
MsgBox "In workbook Close"

If (Range("C27") < 3 And Range("D27") < 2 And Range("E27") < 1 And
Range("F27") < 2 And Range("G27") < 3 _
And Range("I27") < 3 And Range("J27") < 2 And Range("K27") < 1 And
Range("L27") < 2 And Range("M27") < 3 _
And Range("C42") < 2 And Range("D42") < 2 And Range("E42") < 1 And
Range("F42") < 2 And Range("G42") < 2 _
And Range("I42") < 2 And Range("J42") < 2 And Range("K42") < 1 And
Range("L42") < 2 And Range("M42") < 2 _
And Range("C57") < 2 And Range("D57") < 2 And Range("E57") < 1 And
Range("F57") < 2 And Range("G57") < 2 _
And Range("I57") < 2 And Range("J57") < 2 And Range("K57") < 1 And
Range("L57") < 2 And Range("M57") < 2) Then
MsgBox "You must complete the survey before closing." _
& " Please note the number of selections required per action.",
vbExclamation, "CANNOT CLOSE"
Cancel = True
End If

End Sub

You will need to save the workbook to retain the code modification.
--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy


"Michelle K" wrote in message
...
I tried adding these lines but they don't seem to be working:

Public Sub ResetEvents()

Application.EnableEvents = True

End Sub

Private Sub Worksheet_SelectionChange(ByVal Target As Range)

Application.EnableEvents = True

End Sub

I am sure I am missing something or have written these under the wrong
events. Help!

"Tom Ogilvy" wrote:

Do you have other event related code where you disable events

Application.EnableEvents = False

It sounds like events are getting disabled and never reenabled.

--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy

"Michelle K" wrote in message
...
Here is the code:

Private Sub Workbook_BeforeClose(Cancel As Boolean)


If (Range("C27") < 3 And Range("D27") < 2 And Range("E27") < 1 And
Range("F27") < 2 And Range("G27") < 3 _
And Range("I27") < 3 And Range("J27") < 2 And Range("K27") < 1 And
Range("L27") < 2 And Range("M27") < 3 _
And Range("C42") < 2 And Range("D42") < 2 And Range("E42") < 1 And
Range("F42") < 2 And Range("G42") < 2 _
And Range("I42") < 2 And Range("J42") < 2 And Range("K42") < 1 And
Range("L42") < 2 And Range("M42") < 2 _
And Range("C57") < 2 And Range("D57") < 2 And Range("E57") < 1 And
Range("F57") < 2 And Range("G57") < 2 _
And Range("I57") < 2 And Range("J57") < 2 And Range("K57") < 1 And
Range("L57") < 2 And Range("M57") < 2) Then
MsgBox "You must complete the survey before closing." _
& " Please note the number of selections required per action.",
vbExclamation, "CANNOT CLOSE"
Cancel = True
End If

End Sub

it's a simple code that just prevents the user from closing Excel
without
answering the survey accordingly. It runs once and after that it
doesn't
anymore.

"K Dales" wrote:

Can you post your code? Hard to know without seeing it.

"Michelle K" wrote:

I have a survey form where users can rate corporate performance.
It
is made
up of radio buttons to rank efficiency. i designed it to prevent
closing and
printing if the answers are too skewed (we need 3 5's, 2 4'2 ,
etc)
It works
fine the first time you open the file. However, if you change
your
answers
(say, rated it 4 and then want to change the rating to 3), the
code
stops
working.

Why is this? How can I solve this issue?

Thanks so much,
Michelle K

There are so many conditions in your code that is has to meet to do
anything, it would not be surprising that all the conditions are not met.
(You may actually have a logic error and you are not checking what you think
you are checking). There must be an easier check you can perform, but I
have no knowledge of what you are doing, so I can't suggest anything
specific. I would think the worksheet functions countif or sumif might be
able to play a roll here.

--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy

"Michelle K" wrote in message
...
I added a message box into the top of the code and it worked - meaning, it
is
reading the code. How come then that it isn't evaluating the condition
anymore?

"Tom Ogilvy" wrote:

If events are disabled, your second procedure will never get triggered.

Are you sure it doesn't run. Perhaps the condition doesn't warrant a
message box?

