Hi Luke,

Thanks, never ignore the obvious. I had unchecked it; but on Column A
which of course now makes no sense.

I knew of Deb's Dependent Validation page and have used it often; but
this was a little different in that based on ColumnA, it could a full
list of a subset of full list (Advertising) so I don't think that
would work with her example.

Thanks again.


On Mar 19, 12:07*pm, "Luke M" wrote:
I'm guessing you may just need to uncheck the "ignore blank" on the
validation dialogue. However, here's an alternative way to make dynamic
validation lists:http://www.contextures.com/xlDataval02.html

--
Best Regards,

Luke M"willwonka" wrote in message

...



So I have two columns of Data Validations:

Column A we'll call Cost Centers
Column B we'll *call Accounts

If somebody puts in a Cost Center for a specific department which we
will call Advertising, then a different list shows up in Column B of
only Advertising Accts. *I use the following formula in Column B for
my Data Validation:

=IF(ISERROR(VLOOKUP(A5,advertising,1,0)),accounts, advaccts) where
"accounts" is all accounts and "advaccts" is only advertising
accounts.

That works ok. *I'm sure that is not the best way of doing it; but
here is my problem.

If I don't put anything in Column A, users can type anything into
Column B and there is no Data Validation. *I was hoping that it would
use the "accounts" list as validation if nothing was entered into
Column A.

Thoughts on how to keep data validation on column B if nothing is put
into Column A?- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -