Evaluate (Variable Function Name)?
 

It's probably not possible, but I wonder if I can build a generic sub that
builds a function name at runtime using Evaluate (or another method)?

For example, I have a function CalcRSI which works fine.

CalcRSI(DataSeries as single, Periods as integer) as Variant

I have other functions CalcSMA, CalcEMA, CalcWhatever that take the same
arguments. Rather than explicitly call each one, separately, I would like to
build a generic sub that funnels all my functions (that use the same inputs).

So I'd like to replace
x = CalcRSI(same arguments)
y = CalcSMA(same arguments)
z= CalcEMA(same arguments)

with
strCalcName = "Calc" & strName

x = Evaluate(strCalcName & "(" & arg1 & "," & arg2 & ")" )

I have other reasons for wanting to simplify this process that are not
relevant here.

The above compiles ok, but at runtime, I get "Run-time error 13 Type
mismatch", at the x = Evaluate(...) line.

I guess Excel is telling me it can't be done, and yet, ... It really will
make a difference if I can do this, but I'm not optimistic.

Thanks in advance, and I won't shoot the messenger.

Evaluate (Variable Function Name)?
 

I forgot to mention that if I put everything inside the evaluate function
into a string variable, and then try Evaluate(strWholeExpression) then it
compiles, it runs, but just exits the sub (I presume out of disgust for my
technique) at this line without any error messages.

"Post Tenebras Lux" wrote:

It's probably not possible, but I wonder if I can build a generic sub that
builds a function name at runtime using Evaluate (or another method)?

For example, I have a function CalcRSI which works fine.

CalcRSI(DataSeries as single, Periods as integer) as Variant

I have other functions CalcSMA, CalcEMA, CalcWhatever that take the same
arguments. Rather than explicitly call each one, separately, I would like to
build a generic sub that funnels all my functions (that use the same inputs).

So I'd like to replace
x = CalcRSI(same arguments)
y = CalcSMA(same arguments)
z= CalcEMA(same arguments)

with
strCalcName = "Calc" & strName

x = Evaluate(strCalcName & "(" & arg1 & "," & arg2 & ")" )

I have other reasons for wanting to simplify this process that are not
relevant here.

The above compiles ok, but at runtime, I get "Run-time error 13 Type
mismatch", at the x = Evaluate(...) line.

I guess Excel is telling me it can't be done, and yet, ... It really will
make a difference if I can do this, but I'm not optimistic.

Thanks in advance, and I won't shoot the messenger.

Evaluate (Variable Function Name)?
 

Following code works by me:

HTH
--
AP

'----------------------------------
Option Explicit

Function CalcRSI(DataSeries As Single, Periods As Integer) As Variant
CalcRSI = DataSeries * Periods
End Function

Sub tester()
Const strName = "RSI"
Dim strCalcName As String
Dim x As Long
Dim arg1 As Single
Dim arg2 As Integer

strCalcName = "Calc" & strName
arg1 = 3
arg2 = 4
x = Evaluate(strCalcName & "(" & arg1 & "," & arg2 & ")")
MsgBox x

End Sub
'-------------------------------------

"Post Tenebras Lux" a écrit dans
le message de news: ...
I forgot to mention that if I put everything inside the evaluate function
into a string variable, and then try Evaluate(strWholeExpression) then it
compiles, it runs, but just exits the sub (I presume out of disgust for my
technique) at this line without any error messages.

"Post Tenebras Lux" wrote:

It's probably not possible, but I wonder if I can build a generic sub
that
builds a function name at runtime using Evaluate (or another method)?

For example, I have a function CalcRSI which works fine.

CalcRSI(DataSeries as single, Periods as integer) as Variant

I have other functions CalcSMA, CalcEMA, CalcWhatever that take the same
arguments. Rather than explicitly call each one, separately, I would
like to
build a generic sub that funnels all my functions (that use the same
inputs).

