Problem with small()....I think
 

Ok, A few weeks ago I asked for help in finding the smallest two numbers in a
group of numbers that were added together in order to reduce the total by the
smallest numbers. the form that was suggested was(using my cell locations):
=sum(I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9-small((I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9),{1,2}))
This is not working correctly, assume that the the values in the designated
cells are the following values:0, 11, 9, 9, 15; the value that is computed is
50. The only thing that seems to be consistent is that the last value is
added in again then the two smallest values are subtracted. I tried on
several sets of values and it was always coming up the same way, if I add the
last value in then subtract the two lowest values it matches what Excel
computes. Obviously I am doing something wrong but what?

All comments, and suggestions are welcome and appreciated.

Hi

Try
=SUM(I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9)-SMALL((I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9),1)-SMALL((I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9),2)

--


XL2003
Regards

William



"Weekend user" wrote in message
...
Ok, A few weeks ago I asked for help in finding the smallest two numbers
in a
group of numbers that were added together in order to reduce the total by
the
smallest numbers. the form that was suggested was(using my cell
locations):
=sum(I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9-small((I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9),{1,2}))
This is not working correctly, assume that the the values in the
designated
cells are the following values:0, 11, 9, 9, 15; the value that is computed
is
50. The only thing that seems to be consistent is that the last value is
added in again then the two smallest values are subtracted. I tried on
several sets of values and it was always coming up the same way, if I add
the
last value in then subtract the two lowest values it matches what Excel
computes. Obviously I am doing something wrong but what?

All comments, and suggestions are welcome and appreciated.

Another way:

=SUM(I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9)-SUM(SMALL((I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9),{1,2}))

Biff

"William" wrote in message
...
Hi

Try
=SUM(I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9)-SMALL((I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9),1)-SMALL((I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9),2)

--


XL2003
Regards

William



"Weekend user" wrote in message
...
Ok, A few weeks ago I asked for help in finding the smallest two numbers
in a
group of numbers that were added together in order to reduce the total by
the
smallest numbers. the form that was suggested was(using my cell
locations):
=sum(I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9-small((I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9),{1,2}))
This is not working correctly, assume that the the values in the
designated
cells are the following values:0, 11, 9, 9, 15; the value that is
computed
is
50. The only thing that seems to be consistent is that the last value is
added in again then the two smallest values are subtracted. I tried on
several sets of values and it was always coming up the same way, if I add
the
last value in then subtract the two lowest values it matches what Excel
computes. Obviously I am doing something wrong but what?

All comments, and suggestions are welcome and appreciated.

Or maybe even this:

=SUM(LARGE((I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9),{1,2,3}))

Biff

"Biff" wrote in message
...
Another way:

=SUM(I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9)-SUM(SMALL((I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9),{1,2}))

Biff

"William" wrote in message
...
Hi

Try
=SUM(I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9)-SMALL((I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9),1)-SMALL((I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9),2)

--


XL2003
Regards

William



"Weekend user" wrote in message
...
Ok, A few weeks ago I asked for help in finding the smallest two numbers
in a
group of numbers that were added together in order to reduce the total
by
the
smallest numbers. the form that was suggested was(using my cell
locations):
=sum(I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9-small((I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9),{1,2}))
This is not working correctly, assume that the the values in the
designated
cells are the following values:0, 11, 9, 9, 15; the value that is
computed
is
50. The only thing that seems to be consistent is that the last value
is
added in again then the two smallest values are subtracted. I tried on
several sets of values and it was always coming up the same way, if I
add
the
last value in then subtract the two lowest values it matches what Excel
computes. Obviously I am doing something wrong but what?

All comments, and suggestions are welcome and appreciated.

"Weekend user" wrote...
Ok, A few weeks ago I asked for help in finding the smallest two numbers
in a group of numbers that were added together in order to reduce the
total by the smallest numbers. the form that was suggested was(using my
cell locations):
=sum(I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9-small((I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9),{1,2}))
....

The reason this doesn't work is because you're subtracting an array from the
single cell Y9, which effectively double-counts Y9 in the sum. With I9=0,
L9=11, R9=9, V9=9 and Y9=15, your sum becomes

SUM(0,11,9,9,15-{0,9}) = SUM(0,11,9,9,{15,6}) = SUM(0,11,9,9,15,6) = 50

Try

=SUM((I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9),-SMALL((I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9),{1,2}))

On Sun, 15 May 2005 20:28:01 -0700, Weekend user
wrote:

Ok, A few weeks ago I asked for help in finding the smallest two numbers in a
group of numbers that were added together in order to reduce the total by the
smallest numbers. the form that was suggested was(using my cell locations):
=sum(I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9-small((I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9),{1,2}))
This is not working correctly, assume that the the values in the designated
cells are the following values:0, 11, 9, 9, 15; the value that is computed is
50. The only thing that seems to be consistent is that the last value is
added in again then the two smallest values are subtracted. I tried on
several sets of values and it was always coming up the same way, if I add the
last value in then subtract the two lowest values it matches what Excel
computes. Obviously I am doing something wrong but what?

All comments, and suggestions are welcome and appreciated.

It's close. But if you use the Evaluate Formula button (Tools/Formula
Auditing/Evaluate Formula) you will see that your formula is not doing what you
expect.

Try this slight modification, instead:

=SUM(I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9)-SUM(SMALL((I9,L9,R9,V9,Y9),{1,2}))


--ron