Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1   Report Post  
Old January 29th 09, 11:29 AM posted to microsoft.public.excel.misc
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by ExcelBanter: Jan 2009
Posts: 5
Default reverse percentage calculation

I have encountered a strange problem which I can't get my head around, will
try to explain as best I can.

I am trying to calculate the value of a product which when multiplied by a
figure, will then have 10% deducted from the total leaving a final total.

However the final total has to be above a minimum value.

I can calculate the amount with the percentage deduction getting involved
but I am unable to wrap my brain around getting the percentage involved.

eg. Goal is 15, and multiplier is 1.20

so the amount should be 15 / 1.20 = 12.50 (so far so easy)

this 12.50 is then rounded up to nearest whole number becoming 13.00

now this rounded up number is multiplied by multiplier to get the total

13.00 * 1.20 = 15.60 (which is above the goal of 15)


Now there needs to be a 10% deduction from the total

10% of 15.60 = 1.56 to deduct

final total = 14.04 (this is now under the goal amount)


My question is this, can this be calculated in a formula to work out the 10%
deduction and if that takes the final total below the goal, can I then work
out what the amount should be to keep it above the goal.

Hope the above can be understood by someone as it sure confuses me...

Many thanks,

G Baker

  #2   Report Post  
Old January 29th 09, 11:44 AM posted to microsoft.public.excel.misc
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by ExcelBanter: Apr 2007
Posts: 11,501
Default reverse percentage calculation

Try this


=MAX(15,(ROUNDUP(15/1.2,0)*1.2*0.9))


In practice I'd have all these values in cells an reference the cells in the
formula.

Mike

"Gavin Baker" wrote:

I have encountered a strange problem which I can't get my head around, will
try to explain as best I can.

I am trying to calculate the value of a product which when multiplied by a
figure, will then have 10% deducted from the total leaving a final total.

However the final total has to be above a minimum value.

I can calculate the amount with the percentage deduction getting involved
but I am unable to wrap my brain around getting the percentage involved.

eg. Goal is 15, and multiplier is 1.20

so the amount should be 15 / 1.20 = 12.50 (so far so easy)

this 12.50 is then rounded up to nearest whole number becoming 13.00

now this rounded up number is multiplied by multiplier to get the total

13.00 * 1.20 = 15.60 (which is above the goal of 15)


Now there needs to be a 10% deduction from the total

10% of 15.60 = 1.56 to deduct

final total = 14.04 (this is now under the goal amount)


My question is this, can this be calculated in a formula to work out the 10%
deduction and if that takes the final total below the goal, can I then work
out what the amount should be to keep it above the goal.

Hope the above can be understood by someone as it sure confuses me...

Many thanks,

G Baker

  #3   Report Post  
Old January 29th 09, 12:04 PM posted to microsoft.public.excel.misc
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by ExcelBanter: Feb 2007
Posts: 8,651
Default reverse percentage calculation

If your goal of 15 is in A1, and your 15.60 is in F1, then your deduction
will be =MIN(F1*10%,F1-A1)

For any reasonably large starting point, of course, you won't get near the
10% figure, because all you are deducting is the effect of the whole number
rounding between your division by 1.2 and the multiplying back up by 1.2.
You'd only get to 10% if your starting number were small so that the whole
number rounding between those steps becomes more significant.
--
David Biddulph

"Gavin Baker" wrote in message
...
I have encountered a strange problem which I can't get my head around, will
try to explain as best I can.

I am trying to calculate the value of a product which when multiplied by a
figure, will then have 10% deducted from the total leaving a final total.

However the final total has to be above a minimum value.

