What is the easiest way for me to share a routine I have
built with this newsgroup given that it has userforms?
That is, if it doesn't have forms then I can just drop the
code in and share it with you all. However if it is
loaded with forms and controls, the code isn't enough. Do
people submit full xla files to the group? Can they?

Thanks

Thanks for the offer. However, there is no practical way to share
binary files. Google will not archive posts with binary content and
most regulars positively frown on binary attachments in text-only
newsgroups. I, for one, simply delete any post that contains an
attachment.

So, about the only choice you have is (a) don't share or (b) create
your own web site.

--
Regards,

Tushar Mehta
www.tushar-mehta.com
Excel, PowerPoint, and VBA add-ins, tutorials
Custom MS Office productivity solutions

In article ,
says...
What is the easiest way for me to share a routine I have
built with this newsgroup given that it has userforms?
That is, if it doesn't have forms then I can just drop the
code in and share it with you all. However if it is
loaded with forms and controls, the code isn't enough. Do
people submit full xla files to the group? Can they?

Thanks

Most regulars don't want to see attachments to posts in the newsgroups.

Any way you can post it on a website and just share the link to that site?

ExcelMonkey wrote:

What is the easiest way for me to share a routine I have
built with this newsgroup given that it has userforms?
That is, if it doesn't have forms then I can just drop the
code in and share it with you all. However if it is
loaded with forms and controls, the code isn't enough. Do
people submit full xla files to the group? Can they?

Thanks

--

Dave Peterson

Whilst I am not suggesting that people do attach to the NG, can someone
explain to me the difference between posting it to an NG and to a website?

In both cases, AFAIK, you can save the file to your machine and virus check
it, or you can leave it alone. And if you open it, you can disable macros.

Just asking.

Bob


"Dave Peterson" wrote in message
...
Most regulars don't want to see attachments to posts in the newsgroups.

Any way you can post it on a website and just share the link to that site?

ExcelMonkey wrote:

What is the easiest way for me to share a routine I have
built with this newsgroup given that it has userforms?
That is, if it doesn't have forms then I can just drop the
code in and share it with you all. However if it is
loaded with forms and controls, the code isn't enough. Do
people submit full xla files to the group? Can they?

Thanks

--

Dave Peterson

News servers form a gobal peer-to-peer network. Post something to one
and it is propagated to *every* server around the world.

Many hosts that carry newsgroups prohibit binary posts in text-only
newsgroups. Such messages are simply deleted by the server.

Some others may impose limits on how much space is dedicated to a
particular newsgroup. One large binary file can force the deletion of
dozens (or even hundreds) of text-only messages.

Some services impose limits on the rate at which a customer can
download data from a news server. Even accidentally downloading a
large binary file can result in that limit being exceeded.

Newsgroups constitute a push technology in terms of keeping news
servers up-to-date, though there is a pull flavor to the client-server
interaction. Putting a file on a website is strictly a pull
technology.

--
Regards,

Tushar Mehta
www.tushar-mehta.com
Excel, PowerPoint, and VBA add-ins, tutorials
Custom MS Office productivity solutions

In article ,
says...
Whilst I am not suggesting that people do attach to the NG, can someone
explain to me the difference between posting it to an NG and to a website?

In both cases, AFAIK, you can save the file to your machine and virus check
it, or you can leave it alone. And if you open it, you can disable macros.

Just asking.

Bob


"Dave Peterson" wrote in message
...
Most regulars don't want to see attachments to posts in the newsgroups.

Any way you can post it on a website and just share the link to that site?

ExcelMonkey wrote:

What is the easiest way for me to share a routine I have
built with this newsgroup given that it has userforms?
That is, if it doesn't have forms then I can just drop the
code in and share it with you all. However if it is
loaded with forms and controls, the code isn't enough. Do
people submit full xla files to the group? Can they?

Thanks

--

Dave Peterson

Okay, so the expected argument. But then surely the argument is to raise
with MS to forbid attachments, delete them at source, rather than
fruitlessly banging on at people who do post, or even recipients like
yourself having to delete any such offending items.

Problem, not symptom.


Bob


"Tushar Mehta" wrote in message
om...
News servers form a gobal peer-to-peer network. Post something to one
and it is propagated to *every* server around the world.

