Excel bug?
 

I've been trying to narrow down a problem we've been experiencing with Excel,
and one of my colleagues has sent me the message included below. Are
microsoft aware of this? And - triumph of hope over experience here - is
there any chance of MS fixing this if they do?

-----

I think Ive just moved this fault from us to Excel, which doesnt help the
user much but means theres not much point us spending more time on this.

I can create a crash in Excel 2002 SP3 on Win XP SP3 as follows:

· Create a new workbook with three sheets.
· On Sheet2, name any cell prop_recharge.
· On Sheet1, enter +prop_recharge in any cell.
· Open Visual Basic editor.
· Make Sheet2 very hidden.
· Save the workbook.

I then get the same crash we were getting with the other files.

If I do the same thing with the name proparecharge Excel doesnt crash.

Excel bug?
 

I cannot duplicate your problem with Excel 2002 SP3

Charles
___________________________________
The Excel Calculation Site
http://www.decisionmodels.com

"PatrickS" <msdn_newsgroups001@_removetextplusunderscores_seu rre.com. wrote
in message ...
I've been trying to narrow down a problem we've been experiencing with
Excel,
and one of my colleagues has sent me the message included below. Are
microsoft aware of this? And - triumph of hope over experience here - is
there any chance of MS fixing this if they do?

-----

I think I've just moved this fault from us to Excel, which doesn't help
the
user much but means there's not much point us spending more time on this.

I can create a crash in Excel 2002 SP3 on Win XP SP3 as follows:

· Create a new workbook with three sheets.
· On Sheet2, name any cell prop_recharge.
· On Sheet1, enter +prop_recharge in any cell.
· Open Visual Basic editor.
· Make Sheet2 very hidden.
· Save the workbook.

I then get the same crash we were getting with the other files.

If I do the same thing with the name proparecharge Excel doesn't crash.

Excel bug?
 

PatrickS,

I do not receive this error either.

Are you/your team using any addins or COM addins? Perhaps that is the
source of the issue?

--
Thx
MSweetG222



"PatrickS" wrote:

I've been trying to narrow down a problem we've been experiencing with Excel,
and one of my colleagues has sent me the message included below. Are
microsoft aware of this? And - triumph of hope over experience here - is
there any chance of MS fixing this if they do?

-----

I think Ive just moved this fault from us to Excel, which doesnt help the
user much but means theres not much point us spending more time on this.

I can create a crash in Excel 2002 SP3 on Win XP SP3 as follows:

· Create a new workbook with three sheets.
· On Sheet2, name any cell prop_recharge.
· On Sheet1, enter +prop_recharge in any cell.
· Open Visual Basic editor.
· Make Sheet2 very hidden.
· Save the workbook.

I then get the same crash we were getting with the other files.

If I do the same thing with the name proparecharge Excel doesnt crash.