Excel 2002 - How to keep the formulas unchanged ?
 

Dear Sir,

May I know how to keep the formula in a cell at its stationary position when
the other cell is moved ?

Lets consider the folowing worksheet example:

A B C D
1 = C1-B1
2 = C2-B2
3 = C3-B3
4

Formula =(C1-B1) is entered cell A1, however when cell C1 is cut and moved
to position C2, the formula in cell A1 now becomes = (C2-B1).

Is there a way to keep the formula in column A remain unchanged even if
column C is moved out from its original position (i.e. up, down, lefft or
right) ?


Thanks

Low


--
A36B58K641

Excel 2002 - How to keep the formulas unchanged ?
 

Try this format:
=$C$1-$B$1

Regards,
Stefi

"Mr. Low" wrote:

Dear Sir,

May I know how to keep the formula in a cell at its stationary position when
the other cell is moved ?

Lets consider the folowing worksheet example:

A B C D
1 = C1-B1
2 = C2-B2
3 = C3-B3
4

Formula =(C1-B1) is entered cell A1, however when cell C1 is cut and moved
to position C2, the formula in cell A1 now becomes = (C2-B1).

Is there a way to keep the formula in column A remain unchanged even if
column C is moved out from its original position (i.e. up, down, lefft or
right) ?


Thanks

Low


--
A36B58K641

Excel 2002 - How to keep the formulas unchanged ?
 

try
= indirect("C1")-indrect("B1")

"Mr. Low" wrote:

Dear Sir,

May I know how to keep the formula in a cell at its stationary position when
the other cell is moved ?

Lets consider the folowing worksheet example:

A B C D
1 = C1-B1
2 = C2-B2
3 = C3-B3
4

Formula =(C1-B1) is entered cell A1, however when cell C1 is cut and moved
to position C2, the formula in cell A1 now becomes = (C2-B1).

Is there a way to keep the formula in column A remain unchanged even if
column C is moved out from its original position (i.e. up, down, lefft or
right) ?


Thanks

Low


--
A36B58K641

Excel 2002 - How to keep the formulas unchanged ?
 

Dear BJ,

I tried to key in the formula manually, it works.

However in real work situation, I have sometime up to 5000 cells need to
have this formula, copying the formula from the first cell to the others is
not working as the cell address within the foumula does not change.

Eg. =INDIRECT("B4")-INDIRECT("C4") wiull remain the same when it is copied
downwards. Is there anyway to overcome this problem ?


Thanks

Low

--
A36B58K641


"bj" wrote:

try
= indirect("C1")-indrect("B1")

"Mr. Low" wrote:

Dear Sir,

May I know how to keep the formula in a cell at its stationary position when
the other cell is moved ?

Lets consider the folowing worksheet example:

A B C D
1 = C1-B1
2 = C2-B2
3 = C3-B3
4

Formula =(C1-B1) is entered cell A1, however when cell C1 is cut and moved
to position C2, the formula in cell A1 now becomes = (C2-B1).

Is there a way to keep the formula in column A remain unchanged even if
column C is moved out from its original position (i.e. up, down, lefft or
right) ?


Thanks

Low


--
A36B58K641

Excel 2002 - How to keep the formulas unchanged ?
 

Hello Stefi,

Thanks for your info.

However it does not work as formula $C$1-$B$1 becomes $C$1-$B$2 when cell BI
is moved on row down. Is there any other ways


Kind Regards

Low

--
A36B58K641


"Stefi" wrote:

Try this format:
=$C$1-$B$1

Regards,
Stefi

"Mr. Low" wrote:

Dear Sir,

May I know how to keep the formula in a cell at its stationary position when
the other cell is moved ?

Lets consider the folowing worksheet example:

A B C D
1 = C1-B1
2 = C2-B2
3 = C3-B3
4

Formula =(C1-B1) is entered cell A1, however when cell C1 is cut and moved
to position C2, the formula in cell A1 now becomes = (C2-B1).

Is there a way to keep the formula in column A remain unchanged even if
column C is moved out from its original position (i.e. up, down, lefft or
right) ?


Thanks

Low


--
A36B58K641

Excel 2002 - How to keep the formulas unchanged ?
 

Try this:

=INDIRECT("C"&ROWS($1:1))-INDIRECT("B"&ROWS($1:1))

--

HTH,

RD
================================================== ===
Please keep all correspondence within the Group, so all may benefit!
================================================== ===

"Mr. Low" wrote in message
...
Dear BJ,

I tried to key in the formula manually, it works.

However in real work situation, I have sometime up to 5000 cells need to
have this formula, copying the formula from the first cell to the others is
not working as the cell address within the foumula does not change.

Eg. =INDIRECT("B4")-INDIRECT("C4") wiull remain the same when it is copied
downwards. Is there anyway to overcome this problem ?