So I'd like to replace
x = CalcRSI(same arguments)
y = CalcSMA(same arguments)
z= CalcEMA(same arguments)

with
strCalcName = "Calc" & strName

x = Evaluate(strCalcName & "(" & arg1 & "," & arg2 & ")" )

I have other reasons for wanting to simplify this process that are not
relevant here.

The above compiles ok, but at runtime, I get "Run-time error 13 Type
mismatch", at the x = Evaluate(...) line.

I guess Excel is telling me it can't be done, and yet, ... It really
will
make a difference if I can do this, but I'm not optimistic.

Thanks in advance, and I won't shoot the messenger.

Evaluate (Variable Function Name)?
 

Would any ideas here help?

Sub Demo()
Dim arg
Dim j

arg = 5
For j = 1 To 2
Run "MyProc" & j, arg + j
Next j
End Sub

Sub MyProc1(k)
MsgBox "Here with " & k
End Sub

Sub MyProc2(k)
MsgBox "In Procedure 2 with " & k
End Sub

--
HTH. :)
Dana DeLouis
Windows XP, Office 2003


"Post Tenebras Lux" wrote in
message ...
I forgot to mention that if I put everything inside the evaluate function
into a string variable, and then try Evaluate(strWholeExpression) then it
compiles, it runs, but just exits the sub (I presume out of disgust for my
technique) at this line without any error messages.

"Post Tenebras Lux" wrote:

It's probably not possible, but I wonder if I can build a generic sub
that
builds a function name at runtime using Evaluate (or another method)?

For example, I have a function CalcRSI which works fine.

CalcRSI(DataSeries as single, Periods as integer) as Variant

I have other functions CalcSMA, CalcEMA, CalcWhatever that take the same
arguments. Rather than explicitly call each one, separately, I would
like to
build a generic sub that funnels all my functions (that use the same
inputs).

So I'd like to replace
x = CalcRSI(same arguments)
y = CalcSMA(same arguments)
z= CalcEMA(same arguments)

with
strCalcName = "Calc" & strName

x = Evaluate(strCalcName & "(" & arg1 & "," & arg2 & ")" )

I have other reasons for wanting to simplify this process that are not
relevant here.

The above compiles ok, but at runtime, I get "Run-time error 13 Type
mismatch", at the x = Evaluate(...) line.

I guess Excel is telling me it can't be done, and yet, ... It really
will
make a difference if I can do this, but I'm not optimistic.

Thanks in advance, and I won't shoot the messenger.

Evaluate (Variable Function Name)?
 

Thanks. It works great until you change
DataSeries as single
to DataSeries() as single.

My error in the initial explanation: it doesn't seem able to pass an array,
only single value arguments.

Any more thoughts?

"Ardus Petus" wrote:

Following code works by me:

HTH
--
AP

'----------------------------------
Option Explicit

Function CalcRSI(DataSeries As Single, Periods As Integer) As Variant
CalcRSI = DataSeries * Periods
End Function

Sub tester()
Const strName = "RSI"
Dim strCalcName As String
Dim x As Long
Dim arg1 As Single
Dim arg2 As Integer

strCalcName = "Calc" & strName
arg1 = 3
arg2 = 4
x = Evaluate(strCalcName & "(" & arg1 & "," & arg2 & ")")
MsgBox x

End Sub
'-------------------------------------

"Post Tenebras Lux" a écrit dans
le message de news: ...
I forgot to mention that if I put everything inside the evaluate function
into a string variable, and then try Evaluate(strWholeExpression) then it
compiles, it runs, but just exits the sub (I presume out of disgust for my
technique) at this line without any error messages.

"Post Tenebras Lux" wrote:

It's probably not possible, but I wonder if I can build a generic sub
that
builds a function name at runtime using Evaluate (or another method)?

For example, I have a function CalcRSI which works fine.

CalcRSI(DataSeries as single, Periods as integer) as Variant

I have other functions CalcSMA, CalcEMA, CalcWhatever that take the same
arguments. Rather than explicitly call each one, separately, I would
like to
build a generic sub that funnels all my functions (that use the same
inputs).

