Thank you some much both of you, I tried yours first Bernie (it was
first and also less effort for me!). It worked perfectly. I have no
doubt yours would have worked too Dave, I am in these groups often
enough to know what kind of success rate you have! Thanks again, you
have saved me another day of scratching my head! I can't believe I had
mixed up the rows/columns....no wonder it failed on the third attempt!
It seems so simple now you have pointed it out but I doubt I would have
ever twigged.