Try putting in a msgbox at the top (temporarily

Private Sub Workbook_BeforeClose(Cancel As Boolean)
MsgBox "In workbook Close"

If (Range("C27") < 3 And Range("D27") < 2 And Range("E27") < 1 And
Range("F27") < 2 And Range("G27") < 3 _
And Range("I27") < 3 And Range("J27") < 2 And Range("K27") < 1 And
Range("L27") < 2 And Range("M27") < 3 _
And Range("C42") < 2 And Range("D42") < 2 And Range("E42") < 1 And
Range("F42") < 2 And Range("G42") < 2 _
And Range("I42") < 2 And Range("J42") < 2 And Range("K42") < 1 And
Range("L42") < 2 And Range("M42") < 2 _
And Range("C57") < 2 And Range("D57") < 2 And Range("E57") < 1 And
Range("F57") < 2 And Range("G57") < 2 _
And Range("I57") < 2 And Range("J57") < 2 And Range("K57") < 1 And
Range("L57") < 2 And Range("M57") < 2) Then
MsgBox "You must complete the survey before closing." _
& " Please note the number of selections required per action.",
vbExclamation, "CANNOT CLOSE"
Cancel = True
End If

End Sub

You will need to save the workbook to retain the code modification.
--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy


"Michelle K" wrote in message
...
I tried adding these lines but they don't seem to be working:

Public Sub ResetEvents()

Application.EnableEvents = True

End Sub

Private Sub Worksheet_SelectionChange(ByVal Target As Range)

Application.EnableEvents = True

End Sub

I am sure I am missing something or have written these under the wrong
events. Help!

"Tom Ogilvy" wrote:

Do you have other event related code where you disable events

Application.EnableEvents = False

It sounds like events are getting disabled and never reenabled.

--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy

"Michelle K" wrote in message
...
Here is the code:

Private Sub Workbook_BeforeClose(Cancel As Boolean)


If (Range("C27") < 3 And Range("D27") < 2 And Range("E27") < 1
And
Range("F27") < 2 And Range("G27") < 3 _
And Range("I27") < 3 And Range("J27") < 2 And Range("K27") < 1
And
Range("L27") < 2 And Range("M27") < 3 _
And Range("C42") < 2 And Range("D42") < 2 And Range("E42") < 1
And
Range("F42") < 2 And Range("G42") < 2 _
And Range("I42") < 2 And Range("J42") < 2 And Range("K42") < 1
And
Range("L42") < 2 And Range("M42") < 2 _
And Range("C57") < 2 And Range("D57") < 2 And Range("E57") < 1
And
Range("F57") < 2 And Range("G57") < 2 _
And Range("I57") < 2 And Range("J57") < 2 And Range("K57") < 1
And
Range("L57") < 2 And Range("M57") < 2) Then
MsgBox "You must complete the survey before closing." _
& " Please note the number of selections required per action.",
vbExclamation, "CANNOT CLOSE"
Cancel = True
End If

End Sub

it's a simple code that just prevents the user from closing Excel
without
answering the survey accordingly. It runs once and after that it
doesn't
anymore.

"K Dales" wrote:

Can you post your code? Hard to know without seeing it.

"Michelle K" wrote:

I have a survey form where users can rate corporate
performance.
It
is made
up of radio buttons to rank efficiency. i designed it to
prevent
closing and
printing if the answers are too skewed (we need 3 5's, 2 4'2 ,
etc)
It works
fine the first time you open the file. However, if you change
your
answers
(say, rated it 4 and then want to change the rating to 3), the
code
stops
working.

Why is this? How can I solve this issue?

Thanks so much,
Michelle K

Thanks Tom.

It's a survey that lets you rate performance from 1-5 and importance from
1-5 as well. At the end of each section, we want users to have 3 items with
a rating of 5, 2 items with a rating of 4 and so on. I am not the idea
behind the requirements. I am just writing the code for a committee here at
work. So what i did was to add radio buttons and then tallied how many were
5's, etc at the bottom of each section (Rows 27, 42 and 57).

