No, works fine for me, XL2K.
You're not trying to run it on a cell that already has a comment, are you ?
Or i is not a valid row ?

NickHK

"Maury Markowitz" wrote in
message ...
"Dave Peterson" wrote:

The second line worked ok for me.

Urrrg. Ok, thanks for trying guys, I guess it's just one of those
mysteries.
No, there's no protection or anything, and you get the generic
"application
defined error" (thanks MS!)

Maury