Thanks

Low

--
A36B58K641


"bj" wrote:

try
= indirect("C1")-indrect("B1")

"Mr. Low" wrote:

Dear Sir,

May I know how to keep the formula in a cell at its stationary position
when
the other cell is moved ?

Lets consider the folowing worksheet example:

A B C D
1 = C1-B1
2 = C2-B2
3 = C3-B3
4

Formula =(C1-B1) is entered cell A1, however when cell C1 is cut and
moved
to position C2, the formula in cell A1 now becomes = (C2-B1).

Is there a way to keep the formula in column A remain unchanged even
if
column C is moved out from its original position (i.e. up, down, lefft
or
right) ?


Thanks

Low


--
A36B58K641

Excel 2002 - How to keep the formulas unchanged ?
 

Try this:

A1: =OFFSET(A1,0,2)-OFFSET(A1,0,1)
Copy down as far as you need

That formula is durable against either the Col_B or the Col_C cells moving
(or both).

Does that help?
***********
Regards,
Ron

XL2002, WinXP


"Mr. Low" wrote:

Dear Sir,

May I know how to keep the formula in a cell at its stationary position when
the other cell is moved ?

Lets consider the folowing worksheet example:

A B C D
1 = C1-B1
2 = C2-B2
3 = C3-B3
4

Formula =(C1-B1) is entered cell A1, however when cell C1 is cut and moved
to position C2, the formula in cell A1 now becomes = (C2-B1).

Is there a way to keep the formula in column A remain unchanged even if
column C is moved out from its original position (i.e. up, down, lefft or
right) ?


Thanks

Low


--
A36B58K641

Excel 2002 - How to keep the formulas unchanged ?
 

Hello Ron,

This is a great formula, It works very well irrespective of the cell
positions (rows ande column)

Many Thanks

Low

--
A36B58K641


"Ron Coderre" wrote:

Try this:

A1: =OFFSET(A1,0,2)-OFFSET(A1,0,1)
Copy down as far as you need

That formula is durable against either the Col_B or the Col_C cells moving
(or both).

Does that help?
***********
Regards,
Ron

XL2002, WinXP


"Mr. Low" wrote:

Dear Sir,

May I know how to keep the formula in a cell at its stationary position when
the other cell is moved ?

Lets consider the folowing worksheet example:

A B C D
1 = C1-B1
2 = C2-B2
3 = C3-B3
4

Formula =(C1-B1) is entered cell A1, however when cell C1 is cut and moved
to position C2, the formula in cell A1 now becomes = (C2-B1).

Is there a way to keep the formula in column A remain unchanged even if
column C is moved out from its original position (i.e. up, down, lefft or
right) ?


Thanks

Low


--
A36B58K641

Excel 2002 - How to keep the formulas unchanged ?
 

Hello Rag,

It works well.

Many Thanks

Low

--
A36B58K641


"RagDyeR" wrote:

Try this:

=INDIRECT("C"&ROWS($1:1))-INDIRECT("B"&ROWS($1:1))

--

HTH,

RD
================================================== ===
Please keep all correspondence within the Group, so all may benefit!
================================================== ===

"Mr. Low" wrote in message
...
Dear BJ,

I tried to key in the formula manually, it works.

However in real work situation, I have sometime up to 5000 cells need to
have this formula, copying the formula from the first cell to the others is
not working as the cell address within the foumula does not change.

Eg. =INDIRECT("B4")-INDIRECT("C4") wiull remain the same when it is copied
downwards. Is there anyway to overcome this problem ?


Thanks

Low

--
A36B58K641


"bj" wrote:

try
= indirect("C1")-indrect("B1")

"Mr. Low" wrote:

Dear Sir,

May I know how to keep the formula in a cell at its stationary position
when
the other cell is moved ?

Lets consider the folowing worksheet example:

A B C D
1 = C1-B1
2 = C2-B2
3 = C3-B3
4

Formula =(C1-B1) is entered cell A1, however when cell C1 is cut and
moved
to position C2, the formula in cell A1 now becomes = (C2-B1).

Is there a way to keep the formula in column A remain unchanged even
if
column C is moved out from its original position (i.e. up, down, lefft
or
right) ?


Thanks

Low


--
A36B58K641

Excel 2002 - How to keep the formulas unchanged ?
 

Or for a non-volatile solution use a defined name e.g. =Diff by
choosing Insert Name Define Diff: =C2-B2

Mr. Low wrote:

Dear Sir,

May I know how to keep the formula in a cell at its stationary position when
the other cell is moved ?

Lets consider the folowing worksheet example:

A B C D
1 = C1-B1
2 = C2-B2
3 = C3-B3
4

Formula =(C1-B1) is entered cell A1, however when cell C1 is cut and moved
to position C2, the formula in cell A1 now becomes = (C2-B1).

Is there a way to keep the formula in column A remain unchanged even if
column C is moved out from its original position (i.e. up, down, lefft or
right) ?


Thanks

Low


--
A36B58K641