I am trying to calculate a formula for alimony recapture for tax planning,
that will compute the amounts that must be paid for each of three years
without triggering recapture.

The facts a

Assume total payment over 3 years is $100,000

To calculate:

Year 1 payment must not be $7,500 more than year 2 payment, nor $22,500 more
than year 3 payment (otherwise, there will be excess payments that will
trigger a recapture tax)

Any negative results of calculations are considered zero

The formula that I have works only when there is enough in the total payment
to make a positive payment for each of the three years.

Legend:
A1 = Cell containing the total payments over 3 years (e.g., $100,000)
A2 = Cell containing year 1 payment
A3 = Cell containing year 2 payment
A4 = Cell containing year 3 payment

Formula for year 1 payment: Cell A2
=A1 + 30000/3

Results: $43,333


Formula for year 2 payment: Cell A3

=IF(SUM(A2-7500)<0,0,SUM(A2-7500))

Result: $35,833

Formula for year 3 payment: Cell A4

=IF(SUM(A2-22500)<0,0,SUM(A2-22500))

Result: $20,833

The problem with the formulas for years 2 and 3 is when the total payment
drops below a minimum amount to allow for full payments in years 2 and 3;
then, the total payments for years 2 and 3 will exceed the remaining amount
after subtracting year 1 payment from the total amount

For example, if total payments for all 3 years are $35,000,
then year 1 payment is $21,667, year 2, $14,167, and year 3 is zero, for a
total of $35,833. This exceeds the alloted total payment by $833.
What can be added to the formulas for years 2 and 3 to assure that the total
payments for each of the 3 years will not exceed the alloted total amount?

Thank you




--
MZ

Try

=MAX(MIN(SUM(A2-7500),$A$1-SUM($A$2:A2)),0)

=MAX(MIN(SUM(A3-2250),$A$1-SUM($A$2:A3)),0)

---
HTH
Bob Phillips

"MZ" wrote in message
...
I am trying to calculate a formula for alimony recapture for tax planning,
that will compute the amounts that must be paid for each of three years
without triggering recapture.

The facts a

Assume total payment over 3 years is $100,000

To calculate:

Year 1 payment must not be $7,500 more than year 2 payment, nor $22,500
more
than year 3 payment (otherwise, there will be excess payments that will
trigger a recapture tax)

Any negative results of calculations are considered zero

The formula that I have works only when there is enough in the total
payment
to make a positive payment for each of the three years.

Legend:
A1 = Cell containing the total payments over 3 years (e.g., $100,000)
A2 = Cell containing year 1 payment
A3 = Cell containing year 2 payment
A4 = Cell containing year 3 payment

Formula for year 1 payment: Cell A2
=A1 + 30000/3

Results: $43,333


Formula for year 2 payment: Cell A3

=IF(SUM(A2-7500)<0,0,SUM(A2-7500))

Result: $35,833

Formula for year 3 payment: Cell A4

=IF(SUM(A2-22500)<0,0,SUM(A2-22500))

Result: $20,833

The problem with the formulas for years 2 and 3 is when the total payment
drops below a minimum amount to allow for full payments in years 2 and 3;
then, the total payments for years 2 and 3 will exceed the remaining
amount
after subtracting year 1 payment from the total amount

For example, if total payments for all 3 years are $35,000,
then year 1 payment is $21,667, year 2, $14,167, and year 3 is zero, for a
total of $35,833. This exceeds the alloted total payment by $833.
What can be added to the formulas for years 2 and 3 to assure that the
total
payments for each of the 3 years will not exceed the alloted total amount?

Thank you




--
MZ

And of course you can replace SUM(A2-7500) by just A2-7500, because you
haven't given Excel anything to add to A2-7500.
Excel help for the SUM function will tell you what it does.
--
David Biddulph

"Bob Phillips" wrote in message
...
Try

=MAX(MIN(SUM(A2-7500),$A$1-SUM($A$2:A2)),0)

=MAX(MIN(SUM(A3-2250),$A$1-SUM($A$2:A3)),0)

---
HTH
Bob Phillips

"MZ" wrote in message
...
I am trying to calculate a formula for alimony recapture for tax planning,
that will compute the amounts that must be paid for each of three years
without triggering recapture.

The facts a

Assume total payment over 3 years is $100,000

To calculate:

Year 1 payment must not be $7,500 more than year 2 payment, nor $22,500
more
than year 3 payment (otherwise, there will be excess payments that will
trigger a recapture tax)

Any negative results of calculations are considered zero

The formula that I have works only when there is enough in the total
payment
to make a positive payment for each of the three years.

Legend:
A1 = Cell containing the total payments over 3 years (e.g., $100,000)
A2 = Cell containing year 1 payment
A3 = Cell containing year 2 payment
A4 = Cell containing year 3 payment

Formula for year 1 payment: Cell A2
=A1 + 30000/3

Results: $43,333


Formula for year 2 payment: Cell A3

=IF(SUM(A2-7500)<0,0,SUM(A2-7500))

Result: $35,833

Formula for year 3 payment: Cell A4

=IF(SUM(A2-22500)<0,0,SUM(A2-22500))

Result: $20,833

The problem with the formulas for years 2 and 3 is when the total payment
drops below a minimum amount to allow for full payments in years 2 and 3;
then, the total payments for years 2 and 3 will exceed the remaining
amount
after subtracting year 1 payment from the total amount

For example, if total payments for all 3 years are $35,000,
then year 1 payment is $21,667, year 2, $14,167, and year 3 is zero, for
a
total of $35,833. This exceeds the alloted total payment by $833.
What can be added to the formulas for years 2 and 3 to assure that the
total
payments for each of the 3 years will not exceed the alloted total
amount?

Thank you




--
MZ