Here's an easy one that I can't see!

Why does

InStr(4,"XXpXXpXXPXXP","P",vbTextCompare)

return 6 and

Instr(5,"ABC-123-XYZ","-",vbTextCompare)

return 8??? I thought the second one would return 4 because the second dash
is the fourth character when you start search at position 5.

THANKS!

InStr return the Absolute Position in the string, regardless of the
"Start position" the Start position just tells it to skip the first few
characters.

Charles

Norm Lundquist wrote:
Here's an easy one that I can't see!

Why does

InStr(4,"XXpXXpXXPXXP","P",vbTextCompare)

return 6 and

Instr(5,"ABC-123-XYZ","-",vbTextCompare)

return 8??? I thought the second one would return 4 because the second dash
is the fourth character when you start search at position 5.

THANKS!

Instr return the position of the character from the beginning of the string,
not relative to where you start.

NickHK

"Norm Lundquist" ...
Here's an easy one that I can't see!

Why does

InStr(4,"XXpXXpXXPXXP","P",vbTextCompare)

return 6 and

Instr(5,"ABC-123-XYZ","-",vbTextCompare)

return 8??? I thought the second one would return 4 because the second
dash
is the fourth character when you start search at position 5.

THANKS!

It returns the position from the start of the string, not relative to where
you start searching.

--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy


"Norm Lundquist" wrote:

Here's an easy one that I can't see!

Why does

InStr(4,"XXpXXpXXPXXP","P",vbTextCompare)

return 6 and

Instr(5,"ABC-123-XYZ","-",vbTextCompare)

return 8??? I thought the second one would return 4 because the second dash
is the fourth character when you start search at position 5.

THANKS!

Tom,

But why does the first example return 6 for the "P" when it is actually the
9th character? I must REALLY be missing something!

Norm

"Tom Ogilvy" wrote:

It returns the position from the start of the string, not relative to where
you start searching.

--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy


"Norm Lundquist" wrote:

Here's an easy one that I can't see!

Why does

InStr(4,"XXpXXpXXPXXP","P",vbTextCompare)

return 6 and

Instr(5,"ABC-123-XYZ","-",vbTextCompare)

return 8??? I thought the second one would return 4 because the second dash
is the fourth character when you start search at position 5.

THANKS!

Sorry for being so blind today! I was expecting it to find the capital P.

I think I'll go crawl under a rock now!


"Norm Lundquist" wrote:

Tom,

But why does the first example return 6 for the "P" when it is actually the
9th character? I must REALLY be missing something!

Norm

"Tom Ogilvy" wrote:

It returns the position from the start of the string, not relative to where
you start searching.

--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy


"Norm Lundquist" wrote:

Here's an easy one that I can't see!

Why does

InStr(4,"XXpXXpXXPXXP","P",vbTextCompare)

return 6 and

Instr(5,"ABC-123-XYZ","-",vbTextCompare)

return 8??? I thought the second one would return 4 because the second dash
is the fourth character when you start search at position 5.

THANKS!

use a binary compare if you want it to be case sensitive.

--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy


"Norm Lundquist" wrote:

Sorry for being so blind today! I was expecting it to find the capital P.

I think I'll go crawl under a rock now!


"Norm Lundquist" wrote:

Tom,

But why does the first example return 6 for the "P" when it is actually the
9th character? I must REALLY be missing something!

Norm

"Tom Ogilvy" wrote:

It returns the position from the start of the string, not relative to where
you start searching.

--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy


"Norm Lundquist" wrote:

Here's an easy one that I can't see!

Why does

InStr(4,"XXpXXpXXPXXP","P",vbTextCompare)

return 6 and

Instr(5,"ABC-123-XYZ","-",vbTextCompare)

return 8??? I thought the second one would return 4 because the second dash
is the fourth character when you start search at position 5.

THANKS!

Norm Lundquist wrote:
Tom,

But why does the first example return 6 for the "P" when it is actually the
9th character? I must REALLY be missing something!

Norm


Two things: InStr is maybe(?) NOT case-sensitive but DOES only begin to
look where you tell it to... AND returns position from beginning of
string (as prev. stated).

Will

See what value you get for:
InStr(4,"XXpXXpXXPXXP","P",vbBinaryCompare)

NickHK

"Norm Lundquist" ...
Tom,

But why does the first example return 6 for the "P" when it is actually
the
9th character? I must REALLY be missing something!

Norm

"Tom Ogilvy" wrote:

It returns the position from the start of the string, not relative to
where
you start searching.

--
Regards,
Tom Ogilvy


"Norm Lundquist" wrote:

Here's an easy one that I can't see!

Why does

InStr(4,"XXpXXpXXPXXP","P",vbTextCompare)

return 6 and

Instr(5,"ABC-123-XYZ","-",vbTextCompare)

return 8??? I thought the second one would return 4 because the second
dash
is the fourth character when you start search at position 5.

THANKS!

Aren't they doing it exactly the same way. Returning the position of the
character in that string--no matter where you started.

It's not where you start the search, the function is returning the position in
the string.



Norm Lundquist wrote:

Here's an easy one that I can't see!

Why does

InStr(4,"XXpXXpXXPXXP","P",vbTextCompare)

return 6 and

Instr(5,"ABC-123-XYZ","-",vbTextCompare)

return 8??? I thought the second one would return 4 because the second dash
is the fourth character when you start search at position 5.

THANKS!

--

Dave Peterson

Because it returns its position in the string, not relative to the start
point.

--
HTH

Bob Phillips

(replace somewhere in email address with gmail if mailing direct)

"Norm Lundquist" wrote in message
...
Here's an easy one that I can't see!

Why does

InStr(4,"XXpXXpXXPXXP","P",vbTextCompare)

return 6 and

Instr(5,"ABC-123-XYZ","-",vbTextCompare)

return 8??? I thought the second one would return 4 because the second
dash
is the fourth character when you start search at position 5.

THANKS!