View Single Post
  #2   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.misc
Jim Rech Jim Rech is offline
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 2,718
Default Form buttons vs. ActiveX Buttons

2) the only way to change the name of a form button is with VBA code

Nope. Select the Forms toolbar button, then click in the Name box to the
left of the Formula bar and you can edit the name.

background color are all changeable.


I don't believe that's true of Forms buttons.

For my part I always use Forms buttons unless there is some feature of a
Control Toolbox button I need. They are simpler and lighter weight and
maybe more stable. Not a lot it in though so you really can't go wrong.


--
Jim
"GeorgeJ" wrote in message
...
I am working on an XL 2007 project requiring command buttons on a form.
When
I go into the developer tab and activate the design mode and then select
insert, I am presented with 2 options for a button - a "form" button" or
an
"Active X" button. I am trying to determine the advantanges and
disadvantages of each type vs. the other. So far this is what I have come
up
with...

1) Both types are flexible in appearance, e. g. the button size, location,
shape, text, text format, size and color, background color are all
changeable.

2) the only way to change the name of a form button is with VBA code, e.
g.


Sub ChangeButtonName()

activesheet.Shapes("Button1").Name = "Delete Departments Instructions"
End Sub

OTOH, the name of an ActiveX button can be changed by entering the
Designer mode and right clicking on the button and then selecting
properties
and changing the name property. The name of a form button may have spaces
in
it whereas the name of an ActiveX button may not


3) The code executed when an ActiveX button is pressed *must* be on the
code sheet for the worksheet on which the button is located, and the
routine
must have a name corresponding to the button, e. g.

Private Sub CommandButton1_Click()
MsgBox "Hello from CommandButton1"
End Sub

OTOH a form button can be given the name of the routine to execute when
the
button is pressed, and this routine can be located in any VBA module.
What's
more, the routine can even be declared private!

Am I correct in what I have stated about the 2 kinds of buttons? Which
kind
is recommended?

P.S. I have been speaking of command buttons, but as for labels, the
"Active X" kind seems better than the form kind because I can change the
text
size and color of Active X labels but can't seem to do that for form
labels.
It is possble to change text size and font and color on a form label ?


Thanks in advance


--
-regards