Let me check my logic and see how it goes. If you think of anything else,
please let me know. It's one of the big boss' pet projects. :(

"Tom Ogilvy" wrote:

There are so many conditions in your code that is has to meet to do
anything, it would not be surprising that all the conditions are not met.
(You may actually have a logic error and you are not checking what you think
you are checking). There must be an easier check you can perform, but I
have no knowledge of what you are doing, so I can't suggest anything
specific. I would think the worksheet functions countif or sumif might be
able to play a roll here.

--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy

"Michelle K" wrote in message
...
I added a message box into the top of the code and it worked - meaning, it
is
reading the code. How come then that it isn't evaluating the condition
anymore?

"Tom Ogilvy" wrote:

If events are disabled, your second procedure will never get triggered.

Are you sure it doesn't run. Perhaps the condition doesn't warrant a
message box?

Try putting in a msgbox at the top (temporarily

Private Sub Workbook_BeforeClose(Cancel As Boolean)
MsgBox "In workbook Close"

If (Range("C27") < 3 And Range("D27") < 2 And Range("E27") < 1 And
Range("F27") < 2 And Range("G27") < 3 _
And Range("I27") < 3 And Range("J27") < 2 And Range("K27") < 1 And
Range("L27") < 2 And Range("M27") < 3 _
And Range("C42") < 2 And Range("D42") < 2 And Range("E42") < 1 And
Range("F42") < 2 And Range("G42") < 2 _
And Range("I42") < 2 And Range("J42") < 2 And Range("K42") < 1 And
Range("L42") < 2 And Range("M42") < 2 _
And Range("C57") < 2 And Range("D57") < 2 And Range("E57") < 1 And
Range("F57") < 2 And Range("G57") < 2 _
And Range("I57") < 2 And Range("J57") < 2 And Range("K57") < 1 And
Range("L57") < 2 And Range("M57") < 2) Then
MsgBox "You must complete the survey before closing." _
& " Please note the number of selections required per action.",
vbExclamation, "CANNOT CLOSE"
Cancel = True
End If

End Sub

You will need to save the workbook to retain the code modification.
--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy


"Michelle K" wrote in message
...
I tried adding these lines but they don't seem to be working:

Public Sub ResetEvents()

Application.EnableEvents = True

End Sub

Private Sub Worksheet_SelectionChange(ByVal Target As Range)

Application.EnableEvents = True

End Sub

I am sure I am missing something or have written these under the wrong
events. Help!

"Tom Ogilvy" wrote:

Do you have other event related code where you disable events

Application.EnableEvents = False

It sounds like events are getting disabled and never reenabled.

--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy

"Michelle K" wrote in message
...
Here is the code:

Private Sub Workbook_BeforeClose(Cancel As Boolean)


If (Range("C27") < 3 And Range("D27") < 2 And Range("E27") < 1
And
Range("F27") < 2 And Range("G27") < 3 _
And Range("I27") < 3 And Range("J27") < 2 And Range("K27") < 1
And
Range("L27") < 2 And Range("M27") < 3 _
And Range("C42") < 2 And Range("D42") < 2 And Range("E42") < 1
And
Range("F42") < 2 And Range("G42") < 2 _
And Range("I42") < 2 And Range("J42") < 2 And Range("K42") < 1
And
Range("L42") < 2 And Range("M42") < 2 _
And Range("C57") < 2 And Range("D57") < 2 And Range("E57") < 1
And
Range("F57") < 2 And Range("G57") < 2 _
And Range("I57") < 2 And Range("J57") < 2 And Range("K57") < 1
And
Range("L57") < 2 And Range("M57") < 2) Then
MsgBox "You must complete the survey before closing." _
& " Please note the number of selections required per action.",
vbExclamation, "CANNOT CLOSE"
Cancel = True
End If

End Sub

it's a simple code that just prevents the user from closing Excel
without
answering the survey accordingly. It runs once and after that it
doesn't
anymore.

"K Dales" wrote:

Can you post your code? Hard to know without seeing it.

"Michelle K" wrote:

I have a survey form where users can rate corporate
performance.
It
is made
up of radio buttons to rank efficiency. i designed it to
prevent
closing and
printing if the answers are too skewed (we need 3 5's, 2 4'2 ,
etc)
It works
fine the first time you open the file. However, if you change
your
answers
(say, rated it 4 and then want to change the rating to 3), the
code
stops
working.

