here is the problem:

A B C
1 Apple .40 =Index(A1:A5,Match(Large(B1:B5,1),0))
(Returns-Peach)
2 Orange .30 =Index(A1:A5,Match(Large(B1:B5,2),0))
(Returns-Apple)
3 Banana .20 =Index(A1:A5,Match(large(B1:B5,3),0))
(Returns-Apple)
4 Pear .40 =Index(A1:A5,Match(Large(B1:B5,4),0))
(Returns-Orange)
5 Peach .50 =Index(A1:A5,Match(Large(B1:B5,5),0))
(Returns-Banana)

Is there a way to have the formula in C3 return Pear?