I can calculate the amount with the percentage deduction getting involved
but I am unable to wrap my brain around getting the percentage involved.

eg. Goal is 15, and multiplier is 1.20

so the amount should be 15 / 1.20 = 12.50 (so far so easy)

this 12.50 is then rounded up to nearest whole number becoming 13.00

now this rounded up number is multiplied by multiplier to get the total

13.00 * 1.20 = 15.60 (which is above the goal of 15)


Now there needs to be a 10% deduction from the total

10% of 15.60 = 1.56 to deduct

final total = 14.04 (this is now under the goal amount)


My question is this, can this be calculated in a formula to work out the
10%
deduction and if that takes the final total below the goal, can I then
work
out what the amount should be to keep it above the goal.

Hope the above can be understood by someone as it sure confuses me...

Many thanks,

G Baker



  #4   Report Post  
Old January 29th 09, 12:13 PM posted to microsoft.public.excel.misc
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by ExcelBanter: Jan 2009
Posts: 5
Default reverse percentage calculation

That seems to work, could you explain where the 0.9 comes from at the end of
the formula? so that I can reference it to the relevant cells.

Also would it make any difference if the percentage changed for different
line, eg some at 10% some at 15% etc.

Many thanks,

G Baker

"Mike H" wrote:

Try this


=MAX(15,(ROUNDUP(15/1.2,0)*1.2*0.9))


In practice I'd have all these values in cells an reference the cells in the
formula.

Mike

"Gavin Baker" wrote:

I have encountered a strange problem which I can't get my head around, will
try to explain as best I can.

I am trying to calculate the value of a product which when multiplied by a
figure, will then have 10% deducted from the total leaving a final total.

However the final total has to be above a minimum value.

I can calculate the amount with the percentage deduction getting involved
but I am unable to wrap my brain around getting the percentage involved.

eg. Goal is 15, and multiplier is 1.20

so the amount should be 15 / 1.20 = 12.50 (so far so easy)

this 12.50 is then rounded up to nearest whole number becoming 13.00

now this rounded up number is multiplied by multiplier to get the total

13.00 * 1.20 = 15.60 (which is above the goal of 15)


Now there needs to be a 10% deduction from the total

10% of 15.60 = 1.56 to deduct

final total = 14.04 (this is now under the goal amount)


My question is this, can this be calculated in a formula to work out the 10%
deduction and if that takes the final total below the goal, can I then work
out what the amount should be to keep it above the goal.

Hope the above can be understood by someone as it sure confuses me...

Many thanks,

G Baker

  #5   Report Post  
Old January 29th 09, 12:24 PM posted to microsoft.public.excel.misc
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by ExcelBanter: Apr 2007
Posts: 11,501
Default reverse percentage calculation

Hi,

That seems to work, could you explain where the 0.9 comes from


Multiplying by .9 subtracts the 10% you required.

Mike

"Gavin Baker" wrote:

That seems to work, could you explain where the 0.9 comes from at the end of
the formula? so that I can reference it to the relevant cells.

Also would it make any difference if the percentage changed for different
line, eg some at 10% some at 15% etc.

Many thanks,

G Baker

"Mike H" wrote:

Try this


=MAX(15,(ROUNDUP(15/1.2,0)*1.2*0.9))


In practice I'd have all these values in cells an reference the cells in the
formula.

Mike

"Gavin Baker" wrote:

I have encountered a strange problem which I can't get my head around, will
try to explain as best I can.

I am trying to calculate the value of a product which when multiplied by a
figure, will then have 10% deducted from the total leaving a final total.

However the final total has to be above a minimum value.

I can calculate the amount with the percentage deduction getting involved
but I am unable to wrap my brain around getting the percentage involved.

eg. Goal is 15, and multiplier is 1.20

so the amount should be 15 / 1.20 = 12.50 (so far so easy)

this 12.50 is then rounded up to nearest whole number becoming 13.00

now this rounded up number is multiplied by multiplier to get the total

13.00 * 1.20 = 15.60 (which is above the goal of 15)


Now there needs to be a 10% deduction from the total

10% of 15.60 = 1.56 to deduct

final total = 14.04 (this is now under the goal amount)


My question is this, can this be calculated in a formula to work out the 10%
deduction and if that takes the final total below the goal, can I then work
out what the amount should be to keep it above the goal.

