Thread: Bug or feature?
View Single Post
  #1   Report Post  
Posted to microsoft.public.excel.programming
Leo Mazzi Leo Mazzi is offline
external usenet poster
 
Posts: 1
Default Bug or feature?

I was wandering if this is a bug (so it will be fixed) or a feature (so I can
expect the same behavior in the following versions)...

Excel uses in many cell formulas the regional settings list separator
character to separate between parameters (example for GB the list separator
is "," so an IF formula would look as: "=IF(bool, true, false)" but when you
change the country to DE then the separator is ";" and you have to use the
formula in the way: "=IF(bool; true; false)".

Now this would not be a problem if Excel would not use the DEFAULT regional
configuration so if any user customizes his regional settings to have a
different separator than the default - Excel (tested with Excel 2003)
currently ignores it - so for example: the user selected in GB the ";" as a
separator - but Excel still thinks that the separator is ",".

Is this a BUG or a feature? Does anyone know about this?