Shell command ignores parameters
 

Hello to all Excel fundiesRecently (8th February) I asked the question shown
below. However, I received no responses. (It is possible that I missed the
response(s))Is it possibly because the question was rather vague or is the
jury still 'out to lunch' on this one?"Hi all

I wrote an Excel VBA program to run (Shells to) a DOS program (not mine)
which deals bridge hands called "Big Deal"
It takes certain parameters such as the number of hands required, the name
of the output file and the type (e.g. CSV)

This all worked perfectly under Excel 2000 (Windows 98)
I have now converted/upgraded to Windows XP Home and Excel 2003 and have now
found that the parameters (NoOfHands and Hands, etc) are ignored and have
to be (re)typed at run time

Why is this? Has there been a change in the Shell command under Windows XP
or is the problem with Excel 2003?

The lines I use (which worked under the old setup) are list below:

Dim NoOfHands As Integer
(Note: the input control routine for NoOfHands has, for brevity, been
omitted)
Program = "C:\Simultaneous Tournament\Unlimited\Bigdeal\bigdeal -n " &
NoOfHands & " -p Hands -f csv"
TaskID = Shell(Program, vbNormalFocus)

Peter Bircher
South Africa"

Shell command ignores parameters
 

With no testing at all:

maybe wrap your program name in double quotes:

TaskID = Shell(chr(34) & Program & chr(34), vbNormalFocus)

If I were testing this, I'd either shell to DOS and try to get it working
there--then match that syntax or do the same thing via Windows start button|Run
dialog.



Pete wrote:

Hello to all Excel fundiesRecently (8th February) I asked the question shown
below. However, I received no responses. (It is possible that I missed the
response(s))Is it possibly because the question was rather vague or is the
jury still 'out to lunch' on this one?"Hi all

I wrote an Excel VBA program to run (Shells to) a DOS program (not mine)
which deals bridge hands called "Big Deal"
It takes certain parameters such as the number of hands required, the name
of the output file and the type (e.g. CSV)

This all worked perfectly under Excel 2000 (Windows 98)
I have now converted/upgraded to Windows XP Home and Excel 2003 and have now
found that the parameters (NoOfHands and Hands, etc) are ignored and have
to be (re)typed at run time

Why is this? Has there been a change in the Shell command under Windows XP
or is the problem with Excel 2003?

The lines I use (which worked under the old setup) are list below:

Dim NoOfHands As Integer
(Note: the input control routine for NoOfHands has, for brevity, been
omitted)
Program = "C:\Simultaneous Tournament\Unlimited\Bigdeal\bigdeal -n " &
NoOfHands & " -p Hands -f csv"
TaskID = Shell(Program, vbNormalFocus)

Peter Bircher
South Africa"

--

Dave Peterson

Shell command ignores parameters
 

Thanks Dave
Will try that.
Peter Bircher

"Dave Peterson" wrote in message
...
With no testing at all:

maybe wrap your program name in double quotes:

TaskID = Shell(chr(34) & Program & chr(34), vbNormalFocus)

If I were testing this, I'd either shell to DOS and try to get it working
there--then match that syntax or do the same thing via Windows start
button|Run
dialog.



Pete wrote:

Hello to all Excel fundiesRecently (8th February) I asked the question
shown
below. However, I received no responses. (It is possible that I missed
the
response(s))Is it possibly because the question was rather vague or is
the
jury still 'out to lunch' on this one?"Hi all

I wrote an Excel VBA program to run (Shells to) a DOS program (not mine)
which deals bridge hands called "Big Deal"
It takes certain parameters such as the number of hands required, the
name
of the output file and the type (e.g. CSV)

This all worked perfectly under Excel 2000 (Windows 98)
I have now converted/upgraded to Windows XP Home and Excel 2003 and have
now
found that the parameters (NoOfHands and Hands, etc) are ignored and
have
to be (re)typed at run time

Why is this? Has there been a change in the Shell command under Windows
XP
or is the problem with Excel 2003?

The lines I use (which worked under the old setup) are list below:

Dim NoOfHands As Integer
(Note: the input control routine for NoOfHands has, for brevity, been
omitted)
Program = "C:\Simultaneous Tournament\Unlimited\Bigdeal\bigdeal -n " &
NoOfHands & " -p Hands -f csv"
TaskID = Shell(Program, vbNormalFocus)

Peter Bircher
South Africa"

--

Dave Peterson