Hope the above can be understood by someone as it sure confuses me...

Many thanks,

G Baker



  #6   Report Post  
Old January 29th 09, 12:26 PM posted to microsoft.public.excel.misc
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by ExcelBanter: Apr 2007
Posts: 11,501
Default reverse percentage calculation

Gavin

Sorry missed the second bit. That precisely why I made the comment before
that in practice I'd have these values in cells and reference them and not as
part of the formula. If you then want to change the discount from 10% (*0.9)
to 15% (*0.85) then changing a single cell will update multiple formula.

Mike

"Gavin Baker" wrote:

That seems to work, could you explain where the 0.9 comes from at the end of
the formula? so that I can reference it to the relevant cells.

Also would it make any difference if the percentage changed for different
line, eg some at 10% some at 15% etc.

Many thanks,

G Baker

"Mike H" wrote:

Try this


=MAX(15,(ROUNDUP(15/1.2,0)*1.2*0.9))


In practice I'd have all these values in cells an reference the cells in the
formula.

Mike

"Gavin Baker" wrote:

I have encountered a strange problem which I can't get my head around, will
try to explain as best I can.

I am trying to calculate the value of a product which when multiplied by a
figure, will then have 10% deducted from the total leaving a final total.

However the final total has to be above a minimum value.

I can calculate the amount with the percentage deduction getting involved
but I am unable to wrap my brain around getting the percentage involved.

eg. Goal is 15, and multiplier is 1.20

so the amount should be 15 / 1.20 = 12.50 (so far so easy)

this 12.50 is then rounded up to nearest whole number becoming 13.00

now this rounded up number is multiplied by multiplier to get the total

13.00 * 1.20 = 15.60 (which is above the goal of 15)


Now there needs to be a 10% deduction from the total

10% of 15.60 = 1.56 to deduct

final total = 14.04 (this is now under the goal amount)


My question is this, can this be calculated in a formula to work out the 10%
deduction and if that takes the final total below the goal, can I then work
out what the amount should be to keep it above the goal.

Hope the above can be understood by someone as it sure confuses me...

Many thanks,

G Baker

  #7   Report Post  
Old January 29th 09, 12:44 PM posted to microsoft.public.excel.misc
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by ExcelBanter: Jan 2009
Posts: 5
Default reverse percentage calculation

thanks, i have a calculation as follows to work out the "*0.9" value
(1-(1*percentage))

so for 10% = 0.9 15% = 0.85

testing the rest out right now


"Mike H" wrote:

Gavin

Sorry missed the second bit. That precisely why I made the comment before
that in practice I'd have these values in cells and reference them and not as
part of the formula. If you then want to change the discount from 10% (*0.9)
to 15% (*0.85) then changing a single cell will update multiple formula.

Mike

"Gavin Baker" wrote:

That seems to work, could you explain where the 0.9 comes from at the end of
the formula? so that I can reference it to the relevant cells.

Also would it make any difference if the percentage changed for different
line, eg some at 10% some at 15% etc.

Many thanks,

G Baker

"Mike H" wrote:

Try this


=MAX(15,(ROUNDUP(15/1.2,0)*1.2*0.9))


In practice I'd have all these values in cells an reference the cells in the
formula.

Mike

"Gavin Baker" wrote:

I have encountered a strange problem which I can't get my head around, will
try to explain as best I can.

I am trying to calculate the value of a product which when multiplied by a
figure, will then have 10% deducted from the total leaving a final total.

However the final total has to be above a minimum value.

I can calculate the amount with the percentage deduction getting involved
but I am unable to wrap my brain around getting the percentage involved.

eg. Goal is 15, and multiplier is 1.20

so the amount should be 15 / 1.20 = 12.50 (so far so easy)

this 12.50 is then rounded up to nearest whole number becoming 13.00

now this rounded up number is multiplied by multiplier to get the total

13.00 * 1.20 = 15.60 (which is above the goal of 15)


Now there needs to be a 10% deduction from the total

10% of 15.60 = 1.56 to deduct

final total = 14.04 (this is now under the goal amount)


My question is this, can this be calculated in a formula to work out the 10%
deduction and if that takes the final total below the goal, can I then work
out what the amount should be to keep it above the goal.

