Home |
Search |
Today's Posts |
#3
![]()
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.misc
|
|||
|
|||
![]()
On Jun 12, 12:02 pm, BenS wrote:
The thing that puzzles me is that if I chart this data it looks perfectly linear for the forecasted values. Thus I would expect a uniform rate of growth. But when I look at the month-over month growth rate, it steadily declines from 3.197% in Jun 2007 to 1.546% by April 2010. Can anyone help me understand what is going on? Is FORECAST the best way to do what I am atttempting? I cannot answer the second question. It really depends on what you believe is the (more) correct model for your situation. But I might be able to help you with the first question. It is really surprising for many people. FORECAST() is based a on a linear -- straight-line -- formula, as you say. That is, it assumes a constant __amount__ of change per period, measured in the units being measured. If, instead, you expect a constant __percentage__ change per period, that results in an exponential curve, not a straight line. Use the GROWTH() function for that. You might be able to understand the difference better with a concrete example. Suppose you start with 10000 and you add 1000 every period. The first period, 1000/10000 is 10% growth. But the second period, 1000/11000 is 9.09% growth; and the third period, 1000/12000 is 8.33% growth; and so on. The __percentage__ growth decreases each period because the constant numerator becomes increasing smaller compared to the increasing denominator. In contrast, suppose you start with 10000 and you add 10% every period. The first period, 10000*10% is 1000. But the second period, 11000*10% is 1100; and the third period, 12100*10% is 1210; and so on. The __amount__ of change increases each period because the same percentage of an increasing larger number is an increasing amount. That is, a percentage of a large pie is bigger than the same percentage of a small pie. That is really the power of compounding growth. Does all that make sense now? Applying this to your financial situation, you need to decide if growth by constant amount or by constant rate (percentage) best fits your real-life situation. HTH. |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
![]() |
||||
Thread | Forum | |||
Excel: How to forecast 12 months' figures but force a 10% growth? | Excel Worksheet Functions | |||
Average Growth Rate | Excel Discussion (Misc queries) | |||
Growth Rate | Excel Discussion (Misc queries) | |||
trouble with a growth rate | Excel Worksheet Functions | |||
monthly growth rate | Excel Worksheet Functions |