Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 65
Default Embedded If Limitation

Hi All,

Im using a nested if statement to age documents based upon the number of
days old a document is. Ive been using this formula for months and today
the business has decided to change the age buckets so ive simply added more
nested ifs to my formula. However, the cell displays the formula and not the
result whereas before it used to display the reult. All I have done is click
in cell, press F2 and edited formula. Is there a maximum number of nested
if's?

My formula is below

=IF(K3<31,"0 to 30 Days",IF(K3<61,"31 to 60 Days",IF(K3<91,"61 to 90
Days",IF(K3<121,"91 to 120 Days",IF(K3<151,"121 to 150 Days",IF(K3<366,"151
to 365 Days","365+Days"))))))


If there is a maximum no. of nests, can anubody think of another way to do
this?
I Can use a vlookup but the number of days old is potentially limitless and
i dont want to create a lookup table that big.
--
Rob Gaffney
  #2   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 65
Default Embedded If Limitation - UPDATE FROM REQUESTER

Update - its ok, I found a fault with formula. However, if anybody can find
a smarter way to do this, id be grateful.

Im thinking a vlookup with a range?

i.e. if cell A1 = 57
do a vlookup on 57
in a lookup table that says 1-50 = Rob, 51 - 90 = Dennis
and return the value Rob

--
Rob Gaffney


"Gaffnr" wrote:

Hi All,

Im using a nested if statement to age documents based upon the number of
days old a document is. Ive been using this formula for months and today
the business has decided to change the age buckets so ive simply added more
nested ifs to my formula. However, the cell displays the formula and not the
result whereas before it used to display the reult. All I have done is click
in cell, press F2 and edited formula. Is there a maximum number of nested
if's?

My formula is below

=IF(K3<31,"0 to 30 Days",IF(K3<61,"31 to 60 Days",IF(K3<91,"61 to 90
Days",IF(K3<121,"91 to 120 Days",IF(K3<151,"121 to 150 Days",IF(K3<366,"151
to 365 Days","365+Days"))))))


If there is a maximum no. of nests, can anubody think of another way to do
this?
I Can use a vlookup but the number of days old is potentially limitless and
i dont want to create a lookup table that big.
--
Rob Gaffney

  #3   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 2,480
Default Embedded If Limitation - UPDATE FROM REQUESTER

Hi Rob

Setup a table on say sheet2 in columns A and B
0 Rob
51 Dennis
999 Roger

=IF(A1="","",VLOOKUP(A1,Sheet2!A:B,2))

With a value 57, Dennis would be returned - not Rob.
The Vlookup formula (without the optional 4 th parameter of False) will
return the value which does not exceed the looked-up value.

You can have as many ranges as you wish, just ensure that the first on
starts with 0


--
Regards
Roger Govier

"Gaffnr" wrote in message
...
Update - its ok, I found a fault with formula. However, if anybody can
find
a smarter way to do this, id be grateful.

Im thinking a vlookup with a range?

i.e. if cell A1 = 57
do a vlookup on 57
in a lookup table that says 1-50 = Rob, 51 - 90 = Dennis
and return the value Rob

--
Rob Gaffney


"Gaffnr" wrote:

Hi All,

Im using a nested if statement to age documents based upon the number of
days old a document is. Ive been using this formula for months and
today
the business has decided to change the age buckets so ive simply added
more
nested ifs to my formula. However, the cell displays the formula and not
the
result whereas before it used to display the reult. All I have done is
click
in cell, press F2 and edited formula. Is there a maximum number of
nested
if's?

