I have two worksheets. The first table contains a record for each parcel of
land in town (4500 +/-) containing a lot number ID (101-001-000-000), owners
name and assessment value. The second table contains only records of parcels
that are in a particular zoning district that is proposed (1900 +/-). I need
to pick the owners names and assessment values from the first table
matching the parcels in the second.

It seems I should use "VLOOKUP" -

Worksheet 1 has fields:

PARCEL_ID LOCATION OWNER TOTAL VALUE
(among others)

101-001-000-000 123 Your Street Joe Homeowner 450,000
101-002-000-000 456 Your Street Harry Homeowner 25,000
101-003-000-000 123 My Street Joe Doe
123,456
101-003-001-000 456 My Street Jane Doe
987,654
101-003-001-001 123 Any Street Andy Owner 53,222
and so on for 4500 records

Worksheet 2 has one field:

PARCEL_ID

101-001-000-000
101-003-001-001

only 1900 selected records of the total 4500.