So I'd like to replace
x = CalcRSI(same arguments)
y = CalcSMA(same arguments)
z= CalcEMA(same arguments)

with
strCalcName = "Calc" & strName

x = Evaluate(strCalcName & "(" & arg1 & "," & arg2 & ")" )

I have other reasons for wanting to simplify this process that are not
relevant here.

The above compiles ok, but at runtime, I get "Run-time error 13 Type
mismatch", at the x = Evaluate(...) line.

I guess Excel is telling me it can't be done, and yet, ... It really
will
make a difference if I can do this, but I'm not optimistic.

Thanks in advance, and I won't shoot the messenger.

Evaluate (Variable Function Name)?
 

ALL HAIL DANA! Changing to a sub from a function allowed the variable
procedure name, and for it to pass an array.

Very grateful, I am.



"Dana DeLouis" wrote:

Would any ideas here help?

Sub Demo()
Dim arg
Dim j

arg = 5
For j = 1 To 2
Run "MyProc" & j, arg + j
Next j
End Sub

Sub MyProc1(k)
MsgBox "Here with " & k
End Sub

Sub MyProc2(k)
MsgBox "In Procedure 2 with " & k
End Sub

--
HTH. :)
Dana DeLouis
Windows XP, Office 2003


"Post Tenebras Lux" wrote in
message ...
I forgot to mention that if I put everything inside the evaluate function
into a string variable, and then try Evaluate(strWholeExpression) then it
compiles, it runs, but just exits the sub (I presume out of disgust for my
technique) at this line without any error messages.

"Post Tenebras Lux" wrote:

It's probably not possible, but I wonder if I can build a generic sub
that
builds a function name at runtime using Evaluate (or another method)?

For example, I have a function CalcRSI which works fine.

CalcRSI(DataSeries as single, Periods as integer) as Variant

I have other functions CalcSMA, CalcEMA, CalcWhatever that take the same
arguments. Rather than explicitly call each one, separately, I would
like to
build a generic sub that funnels all my functions (that use the same
inputs).

So I'd like to replace
x = CalcRSI(same arguments)
y = CalcSMA(same arguments)
z= CalcEMA(same arguments)

with
strCalcName = "Calc" & strName

x = Evaluate(strCalcName & "(" & arg1 & "," & arg2 & ")" )

I have other reasons for wanting to simplify this process that are not
relevant here.

The above compiles ok, but at runtime, I get "Run-time error 13 Type
mismatch", at the x = Evaluate(...) line.

I guess Excel is telling me it can't be done, and yet, ... It really
will
make a difference if I can do this, but I'm not optimistic.

Thanks in advance, and I won't shoot the messenger.

Evaluate (Variable Function Name)?
 

...Changing to a sub from a function allowed the variable

Hi. Glad that idea gave you something to work with.
Note that Functions are allowed if one uses ( ), as in this simple example.

Sub Demo2()
MsgBox Run("Norm", 3, 4)
End Sub

Function Norm(x, y)
Norm = Sqr(x ^ 2 + y ^ 2)
End Function

--
HTH. :)
Dana DeLouis
Windows XP, Office 2003


"Post Tenebras Lux" wrote in
message ...
ALL HAIL DANA! Changing to a sub from a function allowed the variable
procedure name, and for it to pass an array.

Very grateful, I am.



"Dana DeLouis" wrote:

Would any ideas here help?

Sub Demo()
Dim arg
Dim j

arg = 5
For j = 1 To 2
Run "MyProc" & j, arg + j
Next j
End Sub

Sub MyProc1(k)
MsgBox "Here with " & k
End Sub

Sub MyProc2(k)
MsgBox "In Procedure 2 with " & k
End Sub

--
HTH. :)
Dana DeLouis
Windows XP, Office 2003


"Post Tenebras Lux" wrote in
message ...
I forgot to mention that if I put everything inside the evaluate
function
into a string variable, and then try Evaluate(strWholeExpression) then
it
compiles, it runs, but just exits the sub (I presume out of disgust for
my
technique) at this line without any error messages.