My formula is below

=IF(K3<31,"0 to 30 Days",IF(K3<61,"31 to 60 Days",IF(K3<91,"61 to 90
Days",IF(K3<121,"91 to 120 Days",IF(K3<151,"121 to 150
Days",IF(K3<366,"151
to 365 Days","365+Days"))))))


If there is a maximum no. of nests, can anubody think of another way to
do
this?
I Can use a vlookup but the number of days old is potentially limitless
and
i dont want to create a lookup table that big.
--
Rob Gaffney


  #4   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 65
Default Embedded If Limitation - UPDATE FROM REQUESTER

Hi Roger.
All these years ive been using that optional 4th character believing it to
be mandatory. I ves tested your theory and works liek a charm . Much neater
than nested ifs. Thanks for your help.
--
Rob Gaffney


"Roger Govier" wrote:

Hi Rob

Setup a table on say sheet2 in columns A and B
0 Rob
51 Dennis
999 Roger

=IF(A1="","",VLOOKUP(A1,Sheet2!A:B,2))

With a value 57, Dennis would be returned - not Rob.
The Vlookup formula (without the optional 4 th parameter of False) will
return the value which does not exceed the looked-up value.

You can have as many ranges as you wish, just ensure that the first on
starts with 0


--
Regards
Roger Govier

"Gaffnr" wrote in message
...
Update - its ok, I found a fault with formula. However, if anybody can
find
a smarter way to do this, id be grateful.

Im thinking a vlookup with a range?

i.e. if cell A1 = 57
do a vlookup on 57
in a lookup table that says 1-50 = Rob, 51 - 90 = Dennis
and return the value Rob

--
Rob Gaffney


"Gaffnr" wrote:

Hi All,

Im using a nested if statement to age documents based upon the number of
days old a document is. Ive been using this formula for months and
today
the business has decided to change the age buckets so ive simply added
more
nested ifs to my formula. However, the cell displays the formula and not
the
result whereas before it used to display the reult. All I have done is
click
in cell, press F2 and edited formula. Is there a maximum number of
nested
if's?

My formula is below

=IF(K3<31,"0 to 30 Days",IF(K3<61,"31 to 60 Days",IF(K3<91,"61 to 90
Days",IF(K3<121,"91 to 120 Days",IF(K3<151,"121 to 150
Days",IF(K3<366,"151
to 365 Days","365+Days"))))))


If there is a maximum no. of nests, can anubody think of another way to
do
this?
I Can use a vlookup but the number of days old is potentially limitless
and
i dont want to create a lookup table that big.
--
Rob Gaffney


  #5   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 10,593
Default Embedded If Limitation - UPDATE FROM REQUESTER

It is not so much of omitting the 4th argument that is why it works, but
rather that its default value is TRUE.

This formula works as well

=IF(A1="","",VLOOKUP(A1,Sheet2!A:B,2,TRUE))

and is better IMO as it explicitly states your intent.

--
---
HTH

Bob


(there's no email, no snail mail, but somewhere should be gmail in my addy)



"Gaffnr" wrote in message
...
Hi Roger.
All these years ive been using that optional 4th character believing it to
be mandatory. I ves tested your theory and works liek a charm . Much
neater
than nested ifs. Thanks for your help.
--
Rob Gaffney


"Roger Govier" wrote:

Hi Rob

Setup a table on say sheet2 in columns A and B
0 Rob
51 Dennis
999 Roger

=IF(A1="","",VLOOKUP(A1,Sheet2!A:B,2))

With a value 57, Dennis would be returned - not Rob.
The Vlookup formula (without the optional 4 th parameter of False) will
return the value which does not exceed the looked-up value.

You can have as many ranges as you wish, just ensure that the first on
starts with 0


--
Regards
Roger Govier

"Gaffnr" wrote in message
...
Update - its ok, I found a fault with formula. However, if anybody can
find
a smarter way to do this, id be grateful.

Im thinking a vlookup with a range?

i.e. if cell A1 = 57
do a vlookup on 57
in a lookup table that says 1-50 = Rob, 51 - 90 = Dennis
and return the value Rob

--
Rob Gaffney


"Gaffnr" wrote:

Hi All,

Im using a nested if statement to age documents based upon the number
of
days old a document is. Ive been using this formula for months and
today
the business has decided to change the age buckets so ive simply added
more
nested ifs to my formula. However, the cell displays the formula and
not
the
result whereas before it used to display the reult. All I have done
is
click
in cell, press F2 and edited formula. Is there a maximum number of
nested
if's?

