Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.programming
|
|||
|
|||
Dependency problem
My workbook runs well in Excel97, but not in Excel2000. The
problem I have seems to be pretty difficult. In the spreadsheet, I have (among other things): - a set D of data (cells containing raw numbers), - a set F of formulas (some are udf's) based on D, - a formula G (not udf) based on both D and F, - a formula U (a udf) based on D, F and G. The situation is easier to comprehend by viewing a diagram, but it seems that there can be no attachments to messages here. So I sketched it below, but there are 5 arrows missing: - from D to G - from D to U - from F to G - from F to U - from G to U G D --------- F U The code for formula U reads the values in all the cells of D and F without problem: Range(...).Value2. But it can't read cell G before its 1,805th attempt (the number 1,805 depends on the number of calls to U in the spreadsheet, of course). That's a big waste of time. If you draw the arrows above, you'll notice that there are 2 triangles, one inside the other. First, I thought that the problem arose because VBA2000 considered this as a circular reference. But in that case, why would the cell containing G be successfully read after a number of attempts ? So I thought, maybe the problem is that the cells in F are calculated last. But that's not the case: all their values are known to VBA before the 900th attempt to read G. At first sight, a solution would be to calculate the value of G in VBA instead of calculating it in the spreadsheet. That way, cell G wouldn't have to be read in VBA. But that's not really satisfactory. Cell G is needed in the spreadsheet. So I have 2 choices: either calculate G in the spreadsheet AND in VBA (messy), or call a udf in cell G to get the value calculated in VBA. But in that case, I might very well end up with the same problem I am having right now. Before losing any more time (I've been working on this for a month), I thought I'd ask the specialists: what is the cause, what is the solution ? Thanks |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
inter-dependency | Excel Worksheet Functions | |||
dependency changes after row insert | Excel Discussion (Misc queries) | |||
Drop down dependency stuff | Excel Worksheet Functions | |||
Cell reference dependency | Excel Programming | |||
dependency protected cells | Excel Programming |