Hi!

=[CUBIE.XLS]Sheet1!E5

Will work if the WB CUBIE is opened or closed.

=INDIRECT("[CUBIE.XLS]Sheet1!" & $H$3)

Will only work if the WB CUBIE is open. As soon as you
close CUBIE and a calculation occurs in your active WB
you'll get a #REF! error.

Biff

-----Original Message-----
I'm trying to link to an external worksheet and would
like to specify the
cell indirectly. Instead of explicitly referencing the
cell I would like to
determine the cell by a formula.

Instead of this:
=[CUBIE.XLS]Sheet1!E5

I would like to calculate "E5" and store it in the
current worksheet cell
[H3]. How can I have an external link using this
indirect reference? How
different would this look if the external document is
open or not?

For example, these attempts did not work:
=[CUBIE.XLS]Sheet1!$H$3]
=INDIRECT("[CUBIE.XLS]Sheet1! & $H$3")

Thanks,
Doug
.