My formula is below

=IF(K3<31,"0 to 30 Days",IF(K3<61,"31 to 60 Days",IF(K3<91,"61 to 90
Days",IF(K3<121,"91 to 120 Days",IF(K3<151,"121 to 150
Days",IF(K3<366,"151
to 365 Days","365+Days"))))))


If there is a maximum no. of nests, can anubody think of another way
to
do
this?
I Can use a vlookup but the number of days old is potentially
limitless
and
i dont want to create a lookup table that big.
--
Rob Gaffney






  #6   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 2,480
Default Embedded If Limitation - UPDATE FROM REQUESTER

Hi Bob

Whilst I agree totally with
It is not so much of omitting the 4th argument that is why it works, but
rather that its default value is TRUE.


I have never found the inclusion of TRUE make's the intention clearer.
Inherently this "appears" backwards to me (simple mind<bg) as TRUE to me
would seem to imply an Exact match, whereas FALSE is the condition that
requires the match to be Exact

I agree it is lazy to leave out the 4th parameter, but I prefer to use 1 and
0 rather than TRUE or FALSE.


--
Regards
Roger Govier

"Bob Phillips" wrote in message
...
It is not so much of omitting the 4th argument that is why it works, but
rather that its default value is TRUE.

This formula works as well

=IF(A1="","",VLOOKUP(A1,Sheet2!A:B,2,TRUE))

and is better IMO as it explicitly states your intent.

--
---
HTH

Bob


(there's no email, no snail mail, but somewhere should be gmail in my
addy)



"Gaffnr" wrote in message
...
Hi Roger.
All these years ive been using that optional 4th character believing it
to
be mandatory. I ves tested your theory and works liek a charm . Much
neater
than nested ifs. Thanks for your help.
--
Rob Gaffney


"Roger Govier" wrote:

Hi Rob

Setup a table on say sheet2 in columns A and B
0 Rob
51 Dennis
999 Roger

=IF(A1="","",VLOOKUP(A1,Sheet2!A:B,2))

With a value 57, Dennis would be returned - not Rob.
The Vlookup formula (without the optional 4 th parameter of False) will
return the value which does not exceed the looked-up value.

You can have as many ranges as you wish, just ensure that the first on
starts with 0


--
Regards
Roger Govier

"Gaffnr" wrote in message
...
Update - its ok, I found a fault with formula. However, if anybody
can
find
a smarter way to do this, id be grateful.

Im thinking a vlookup with a range?

i.e. if cell A1 = 57
do a vlookup on 57
in a lookup table that says 1-50 = Rob, 51 - 90 = Dennis
and return the value Rob

--
Rob Gaffney


"Gaffnr" wrote:

Hi All,

Im using a nested if statement to age documents based upon the number
of
days old a document is. Ive been using this formula for months and
today
the business has decided to change the age buckets so ive simply
added
more
nested ifs to my formula. However, the cell displays the formula and
not
the
result whereas before it used to display the reult. All I have done
is
click
in cell, press F2 and edited formula. Is there a maximum number of
nested
if's?

My formula is below

=IF(K3<31,"0 to 30 Days",IF(K3<61,"31 to 60 Days",IF(K3<91,"61 to 90
Days",IF(K3<121,"91 to 120 Days",IF(K3<151,"121 to 150
Days",IF(K3<366,"151
to 365 Days","365+Days"))))))


If there is a maximum no. of nests, can anubody think of another way
to
do
this?
I Can use a vlookup but the number of days old is potentially
limitless
and
i dont want to create a lookup table that big.
--
Rob Gaffney



Reply
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Row Limitation in SUMPRODUCT Stephen Excel Worksheet Functions 3 October 2nd 07 09:30 PM
Row Limitation Atom Smasher Excel Discussion (Misc queries) 4 July 17th 06 07:59 PM
Way around row limitation mrwawa Excel Discussion (Misc queries) 4 June 29th 06 08:46 PM
Function limitation JayL Excel Worksheet Functions 1 March 4th 05 04:51 PM
Excel Limitation Farhan Excel Worksheet Functions 1 February 11th 05 08:33 AM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:20 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 ExcelBanter.
The comments are property of their posters.
 

About Us

"It's about Microsoft Excel"