Joe is understandably busy and hopefully doing well. For anyone else still looking, there's been a notable change to the way the to numbers being compared are calculated. Ten more rows have been added, and so the two numbers now being compared are J37 and W37. Further, they are now calculated by summing the same columns, but then multiplied a static percentage, then further multiplied further by a random percentage, set by the sheet's user columns S and T at the top. Then a static number is added. The version of the sheet I have uploaded can increase or decrease the value of J37 and W37 by as much as 20%. Directly to the right of those settings, it shows the current result of the random generation in the current calculation.

Latest sheet he https://rapidshare.com/files/3231189247/Combat.xlsm