Hope the above can be understood by someone as it sure confuses me...

Many thanks,

G Baker

  #8   Report Post  
Old January 29th 09, 12:47 PM posted to microsoft.public.excel.misc
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by ExcelBanter: Jan 2009
Posts: 5
Default reverse percentage calculation

am I correct in thinking this will give the minimum of either the deduction
"1.56" or the difference between total and goal "0.6"?

figures are from current example values.

these values are already calculated as I thought they may be needed in some
other calculation later.

thanks for the advice.

"David Biddulph" wrote:

If your goal of 15 is in A1, and your 15.60 is in F1, then your deduction
will be =MIN(F1*10%,F1-A1)

For any reasonably large starting point, of course, you won't get near the
10% figure, because all you are deducting is the effect of the whole number
rounding between your division by 1.2 and the multiplying back up by 1.2.
You'd only get to 10% if your starting number were small so that the whole
number rounding between those steps becomes more significant.
--
David Biddulph

"Gavin Baker" wrote in message
...
I have encountered a strange problem which I can't get my head around, will
try to explain as best I can.

I am trying to calculate the value of a product which when multiplied by a
figure, will then have 10% deducted from the total leaving a final total.

However the final total has to be above a minimum value.

I can calculate the amount with the percentage deduction getting involved
but I am unable to wrap my brain around getting the percentage involved.

eg. Goal is 15, and multiplier is 1.20

so the amount should be 15 / 1.20 = 12.50 (so far so easy)

this 12.50 is then rounded up to nearest whole number becoming 13.00

now this rounded up number is multiplied by multiplier to get the total

13.00 * 1.20 = 15.60 (which is above the goal of 15)


Now there needs to be a 10% deduction from the total

10% of 15.60 = 1.56 to deduct

final total = 14.04 (this is now under the goal amount)


My question is this, can this be calculated in a formula to work out the
10%
deduction and if that takes the final total below the goal, can I then
work
out what the amount should be to keep it above the goal.

Hope the above can be understood by someone as it sure confuses me...

Many thanks,

G Baker




  #9   Report Post  
Old January 29th 09, 01:09 PM posted to microsoft.public.excel.misc
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by ExcelBanter: Jan 2009
Posts: 5
Default reverse percentage calculation

Almost works see test values below

your suggested formula gives the value of 15 (although i suspect that is
coming from being the maximum between the goal (15) and the rounded up value
(13.26))

using 13 the final total with the 10% deduction comes to 14.04 = too low

using 14 the final total with deduction comes to 15.12 = this is what i need

using the 15 from your formula the final total is 16.20 = a bit too high

does that help illustrate the problem?

Thanks for the help so far,

G Baker

"Mike H" wrote:

Gavin

Sorry missed the second bit. That precisely why I made the comment before
that in practice I'd have these values in cells and reference them and not as
part of the formula. If you then want to change the discount from 10% (*0.9)
to 15% (*0.85) then changing a single cell will update multiple formula.

Mike

"Gavin Baker" wrote:

That seems to work, could you explain where the 0.9 comes from at the end of
the formula? so that I can reference it to the relevant cells.

Also would it make any difference if the percentage changed for different
line, eg some at 10% some at 15% etc.

Many thanks,

G Baker

"Mike H" wrote:

Try this


=MAX(15,(ROUNDUP(15/1.2,0)*1.2*0.9))


In practice I'd have all these values in cells an reference the cells in the
formula.

Mike

"Gavin Baker" wrote:

I have encountered a strange problem which I can't get my head around, will
try to explain as best I can.

