ExcelBanter

ExcelBanter (https://www.excelbanter.com/)
-   Excel Discussion (Misc queries) (https://www.excelbanter.com/excel-discussion-misc-queries/)
-   -   Pmt formula returns incorrect answer (https://www.excelbanter.com/excel-discussion-misc-queries/190203-pmt-formula-returns-incorrect-answer.html)

Heinz

Pmt formula returns incorrect answer
 
=PMT(.05,360,260000) result is (13,000.00) Why?

sb1920alk

Pmt formula returns incorrect answer
 
You don't have the right number of zeros. Try =PMT(0.005,360,260000,0) (gives
($1,558.83)) if you want 6% per year (6/100/12 = 0.005). The negative sign is
normal. Think of it as "opposite" since the original balance and the payments
represent money flowing in "opposite" directions. If you want the answer to
be positive, use =PMT(0.005,360,-260000,0) or =-PMT(0.005,360,260000,0), etc.

"Heinz" wrote:

=PMT(.05,360,260000) result is (13,000.00) Why?


joeu2004

Pmt formula returns incorrect answer
 
On Jun 5, 1:13*pm, Heinz wrote:
=PMT(.05,360,260000) result is (13,000.00) Why?


I don't know, since you did not indicate what the expected result is.

If ".05" is an annual rate of 5%, and "360" is the number of months,
you want .05/12 as the first argument, not .05. By the way, you can
write it as 5%/12, if you find that more readable. (I do.)

If the negative result concerns you, you can avoid it by writing
-260000 instead of 260000.

In Excel (and many financial tools), "in" and "out" cash flows must
have opposite signs. But the sign that you choose for "in" is
arbitrary. (A borrower sees the loan amount as a positive inflow,
whereas the lender sees it as a negative outflow. You pretend to be
either.)

Of course, you could also write -PMT(.05,360,260000). As I said, it
is completely arbitrary -- whatever your personal preference is.

But when you have pmt, PV and FV in the same function call, you will
have to obey the rule about opposite signs. This is true for IRR and
XIRR as well. So IMHO, you might as well get used to it.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:58 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
ExcelBanter.com