View Single Post
  #1   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.worksheet.functions
klee
 
Posts: n/a
Default formula gives 2 different answers


hello

I've got a formula which gives me a wrong answer on some occusions. The
formula is below-

=IF(A1=A2,same,diff)

- if i type '1' in cell A1 and '1' in cell A2, it gives me the answer
'same' which is correct.

- if i type 'a' in cell A1 and 'a' in cell A2, it gives me the answer
'same' which is correct.

- if i type '1' in cell A1 and 'a' in cell A2, it gives me the answer
'diff' which is correct.

- if i type 'a' in cell A1 and '1' in cell A2, it gives me the answer
'diff' which is correct.

- if i type '1' in cell A1 and leave cell A2 BLANK, it gives me the
answer 'diff' which is correct.

- if i leave cell A1 BLANK and type in '1' in cell A2, it gives me the
answer 'diff' which is correct.

However!

- if i type 'a' in cell A1 and leave cell A2 BLANK, it gives me the
answer 'same' which is INCORRECT.

- if i leave cell A1 BLANK and type in 'a' in cell A2, it gives me the
answer 'same' which is INCORRECT.

It gives me the wrong answer if i have a 'blank' with a 'letter'. Does
anyone know why?

I've copied the same formula onto a new spreadsheet but it gives me the
correct answer. So it seems its something on the 1st sheet it doesn't
like.

I've also noticed if a type 'TRUE' or 'FALSE' in the 1st sheet it'll
convert it to the value of 1 or 0. However on the 2nd sheet the values
do not get converted. - not sure if this helps any1 thanks


--
klee
------------------------------------------------------------------------
klee's Profile: http://www.excelforum.com/member.php...o&userid=30304
View this thread: http://www.excelforum.com/showthread...hreadid=499685