Why is this? How can I solve this issue?

Thanks so much,
Michelle K

I think your logic is wrong. You should be using OR instead of AND. AND
would require that the user had the wrong number in every one of the cells
that you check. OR would stop closing if any cell that you checked did not
meet the criteria.

--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy

"Michelle K" wrote in message
...
Thanks Tom.

It's a survey that lets you rate performance from 1-5 and importance from
1-5 as well. At the end of each section, we want users to have 3 items
with
a rating of 5, 2 items with a rating of 4 and so on. I am not the idea
behind the requirements. I am just writing the code for a committee here
at
work. So what i did was to add radio buttons and then tallied how many
were
5's, etc at the bottom of each section (Rows 27, 42 and 57).

Let me check my logic and see how it goes. If you think of anything else,
please let me know. It's one of the big boss' pet projects. :(

"Tom Ogilvy" wrote:

There are so many conditions in your code that is has to meet to do
anything, it would not be surprising that all the conditions are not
met.
(You may actually have a logic error and you are not checking what you
think
you are checking). There must be an easier check you can perform, but I
have no knowledge of what you are doing, so I can't suggest anything
specific. I would think the worksheet functions countif or sumif might
be
able to play a roll here.

--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy

"Michelle K" wrote in message
...
I added a message box into the top of the code and it worked -
meaning, it
is
reading the code. How come then that it isn't evaluating the
condition
anymore?

"Tom Ogilvy" wrote:

If events are disabled, your second procedure will never get
triggered.

Are you sure it doesn't run. Perhaps the condition doesn't warrant
a
message box?

Try putting in a msgbox at the top (temporarily

Private Sub Workbook_BeforeClose(Cancel As Boolean)
MsgBox "In workbook Close"

If (Range("C27") < 3 And Range("D27") < 2 And Range("E27") < 1
And
Range("F27") < 2 And Range("G27") < 3 _
And Range("I27") < 3 And Range("J27") < 2 And Range("K27") < 1
And
Range("L27") < 2 And Range("M27") < 3 _
And Range("C42") < 2 And Range("D42") < 2 And Range("E42") < 1
And
Range("F42") < 2 And Range("G42") < 2 _
And Range("I42") < 2 And Range("J42") < 2 And Range("K42") < 1
And
Range("L42") < 2 And Range("M42") < 2 _
And Range("C57") < 2 And Range("D57") < 2 And Range("E57") < 1
And
Range("F57") < 2 And Range("G57") < 2 _
And Range("I57") < 2 And Range("J57") < 2 And Range("K57") < 1
And
Range("L57") < 2 And Range("M57") < 2) Then
MsgBox "You must complete the survey before closing." _
& " Please note the number of selections required per action.",
vbExclamation, "CANNOT CLOSE"
Cancel = True
End If

End Sub

You will need to save the workbook to retain the code modification.
--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy


"Michelle K" wrote in message
...
I tried adding these lines but they don't seem to be working:

Public Sub ResetEvents()

Application.EnableEvents = True

End Sub

Private Sub Worksheet_SelectionChange(ByVal Target As Range)

Application.EnableEvents = True

End Sub

I am sure I am missing something or have written these under the
wrong
events. Help!

"Tom Ogilvy" wrote:

Do you have other event related code where you disable events

Application.EnableEvents = False

It sounds like events are getting disabled and never reenabled.

--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy

"Michelle K" wrote in
message
...
Here is the code:

Private Sub Workbook_BeforeClose(Cancel As Boolean)


