I have a simple Solver problem set up to analyze a price increase. I have
about 20 rows that represent product groups (actually procedures - I work for
a hospital but I'll stick to general terms). These are broke down into three
columns and multiplied by a factor to get net increase in revenue - my target
cell. I have two constraints: a cell representing 10% total average
increase, and a range of cells representing the increase for each product
group to be between -20% and +20%. Specifically, my Constraint box looks
like this:
$A$12:$A$29<=0.2
$A$12:$A$29=-0.2
$AI$<=$AJ$9
AJ9 has a value of 0.10
All this works, and I believe is pretty simple as far as models go.

My question is I get different answers. Once I set up and hit "go" I get an
answer, with cells A12:A29 having values between 0% and 19% But if I erase
and set the range of cells to be 2%, and then rerun Solver, I get different
results.

My problem is simple enough that I can take Solver and tweak to get my goal.
But I am wondering if I am missing something? - I've seen increadibly more
complicated examples on this site.

thanks

If you're rerunning with the same constraints and getting different answers
then there are multiple solutions. But it seemed that you were saying that
you reset your constraints to +/-2%.

Also, AI? What's the reference supposed to be?
$AI$<=$AJ$9

Or, perhaps I'm totally missing something in your explanation. :)

"Dion" wrote:

I have a simple Solver problem set up to analyze a price increase. I have
about 20 rows that represent product groups (actually procedures - I work for
a hospital but I'll stick to general terms). These are broke down into three
columns and multiplied by a factor to get net increase in revenue - my target
cell. I have two constraints: a cell representing 10% total average
increase, and a range of cells representing the increase for each product
group to be between -20% and +20%. Specifically, my Constraint box looks
like this:
$A$12:$A$29<=0.2
$A$12:$A$29=-0.2
$AI$<=$AJ$9
AJ9 has a value of 0.10
All this works, and I believe is pretty simple as far as models go.

My question is I get different answers. Once I set up and hit "go" I get an
answer, with cells A12:A29 having values between 0% and 19% But if I erase
and set the range of cells to be 2%, and then rerun Solver, I get different
results.

My problem is simple enough that I can take Solver and tweak to get my goal.
But I am wondering if I am missing something? - I've seen increadibly more
complicated examples on this site.

thanks