Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#1
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.programming
|
|||
|
|||
original messages in the reply
some persons when they reply to doubts they remove the original messages. If
somebody who is not the originator the doubts sees this reply he/she is not able to find out to what doubt this is the reply. It would be better if the whole thread is available in each message. this is relevant to all the newsgroups. I request any of the MVPs give their general advice on this. |
#2
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.programming
|
|||
|
|||
original messages in the reply
The problem is that in this case so much extraneous gumpf can be left on a
message. Imagine a thread with 50 responses in which each has the whole of every previous thread. Also consider the situation where two people reply to the same question. The in effect open 2 sub-threads, the first will not contain the details in the second, and vice versa, and nor will any subsequent responses to either sub-thread It is a difficult one to get right, but in general I think the best way is to either keep just the previous item, that is the one that you are responding to, or respond specifically to sections by embedding your comments within their text, something like previous poster said and I reply and he also said to which I reply. Some people also maintain that your response should be after the previous post, but I find this messy and less helpful. And don't forget, if threaded you should be able to see all previous responses anyway. -- HTH RP (remove nothere from the email address if mailing direct) "R.VENKATARAMAN" wrote in message ... some persons when they reply to doubts they remove the original messages. If somebody who is not the originator the doubts sees this reply he/she is not able to find out to what doubt this is the reply. It would be better if the whole thread is available in each message. this is relevant to all the newsgroups. I request any of the MVPs give their general advice on this. |
#3
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.programming
|
|||
|
|||
original messages in the reply
thank you Mr. Phillips for explaining the problem. Of course one way to go
to google groups search and see all the messages of that subject. anyhow I understand the problem. Bob Phillips wrote in message ... The problem is that in this case so much extraneous gumpf can be left on a message. Imagine a thread with 50 responses in which each has the whole of every previous thread. Also consider the situation where two people reply to the same question. The in effect open 2 sub-threads, the first will not contain the details in the second, and vice versa, and nor will any subsequent responses to either sub-thread It is a difficult one to get right, but in general I think the best way is to either keep just the previous item, that is the one that you are responding to, or respond specifically to sections by embedding your comments within their text, something like previous poster said and I reply and he also said to which I reply. Some people also maintain that your response should be after the previous post, but I find this messy and less helpful. And don't forget, if threaded you should be able to see all previous responses anyway. -- HTH RP (remove nothere from the email address if mailing direct) "R.VENKATARAMAN" wrote in message ... some persons when they reply to doubts they remove the original messages. If somebody who is not the originator the doubts sees this reply he/she is not able to find out to what doubt this is the reply. It would be better if the whole thread is available in each message. this is relevant to all the newsgroups. I request any of the MVPs give their general advice on this. |
Reply |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Forum | |||
No reply | Excel Worksheet Functions | |||
Auto save replaced my original file and now I need the original? | Excel Discussion (Misc queries) | |||
Reply | Excel Discussion (Misc queries) | |||
Reply to Tom | Excel Programming | |||
Reply to Tom | Excel Programming |