Many hosts that carry newsgroups prohibit binary posts in text-only
newsgroups. Such messages are simply deleted by the server.

Some others may impose limits on how much space is dedicated to a
particular newsgroup. One large binary file can force the deletion of
dozens (or even hundreds) of text-only messages.

Some services impose limits on the rate at which a customer can
download data from a news server. Even accidentally downloading a
large binary file can result in that limit being exceeded.

Newsgroups constitute a push technology in terms of keeping news
servers up-to-date, though there is a pull flavor to the client-server
interaction. Putting a file on a website is strictly a pull
technology.

--
Regards,

Tushar Mehta
www.tushar-mehta.com
Excel, PowerPoint, and VBA add-ins, tutorials
Custom MS Office productivity solutions

In article ,
says...
Whilst I am not suggesting that people do attach to the NG, can someone
explain to me the difference between posting it to an NG and to a
website?

In both cases, AFAIK, you can save the file to your machine and virus
check
it, or you can leave it alone. And if you open it, you can disable
macros.

Just asking.

Bob


"Dave Peterson" wrote in message
...
Most regulars don't want to see attachments to posts in the
newsgroups.

Any way you can post it on a website and just share the link to that
site?

ExcelMonkey wrote:

What is the easiest way for me to share a routine I have
built with this newsgroup given that it has userforms?
That is, if it doesn't have forms then I can just drop the
code in and share it with you all. However if it is
loaded with forms and controls, the code isn't enough. Do
people submit full xla files to the group? Can they?

Thanks

--

Dave Peterson

News servers constitute a *peer-to-peer* network. MS doesn't own it.
There is no central source. MS doesn't decide what is and is not
appropriate for the global network. It can decide what happens only on
the *one* domain under its control, i.e., msnews.microsoft.com

MS doesn't even own or control the newsgroups in the microsoft.*
heirarchy. For example, for a long time it tried deleting
..public.excel but most news servers ignored the deletion. Eventually,
MS resurrected the NG on its own server. Similarly, I believe there is
a NG named worksheetfunctions whereas MS prefers worksheet.functions
However, it cannot force any server that doesn't want to to remove the
NG.

--
Regards,

Tushar Mehta
www.tushar-mehta.com
Excel, PowerPoint, and VBA add-ins, tutorials
Custom MS Office productivity solutions

In article ,
says...
Okay, so the expected argument. But then surely the argument is to raise
with MS to forbid attachments, delete them at source, rather than
fruitlessly banging on at people who do post, or even recipients like
yourself having to delete any such offending items.

Problem, not symptom.


Bob


"Tushar Mehta" wrote in message
om...
News servers form a gobal peer-to-peer network. Post something to one
and it is propagated to *every* server around the world.

Many hosts that carry newsgroups prohibit binary posts in text-only
newsgroups. Such messages are simply deleted by the server.

Some others may impose limits on how much space is dedicated to a
particular newsgroup. One large binary file can force the deletion of
dozens (or even hundreds) of text-only messages.

Some services impose limits on the rate at which a customer can
download data from a news server. Even accidentally downloading a
large binary file can result in that limit being exceeded.

Newsgroups constitute a push technology in terms of keeping news
servers up-to-date, though there is a pull flavor to the client-server
interaction. Putting a file on a website is strictly a pull
technology.

--
Regards,

Tushar Mehta
www.tushar-mehta.com
Excel, PowerPoint, and VBA add-ins, tutorials
Custom MS Office productivity solutions

In article ,
says...
Whilst I am not suggesting that people do attach to the NG, can someone
explain to me the difference between posting it to an NG and to a
website?

In both cases, AFAIK, you can save the file to your machine and virus
check
it, or you can leave it alone. And if you open it, you can disable
macros.

Just asking.

Bob


"Dave Peterson" wrote in message
...
Most regulars don't want to see attachments to posts in the
newsgroups.

Any way you can post it on a website and just share the link to that
site?

ExcelMonkey wrote:

What is the easiest way for me to share a routine I have
built with this newsgroup given that it has userforms?
That is, if it doesn't have forms then I can just drop the
code in and share it with you all. However if it is
loaded with forms and controls, the code isn't enough. Do
people submit full xla files to the group? Can they?

Thanks

--

Dave Peterson