ExcelBanter

ExcelBanter (https://www.excelbanter.com/)
-   Excel Discussion (Misc queries) (https://www.excelbanter.com/excel-discussion-misc-queries/)
-   -   Index vs % (https://www.excelbanter.com/excel-discussion-misc-queries/180173-index-vs-%25.html)

[email protected]

Index vs %
 
What's the difference between an index and percentage growth/decline?

Example: Last year's volume was 158 vs 2006's volume of 97. If I
divide 158 / 97 I get 162.9. Isn't that the same as 62.9%? Why would I
use one over the other and if I decide I don't want it to read 162.9,
just 62.9, how do I get that to happen?

Thanks.

David Biddulph[_2_]

Index vs %
 
-1 or -100%
--
David Biddulph

wrote in message
...
What's the difference between an index and percentage growth/decline?

Example: Last year's volume was 158 vs 2006's volume of 97. If I
divide 158 / 97 I get 162.9. Isn't that the same as 62.9%? Why would I
use one over the other and if I decide I don't want it to read 162.9,
just 62.9, how do I get that to happen?

Thanks.




joeu2004

Index vs %
 
On Mar 15, 7:00*am, " wrote:
What's the difference between an index and percentage growth/decline?


It is largely semantics. But it affects how you use each number in
formulas


Example: Last year's volume was 158 vs 2006's volume of 97. If I
divide 158 / 97 I get 162.9.


No, you get 1.629 (rounded). Apparently, you chose to multiply by 100
to get your index. That is an arbitrary choice, albeit a common one.


Isn't that the same as 62.9%?


Well, 62.9% is derived from that. Specifically, 158/97 - 1, formatted
as Percentage.


Why would I use one over the other


Percentage growth can be negative as well as positive; some people
have trouble dealing with that. For example, if the 2007 volume had
been 36, you would have a "growth" of -62.9% (rounded). Of course, we
say "loss", not "growth". When growth goes from 63% to 126%, it
doubled; similarly when loss goes from -63% to -126%. But what if the
loss goes from -63% to 63%? (Rhetorical.)

In contrast, an index is never negative, at least when we are talking
about volume and other counting numbers that cannot themselves be
negative.


and if I decide I don't want it to read 162.9,
just 62.9, how do I get that to happen?


Just as the index was computed by 100*(158/97), you could compute the
"percentage" by 100*(158/97 - 1).

But I prefer to use 158/97 - 1, and format it as percentage.
Otherwise, you always have to remember to divide the "percentage"
figure by 100 when you use it aritmetic formulas.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 04:00 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
ExcelBanter.com