Ok, I don't understand what you're now trying to do?

--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Richard" wrote in message
...
Hi there, small glitch.
I added another data set to parent and child.
Formula refers to B10 for acceptable value and the acceptable answers are
either nylon or rubber.
I moved acceptable values to A6:A7 and changed formula accordingly.
I F4'd the data ranges as well,

parent child child child
widget1 nylon carton1 tape
widget2 carton2 rubber film
widget3 rubber carton1 tape


nylon
rubber


widget1
=IF(COUNT(MATCH($A$6:$A$7,INDEX($B$2:$D$4,MATCH($A 10,$A$2:$A$4,0),0),0)),$A$6:$A$7,"error")

The formula now returns error.
If I apply an array it returns nylon but ignores the other value of rubber
when I add other product codes in A11 which should return rubber.

Would appreciate some more guidance please.

Thanks
Richard


--
Richard


"T. Valko" wrote:

You're welcome. Thanks for the feedback!

--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Richard" wrote in message
...
Okay brilliant, thank you.
Tried it out and it makes sense.
Will extend it now to the actual workbook.
Really grateful
--
Richard


"T. Valko" wrote:

If I understand what you want, try this...

This data in the range A2:D3 -

widget1 nylon carton1 tape
widget2 rubber carton2 film

A10 = parent lookup value = widget1

B10:B11 = list of acceptable values

Enter this formula in C10 and copy down to C11:

=IF(COUNT(MATCH(B10,INDEX(B$2:D$3,MATCH(A$10,A$2:A $3,0),0),0)),B10,"error")

--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Richard" wrote in message
...
bill of material;
parent child child child
widget1 nylon carton1 tape
widget2 rubber carton2 film

list of acceptable values
nylon
rubber

if the result of looking up a cell with widget1 returns a value
which
is
in
the list of acceptable values, return value, if not return "error"

So the first cell with the formula would be targeted to return an
acceptable
value from a list of raw materials such as nylon or rubber say.
Another cell would then have a similar formula but with say an
acceptable
value concerning cartons.

Each set of child parts would only ever contain one raw material in
the
acceptable value list, never multiples.

The database is extracted using Microsoft Query from a stock control
program.
There are about 4500 parent parts and upto a maximum of 8 child
parts
per
parent.

Thanks, hope this gives you an idea of what I am stuck on.
(Is there a way I can post a spreadsheet example if this explanation
is
not
clear)
Best regards
--
Richard


"T. Valko" wrote:

Can you post a small example and the expected result?

--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"Richard" wrote in message
...
I have two data tables in Excel 2007.
Table A holds a bill of materials with parent and child parts
laid
out
suitable for use with vlookup.
Table B holds a selected list of raw materials which are child
parts.

I want to lookup a parent part from a cell and search for one of
its
child
parts in table A if the result of the search matches one of the
raw
materials
in table B.

I can do simple vlookups but this is outside my knowledge.
Can anyone please point me in the right direction?
Thanks

--
Richard


.



.



.