I am trying to calculate the value of a product which when multiplied by a
figure, will then have 10% deducted from the total leaving a final total.

However the final total has to be above a minimum value.

I can calculate the amount with the percentage deduction getting involved
but I am unable to wrap my brain around getting the percentage involved.

eg. Goal is 15, and multiplier is 1.20

so the amount should be 15 / 1.20 = 12.50 (so far so easy)

this 12.50 is then rounded up to nearest whole number becoming 13.00

now this rounded up number is multiplied by multiplier to get the total

13.00 * 1.20 = 15.60 (which is above the goal of 15)


Now there needs to be a 10% deduction from the total

10% of 15.60 = 1.56 to deduct

final total = 14.04 (this is now under the goal amount)


My question is this, can this be calculated in a formula to work out the 10%
deduction and if that takes the final total below the goal, can I then work
out what the amount should be to keep it above the goal.

Hope the above can be understood by someone as it sure confuses me...

Many thanks,

G Baker

  #10   Report Post  
Old January 29th 09, 02:01 PM posted to microsoft.public.excel.misc
external usenet poster
 
First recorded activity by ExcelBanter: Feb 2007
Posts: 8,651
Default reverse percentage calculation

Yes, if you've already calculated your 1.56 and 0.6, the MIN function will
give the minimum of those two.

MIN is a standard Excel function, so its syntax (and examples of the use)
can be seen in Excel help.
--
David Biddulph

"Gavin Baker" wrote in message
...
am I correct in thinking this will give the minimum of either the
deduction
"1.56" or the difference between total and goal "0.6"?

figures are from current example values.

these values are already calculated as I thought they may be needed in
some
other calculation later.

thanks for the advice.

"David Biddulph" wrote:

If your goal of 15 is in A1, and your 15.60 is in F1, then your deduction
will be =MIN(F1*10%,F1-A1)

For any reasonably large starting point, of course, you won't get near
the
10% figure, because all you are deducting is the effect of the whole
number
rounding between your division by 1.2 and the multiplying back up by 1.2.
You'd only get to 10% if your starting number were small so that the
whole
number rounding between those steps becomes more significant.
--
David Biddulph

"Gavin Baker" wrote in message
...
I have encountered a strange problem which I can't get my head around,
will
try to explain as best I can.

I am trying to calculate the value of a product which when multiplied
by a
figure, will then have 10% deducted from the total leaving a final
total.

However the final total has to be above a minimum value.

I can calculate the amount with the percentage deduction getting
involved
but I am unable to wrap my brain around getting the percentage
involved.

eg. Goal is 15, and multiplier is 1.20

so the amount should be 15 / 1.20 = 12.50 (so far so easy)

this 12.50 is then rounded up to nearest whole number becoming 13.00

now this rounded up number is multiplied by multiplier to get the total

13.00 * 1.20 = 15.60 (which is above the goal of 15)


Now there needs to be a 10% deduction from the total

10% of 15.60 = 1.56 to deduct

final total = 14.04 (this is now under the goal amount)


My question is this, can this be calculated in a formula to work out
the
10%
deduction and if that takes the final total below the goal, can I then
work
out what the amount should be to keep it above the goal.

Hope the above can be understood by someone as it sure confuses me...

Many thanks,

G Baker








Reply
Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules

Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Percentage calculation mmacnz Excel Discussion (Misc queries) 3 October 22nd 07 05:54 AM
percentage calculation Gabriel Excel Discussion (Misc queries) 1 August 28th 06 09:31 AM
'of' percentage with calculation Steve Crowther Excel Discussion (Misc queries) 2 May 22nd 06 09:58 AM
reverse principle calculation Demi Excel Worksheet Functions 3 March 30th 06 12:40 AM
Percentage calculation Roz Excel Discussion (Misc queries) 5 January 6th 06 07:05 PM


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 01:01 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright 2004-2017 ExcelBanter.
The comments are property of their posters.
 

About Us

"It's about Microsoft Excel"

 

Copyright © 2017