If (Range("C27") < 3 And Range("D27") < 2 And Range("E27")
< 1
And
Range("F27") < 2 And Range("G27") < 3 _
And Range("I27") < 3 And Range("J27") < 2 And Range("K27")
< 1
And
Range("L27") < 2 And Range("M27") < 3 _
And Range("C42") < 2 And Range("D42") < 2 And Range("E42")
< 1
And
Range("F42") < 2 And Range("G42") < 2 _
And Range("I42") < 2 And Range("J42") < 2 And Range("K42")
< 1
And
Range("L42") < 2 And Range("M42") < 2 _
And Range("C57") < 2 And Range("D57") < 2 And Range("E57")
< 1
And
Range("F57") < 2 And Range("G57") < 2 _
And Range("I57") < 2 And Range("J57") < 2 And Range("K57")
< 1
And
Range("L57") < 2 And Range("M57") < 2) Then
MsgBox "You must complete the survey before closing." _
& " Please note the number of selections required per
action.",
vbExclamation, "CANNOT CLOSE"
Cancel = True
End If

End Sub

it's a simple code that just prevents the user from closing
Excel
without
answering the survey accordingly. It runs once and after that
it
doesn't
anymore.

"K Dales" wrote:

Can you post your code? Hard to know without seeing it.

"Michelle K" wrote:

I have a survey form where users can rate corporate
performance.
It
is made
up of radio buttons to rank efficiency. i designed it to
prevent
closing and
printing if the answers are too skewed (we need 3 5's, 2
4'2 ,
etc)
It works
fine the first time you open the file. However, if you
change
your
answers
(say, rated it 4 and then want to change the rating to 3),
the
code
stops
working.

Why is this? How can I solve this issue?

Thanks so much,
Michelle K

PERFECT!

Thanks so much!

"Tom Ogilvy" wrote:

I think your logic is wrong. You should be using OR instead of AND. AND
would require that the user had the wrong number in every one of the cells
that you check. OR would stop closing if any cell that you checked did not
meet the criteria.

--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy

"Michelle K" wrote in message
...
Thanks Tom.

It's a survey that lets you rate performance from 1-5 and importance from
1-5 as well. At the end of each section, we want users to have 3 items
with
a rating of 5, 2 items with a rating of 4 and so on. I am not the idea
behind the requirements. I am just writing the code for a committee here
at
work. So what i did was to add radio buttons and then tallied how many
were
5's, etc at the bottom of each section (Rows 27, 42 and 57).

Let me check my logic and see how it goes. If you think of anything else,
please let me know. It's one of the big boss' pet projects. :(

"Tom Ogilvy" wrote:

There are so many conditions in your code that is has to meet to do
anything, it would not be surprising that all the conditions are not
met.
(You may actually have a logic error and you are not checking what you
think
you are checking). There must be an easier check you can perform, but I
have no knowledge of what you are doing, so I can't suggest anything
specific. I would think the worksheet functions countif or sumif might
be
able to play a roll here.

--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy

"Michelle K" wrote in message
...
I added a message box into the top of the code and it worked -
meaning, it
is
reading the code. How come then that it isn't evaluating the
condition
anymore?

"Tom Ogilvy" wrote:

If events are disabled, your second procedure will never get
triggered.

Are you sure it doesn't run. Perhaps the condition doesn't warrant
a
message box?

Try putting in a msgbox at the top (temporarily

Private Sub Workbook_BeforeClose(Cancel As Boolean)
MsgBox "In workbook Close"

If (Range("C27") < 3 And Range("D27") < 2 And Range("E27") < 1
And
Range("F27") < 2 And Range("G27") < 3 _
And Range("I27") < 3 And Range("J27") < 2 And Range("K27") < 1
And
Range("L27") < 2 And Range("M27") < 3 _
And Range("C42") < 2 And Range("D42") < 2 And Range("E42") < 1
And
Range("F42") < 2 And Range("G42") < 2 _
And Range("I42") < 2 And Range("J42") < 2 And Range("K42") < 1
And
Range("L42") < 2 And Range("M42") < 2 _
And Range("C57") < 2 And Range("D57") < 2 And Range("E57") < 1
And
Range("F57") < 2 And Range("G57") < 2 _
And Range("I57") < 2 And Range("J57") < 2 And Range("K57") < 1
And
Range("L57") < 2 And Range("M57") < 2) Then
MsgBox "You must complete the survey before closing." _
& " Please note the number of selections required per action.",
vbExclamation, "CANNOT CLOSE"
Cancel = True
End If

End Sub

You will need to save the workbook to retain the code modification.
--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy


"Michelle K" wrote in message
...
I tried adding these lines but they don't seem to be working:

Public Sub ResetEvents()

Application.EnableEvents = True

End Sub

Private Sub Worksheet_SelectionChange(ByVal Target As Range)

Application.EnableEvents = True

End Sub

I am sure I am missing something or have written these under the
wrong
events. Help!

