Complicated If, AND, OR - Conflict
OK, I think I understand (thanks),,, but who do I "break-out" of my
"imprisionment"?
My K Column has 18 unique BillingSystems and in the If(2) I'm trying to
INCLUDE ALL Except the "SCA/FACS NONCARILION" and the "SCA/NORTH CAROLIN",
meaning any of the 16 (18-the 2);
Accordingly, in My If(5) I'm trying to pull in ONLY the 1 BillingSystem
"SCA/FACS NONCARILION";
But HOW???
Thanks,
Jim May
"Niek Otten" wrote:
I meant this part:
"OR(NOT((K385="SCA/FACS NONCARILION")),NOT((K385="SCA/NORTH CAROLINA")))
If K385="SCA/FACS NONCARILION" then it is NOT "SCA/NORTH CAROLINA" so the OR returns TRUE
If K385 ="SCA/NORTH CAROLINA" then it is NOT ="SCA/FACS NONCARILION" so the OR returns TRUE
And if K385 NOT equals any of both, then it returns TRUE as well
--
Kind regards,
Niek Otten
Microsoft MVP - Excel
"Jim May" wrote in message ...
|I didn't understand your comment "A must be unequal to at least one of them",
| and still don't. Can you put it another way, that I can understand or give
| an example of what I must do for it in this case to return a FALSE (for the
| 2nd If)?
|
| Thanks,
|
|
| "Niek Otten" wrote:
|
| The second IF contains the construction I mentioned, which always returns TRUE
|
| --
| Kind regards,
|
| Niek Otten
| Microsoft MVP - Excel
|
| "Jim May" wrote in message ...
| | Thanks Niek -- I did as you said. And I see that on a record that should
| | come back "
| | "vsmc-sca-NonC" (the 5th If) - the 2nd If Is ALSO COMING Back True, so
| | naturally it is "grabbing" the FIRST If producing TRUE. So, my problem is in
| | my 2nd IF I'm sure. But I'm still stuck with IT !! (the 2nd If (isn't
| | corrent, obviously).. What's it's problem?
| |
| | Thanks,
| |
| | Jim May
| |
| | "Niek Otten" wrote:
| |
| | Why try to do this all in one formula? Break it up to intermediate results in different cells and integrate later, when
| testing is
| | finished.
| |
| | BTW, any construction like
| |
| | OR(NOT(A=1),NOT(A=2)) will always return TRUE; A must be unequal to at least one of them
| |
| | --
| | Kind regards,
| |
| | Niek Otten
| | Microsoft MVP - Excel
| |
| |
| |
| | "Jim May" wrote in message ...
| | | This formula is a "Work-in-progress",
| | | meaning I'm dealing with a rather complicated table structure (currently less
| | | than 7 If's), but, right now with 5 if's -- the formula IS NOT picking up any
| | | records showing "vsmc-sca-NonC" (the 5th If) but instead these same records
| | | are being assigned "VMD" (the 2nd If). Can you spot my problem?
| | |
| | | =IF(D385="Cash","Cash", <<1st If
| | |
| | | IF(AND(OR($D385="Discover",D385="MASTER",D385="Mas ter
| | | card",D385="VISA"),OR(NOT((K385="SCA/FACS NONCARILION")),NOT((K385="SCA/NORTH
| | | CAROLINA")))),"VMD", <<2nd If
| | |
| | | IF(AND(D385="null",C3850,OR(K385="SCA/FACS NONCARILION",K385="SCA/NORTH
| | | CAROLINA")),"bkdf-SCA", << 3rd If
| | |
| | | IF(AND(D385="null",C385<0,OR(K385="SCA/FACS NONCARILION",K385="SCA/NORTH
| | | CAROLINA")),"bkdf-SCA-Crs", <<4th IF
| | |
| | | IF(AND(OR(D385="MASTER",D385="VISA"),K385="SCA/FACS
| | | NONCARILION"),"vsmc-sca-NonC", <<5th If
| | |
| | | "bkdf"))))) << Current Default
| | |
| | | Much Appreciated..
| | |
| | | Jim May
| |
| |
| |
|
|
|
|