Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.misc
DigitalDuck
 
Posts: n/a
Default Multiple Regression R^2 Issue

Whenever I run a multiple regression it always tells me that my R^2 is 1
Now I know these numbers aren't that good.
Maybe someone can help me figure this out.
Here is what it outputs in the summary field:
Regression Statistics:
Multiple R: 1
R Squa 1
Adj. R Squa -1.2E-09
Standard Error: 1.15E-10
Observations 3

I have 7 input variables each with 3 observations.
Anyone know what is going on or if I am just screwing it up and reading it
wrong?
I haven't been in stat for a while, and when I was I used SPSS which was way
more user friendly.
Thanks.

I know there are very ef
  #2   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.misc
Jerry W. Lewis
 
Posts: n/a
Default Multiple Regression R^2 Issue

I am not sure what you were intending to do, but you appear to have asked
Excel to fit 3 variables (or 2 variables and an intercept) to 3 data points,
which by definition will fit perfectly (though is unlikely to be meaningful).

Jerry

"DigitalDuck" wrote:

Whenever I run a multiple regression it always tells me that my R^2 is 1
Now I know these numbers aren't that good.
Maybe someone can help me figure this out.
Here is what it outputs in the summary field:
Regression Statistics:
Multiple R: 1
R Squa 1
Adj. R Squa -1.2E-09
Standard Error: 1.15E-10
Observations 3

I have 7 input variables each with 3 observations.
Anyone know what is going on or if I am just screwing it up and reading it
wrong?
I haven't been in stat for a while, and when I was I used SPSS which was way
more user friendly.
Thanks.

I know there are very ef

  #3   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.misc
DigitalDuck
 
Posts: n/a
Default Multiple Regression R^2 Issue

That makes sense. So in order to have it not = 1 I need to add more data
points for each variable, correct?


"Jerry W. Lewis" wrote:

I am not sure what you were intending to do, but you appear to have asked
Excel to fit 3 variables (or 2 variables and an intercept) to 3 data points,
which by definition will fit perfectly (though is unlikely to be meaningful).

Jerry

"DigitalDuck" wrote:

Whenever I run a multiple regression it always tells me that my R^2 is 1
Now I know these numbers aren't that good.
Maybe someone can help me figure this out.
Here is what it outputs in the summary field:
Regression Statistics:
Multiple R: 1
R Squa 1
Adj. R Squa -1.2E-09
Standard Error: 1.15E-10
Observations 3

I have 7 input variables each with 3 observations.
Anyone know what is going on or if I am just screwing it up and reading it
wrong?
I haven't been in stat for a while, and when I was I used SPSS which was way
more user friendly.
Thanks.

I know there are very ef

  #4   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.misc
DigitalDuck
 
Posts: n/a
Default Multiple Regression R^2 Issue

However, when I run a single regression on just one variable's data, even
though it is only 3 data entries, it gives me a R^2 anywhere from .08 to .98
which would make sense to me. Why when I add multiple variables would it
then change to being 1 when it seemingly works for single variable?

"DigitalDuck" wrote:

That makes sense. So in order to have it not = 1 I need to add more data
points for each variable, correct?


"Jerry W. Lewis" wrote:

I am not sure what you were intending to do, but you appear to have asked
Excel to fit 3 variables (or 2 variables and an intercept) to 3 data points,
which by definition will fit perfectly (though is unlikely to be meaningful).

Jerry

"DigitalDuck" wrote:

Whenever I run a multiple regression it always tells me that my R^2 is 1
Now I know these numbers aren't that good.
Maybe someone can help me figure this out.
Here is what it outputs in the summary field:
Regression Statistics:
Multiple R: 1
R Squa 1
Adj. R Squa -1.2E-09
Standard Error: 1.15E-10
Observations 3

I have 7 input variables each with 3 observations.
Anyone know what is going on or if I am just screwing it up and reading it
wrong?
I haven't been in stat for a while, and when I was I used SPSS which was way
more user friendly.
Thanks.

I know there are very ef

  #5   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.misc
Jerry W. Lewis
 
Posts: n/a
Default Multiple Regression R^2 Issue

When your model has as many free parameters as data points, then there are
zero degrees of freedom for lack of fit. The fit will be perfect and R^2
will be one.

Jerry

"DigitalDuck" wrote:

However, when I run a single regression on just one variable's data, even
though it is only 3 data entries, it gives me a R^2 anywhere from .08 to .98
which would make sense to me. Why when I add multiple variables would it
then change to being 1 when it seemingly works for single variable?

"DigitalDuck" wrote:

That makes sense. So in order to have it not = 1 I need to add more data
points for each variable, correct?


"Jerry W. Lewis" wrote:

I am not sure what you were intending to do, but you appear to have asked
Excel to fit 3 variables (or 2 variables and an intercept) to 3 data points,
which by definition will fit perfectly (though is unlikely to be meaningful).

Jerry

"DigitalDuck" wrote:

Whenever I run a multiple regression it always tells me that my R^2 is 1
Now I know these numbers aren't that good.
Maybe someone can help me figure this out.
Here is what it outputs in the summary field:
Regression Statistics:
Multiple R: 1
R Squa 1
Adj. R Squa -1.2E-09
Standard Error: 1.15E-10
Observations 3

I have 7 input variables each with 3 observations.
Anyone know what is going on or if I am just screwing it up and reading it
wrong?
I haven't been in stat for a while, and when I was I used SPSS which was way
more user friendly.
Thanks.

I know there are very ef

Reply
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
How do I put days of the week into a multiple regression model? Paula Excel Worksheet Functions 2 February 6th 06 09:34 AM
multiple regression template Denise Excel Worksheet Functions 2 December 1st 05 01:20 PM
How do I perform multiple regression in Excel using two independe Freda Excel Worksheet Functions 2 November 29th 05 04:59 PM
multiple regression September21 New Users to Excel 5 September 25th 05 11:48 PM
Multiple Regression in Excel 2002 SP3 (Office XP)? KA Excel Worksheet Functions 3 September 23rd 05 01:50 AM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:43 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 ExcelBanter.
The comments are property of their posters.
 

About Us

"It's about Microsoft Excel"