View Single Post
  #4   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.misc
M Thompson M Thompson is offline
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 37
Default Formula computing problem

Sorry-didn't explain properly. If I do a total of the data I've input
(I9-I11), the result is 855.29. The result of the calculation on that is
20.10, which is correct and what I need to see. If I don't do a total of the
input data, but do a sum of the calculated answers for each individual piece
it comes to 24.25. Why so much difference?

--
OneFineDay


"T. Valko" wrote:

Are you saying that the total of:

-14.42 + -7.93 + -1.91

Should be -20.10

If so, you'll have to explain why you think that should be the result.

The formulas are returning the correct results. Maybe they're not doing what
you think they're doing.

--
Biff
Microsoft Excel MVP


"M Thompson" wrote in message
...
I'm hoping someone somewhere can tell me what's happening and how to fix
it.
This is the formula I'm using:
=-MAX(0,MIN(I9,100)*0.05)+-MAX(0,(I9-100)*0.02) and copy down through I11

Starting in I9 I have the following amounts.
I Results i'm getting
570.75 (14.42)
246.36 (7.93)
38.18 (1.91)

If I do a Total cell and use the same calculation on it, the answer will
be
20.10, which is what I expect. The results of 9-11 are obviously going to
total to more than 20.10. Can someone explain what's happening and is
there
a way to fix it so that the results are reasonably in line. It seems to
me
to be too big a difference to be a rounding thing??

Thanks
--
OneFineDay