workbook.open throws 1004 error
 

Here is the entire application which generates the error:

Sub bob2()
Dim owb As Workbook
Set owb = Workbooks.Open("C:\temp\test-import-data.xls")
End Sub

Can't get much more stripped down than that. I can open
test-import-data.xml just fine in Excel but when I execute this functon
I get 1004 "Application-defined or object-defined error". The file is
created via an output from Siebel. But it is in Excel format. We are
using Excel 2003.

Any ideas?

If I open up the excel document it will automatically close it when I
call the open and still throw the errors.

workbook.open throws 1004 error
 

Are you sure your file is O.K.?

I copied your path, filename, and code and it worked on my machine (Win-XP,
Excel-XP)

So your code (probably) is not buggy.
--
Gary's Student


" wrote:

Here is the entire application which generates the error:

Sub bob2()
Dim owb As Workbook
Set owb = Workbooks.Open("C:\temp\test-import-data.xls")
End Sub

Can't get much more stripped down than that. I can open
test-import-data.xml just fine in Excel but when I execute this functon
I get 1004 "Application-defined or object-defined error". The file is
created via an output from Siebel. But it is in Excel format. We are
using Excel 2003.

Any ideas?

If I open up the excel document it will automatically close it when I
call the open and still throw the errors.

workbook.open throws 1004 error
 

..xls or .xml ?
--
Jim Cone
San Francisco, USA
http://www.realezsites.com/bus/primitivesoftware



wrote in message
Here is the entire application which generates the error:

Sub bob2()
Dim owb As Workbook
Set owb = Workbooks.Open("C:\temp\test-import-data.xls")
End Sub

Can't get much more stripped down than that. I can open
test-import-data.xml just fine in Excel but when I execute this functon
I get 1004 "Application-defined or object-defined error". The file is
created via an output from Siebel. But it is in Excel format. We are
using Excel 2003.
Any ideas?
If I open up the excel document it will automatically close it when I
call the open and still throw the errors.

workbook.open throws 1004 error
 

No, the file isn't okay :). The export from Siebel has a sheetname of
..csv)output(1). This seemed okay at first as there is nothing super
special about this sheetname (though it is bad to begin with). Looking
deeper we found that the actual sheetname was .csv]output(1). Excel
seems to be too smart for it's own good and displays a fixed version of
the name but saving the file kept the "]" in the sheetname.

We edited the binary, changed ] to ) and it loaded. Magic... Well,
the problem is Seibel still exports the wrong thing and I doubt I will
get our developers to fix this.

Our next step is to write a piece of code to always open the file and
edit the binary before importing the data. It's dirty work, and by far
the wrong approach, but it's the best we have unless someone else has
some additional ideas.