"Post Tenebras Lux" wrote:

It's probably not possible, but I wonder if I can build a generic sub
that
builds a function name at runtime using Evaluate (or another method)?

For example, I have a function CalcRSI which works fine.

CalcRSI(DataSeries as single, Periods as integer) as Variant

I have other functions CalcSMA, CalcEMA, CalcWhatever that take the
same
arguments. Rather than explicitly call each one, separately, I would
like to
build a generic sub that funnels all my functions (that use the same
inputs).

So I'd like to replace
x = CalcRSI(same arguments)
y = CalcSMA(same arguments)
z= CalcEMA(same arguments)

with
strCalcName = "Calc" & strName

x = Evaluate(strCalcName & "(" & arg1 & "," & arg2 &
")" )

I have other reasons for wanting to simplify this process that are not
relevant here.

The above compiles ok, but at runtime, I get "Run-time error 13 Type
mismatch", at the x = Evaluate(...) line.

I guess Excel is telling me it can't be done, and yet, ... It really
will
make a difference if I can do this, but I'm not optimistic.

Thanks in advance, and I won't shoot the messenger.

Evaluate (Variable Function Name)?
 

Keeps getting better!

"Dana DeLouis" wrote:

...Changing to a sub from a function allowed the variable

Hi. Glad that idea gave you something to work with.
Note that Functions are allowed if one uses ( ), as in this simple example.

Sub Demo2()
MsgBox Run("Norm", 3, 4)
End Sub

Function Norm(x, y)
Norm = Sqr(x ^ 2 + y ^ 2)
End Function

--
HTH. :)
Dana DeLouis
Windows XP, Office 2003


"Post Tenebras Lux" wrote in
message ...
ALL HAIL DANA! Changing to a sub from a function allowed the variable
procedure name, and for it to pass an array.

Very grateful, I am.



"Dana DeLouis" wrote:

Would any ideas here help?

Sub Demo()
Dim arg
Dim j

arg = 5
For j = 1 To 2
Run "MyProc" & j, arg + j
Next j
End Sub

Sub MyProc1(k)
MsgBox "Here with " & k
End Sub

Sub MyProc2(k)
MsgBox "In Procedure 2 with " & k
End Sub

--
HTH. :)
Dana DeLouis
Windows XP, Office 2003


"Post Tenebras Lux" wrote in
message ...
I forgot to mention that if I put everything inside the evaluate
function
into a string variable, and then try Evaluate(strWholeExpression) then
it
compiles, it runs, but just exits the sub (I presume out of disgust for
my
technique) at this line without any error messages.

"Post Tenebras Lux" wrote:

It's probably not possible, but I wonder if I can build a generic sub
that
builds a function name at runtime using Evaluate (or another method)?

For example, I have a function CalcRSI which works fine.

CalcRSI(DataSeries as single, Periods as integer) as Variant

I have other functions CalcSMA, CalcEMA, CalcWhatever that take the
same
arguments. Rather than explicitly call each one, separately, I would
like to
build a generic sub that funnels all my functions (that use the same
inputs).

So I'd like to replace
x = CalcRSI(same arguments)
y = CalcSMA(same arguments)
z= CalcEMA(same arguments)

with
strCalcName = "Calc" & strName

x = Evaluate(strCalcName & "(" & arg1 & "," & arg2 &
")" )

I have other reasons for wanting to simplify this process that are not
relevant here.

The above compiles ok, but at runtime, I get "Run-time error 13 Type
mismatch", at the x = Evaluate(...) line.

I guess Excel is telling me it can't be done, and yet, ... It really
will
make a difference if I can do this, but I'm not optimistic.

Thanks in advance, and I won't shoot the messenger.