"Tom Ogilvy" wrote:

Do you have other event related code where you disable events

Application.EnableEvents = False

It sounds like events are getting disabled and never reenabled.

--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy

"Michelle K" wrote in
message
...
Here is the code:

Private Sub Workbook_BeforeClose(Cancel As Boolean)


If (Range("C27") < 3 And Range("D27") < 2 And Range("E27")
< 1
And
Range("F27") < 2 And Range("G27") < 3 _
And Range("I27") < 3 And Range("J27") < 2 And Range("K27")
< 1
And
Range("L27") < 2 And Range("M27") < 3 _
And Range("C42") < 2 And Range("D42") < 2 And Range("E42")
< 1
And
Range("F42") < 2 And Range("G42") < 2 _
And Range("I42") < 2 And Range("J42") < 2 And Range("K42")
< 1
And
Range("L42") < 2 And Range("M42") < 2 _
And Range("C57") < 2 And Range("D57") < 2 And Range("E57")
< 1
And
Range("F57") < 2 And Range("G57") < 2 _
And Range("I57") < 2 And Range("J57") < 2 And Range("K57")
< 1
And
Range("L57") < 2 And Range("M57") < 2) Then
MsgBox "You must complete the survey before closing." _
& " Please note the number of selections required per
action.",
vbExclamation, "CANNOT CLOSE"
Cancel = True
End If

End Sub

it's a simple code that just prevents the user from closing
Excel
without
answering the survey accordingly. It runs once and after that
it
doesn't
anymore.

"K Dales" wrote:

Can you post your code? Hard to know without seeing it.

"Michelle K" wrote:

I have a survey form where users can rate corporate
performance.
It
is made
up of radio buttons to rank efficiency. i designed it to
prevent
closing and
printing if the answers are too skewed (we need 3 5's, 2
4'2 ,
etc)
It works
fine the first time you open the file. However, if you
change
your
answers
(say, rated it 4 and then want to change the rating to 3),
the
code
stops
working.

Why is this? How can I solve this issue?

Thanks so much,
Michelle K

I'm using Excel 2003 on an XP box. If I write a vba event handler procedure
that has any error in it, for example mismatch, out of range, whatever, ... I
stop the run, make appropriate changes but, I have to completely shutdown
excel, start it back up in order to get the procedure to run again. If I do
not do this the event handler is not called when I click on a cell, (which
fires the event).

....any suggestions, is this a setting I can change somewhere?
--
j.f.dolan

It sounds like your code turns off events somewhere and it's not getting turned
back on.

Inside the VBE
hit ctrl-g (to see the immediate window)
type this and hit enter:
application.enableevents = true



joed wrote:

I'm using Excel 2003 on an XP box. If I write a vba event handler procedure
that has any error in it, for example mismatch, out of range, whatever, ... I
stop the run, make appropriate changes but, I have to completely shutdown
excel, start it back up in order to get the procedure to run again. If I do
not do this the event handler is not called when I click on a cell, (which
fires the event).

...any suggestions, is this a setting I can change somewhere?
--
j.f.dolan

--

Dave Peterson

That was exactly the problem and your solution has given me an even greater
understanding of events and their use, (and traps)

Thank you very much

---joe
--
j.f.dolan


"Dave Peterson" wrote:

It sounds like your code turns off events somewhere and it's not getting turned
back on.

Inside the VBE
hit ctrl-g (to see the immediate window)
type this and hit enter:
application.enableevents = true



joed wrote:

I'm using Excel 2003 on an XP box. If I write a vba event handler procedure
that has any error in it, for example mismatch, out of range, whatever, ... I
stop the run, make appropriate changes but, I have to completely shutdown
excel, start it back up in order to get the procedure to run again. If I do
not do this the event handler is not called when I click on a cell, (which
fires the event).

...any suggestions, is this a setting I can change somewhere?
--
j.f.dolan

--

Dave Peterson